Tony B.
Yelp
I am giving Nico's 2 stars because the food was good, not great, and the portions were on the small side. The overall experience was not particularly good and I will not be returning.
We went to celebrate a family birthday, all adults, so cocktails were definitely in order. Unfortunately, they were a disappointment. They did not have the basic ingredients for some of the drinks on their menu and when my mother settled on an old fashioned the server, who was also the bartender, told us it was her specialty and she was in for a treat. It was not very good at all, tasted like straight alcohol, in fact none of the other drinks were particularly good. A second round was not ordered :(
When it came time to order the meal, again, some items were not available. Including what the birthday boy was going to order. We had the Roasted Garlic appetizer which was very good, actually the best item of the day. I had the Jumbo Sea Scallops w/ risotto which was good but the 3 scallops weren't very jumbo. The Flat Iron Steak was also 'undersized' but tasty and the Bistro Burger was an average restaurant burger. Everything was good but not great and a little overpriced for what you get.
Dessert time... Did they offer the customary birthday scoop of ice cream? No. So, we were looking at the dessert menu and asked the server if they had affogato (vanilla ice cream w/ espresso poured over) she said yes that it was wonderful here and one of her personal favorites. Then in the next breath said "oh, no we don't have any espresso. We haven't seen the coffee guy in a while". We settled on a creme brulee and bread pudding for the table and called it a day.
The service was meh, the server/bartender was too friendly to some people at the table and ignored others. When complemented on her tattoos she pulled up her skirt to show the one on her upper thigh and she explained that one was the result of peer pressure. Just too much over share.
All in all, a disappointing experience.