Niko's Gyros

We are waiting for our food in the car because the tiny booths inside don't accommodate plus size people. Only extremely thin people could fit in these tiny, cramped booths. The seating is also very old and run down. This was our first and last time coming here. The food was only Ok, not great. The lettuce and tomatoes (which was most of the salad I got) was kind of wilted and not very fresh. And my partner couldn't even eat his. He said it tasted bad. It was a very expensive meal and we ate a few bites and threw it away. Very disappointing.

Great service, the food was made to order and came out in a very reasonable time. Portions were just right and it was recommended we try the cajen fries. Evething was extremely good, we planing in heading back again soon.

I ordered a gyro sandwich and a piece of Blaklava. The cook came out of the dining room without washing his hands to make my gyro. I asked was he even going to wash his hands, he got an attitude and the lady of the place made my gyro. It was plain asl, the pita wasn't even heated, the cucumber sauce was nasty. It was plain Greek yogurt. Oshkosh got some nasty places to eat

Pretty upset with them tonight. Husband went there to order food cause ordering online was not working. My husband order and they double charged up for several things when my husband let them know about it they would not reimburse the money for the food we did not order, they told us we had to reorder and wait almost 7 business days to get the other money refunded back to usand would have to reorder what we want. Like really 😒 Customer service has really dropped big time there...how can you screw up so bad for something online that was only going to cost us $80 charged us over $100. Then want us to get another charge for another order. I think not...Will NOT be going back there.

Please hire sober employees. Half of the staff seemed high. I even saw one vaping in the restaurant. They were generally rude and irritable. The food was oerpriced as well, all this stuff is just basic, cheap pre-frozen junk from Gordon Food Service. Even if it is night time, this does not give employees an excuse to be high on the job. The table also had lots of crumbs and grease stains from I assume multiple former customers.

Ordered our usual, gyro meat was dry and burnt. Didn't get sauce with the gyros. Ordered Philly cheese steak and it was dry as well. Also didn't get the Jalapeno poppers ordered with the combo platter. Paid way to much for the worst meal we have ever had there. Did they change management, cooks or they just don't care. Won't be ordering from them again.

We used to be very happy coming here. The food used to be great. The gyro meat totally dry and hard to eat. Our Greek salads which used to be top notch had no dressing. ( We took these to go) The staff were very rude. From now on when I want a good gyro dinner I will drive all the way to Milwaukee where they know how to serve food. Very disappointed

Delicious gyros in Oshkosh with an always friendly staff. I love this place. Every time I am looking to grab a gyro plate with Cajun fries in Oshkosh, this is my carry out go to and they deliver! They come through. Amazing and delicious. Thank You!

The best place for Greek food. Near the University and open until late. The gyros are so yummy. The Greek salad is crispy and more than enough.

Owner operated lunch dive that never disappoints. I believe they source most ingredients from the city which makes for a fantastic Greek Salad with real Feta and olives. Lamb and Pita is also authentic city style street food. Probably even better after you leave the nearby bars. Cheers!

Pizza puffs are good. I get the Gyro Cheeseburger most times and it is okay. I would recommend them.

Fantastic food always- creepy and disrespectful delivery driver calling me "sweetheart" with disregard for my name and continued to disrespect me once confronted.

This place is awesome they really need more locations.. if you've never been there, I recommend the Cajun fries

order chicken tenders. received them from delivery couldn't even eat them because they were burnt almost the color black.

Philly Cheese Steak - 3.9/4 Recommended by the foreman of a local paint factory that frequents Nikki's after a late night work shift. Spot on good. Pleasantly close to the real Philadelphia cheese steak. Perfectly grilled, moist, thin steak chopped with soft grilled mushrooms (good, not an overwhelming taste), peppers, and translucent, mildly caramelized onions. I am visiting from the Philly area and this sandwich is close to the real deal. American cheese is nicely melted into the steak/ veggie mix. As a side note: The best-of-the-best real Philadelphia cheese steak is slathered in cheese, meat juices, marinaded meat, soft beef with a vast selection of cheese, including cheese wiz (yep, that canned stuff). Still very good here compared to Philly. Cajun fries-3.2/5 - Much better than plain fries for those looking for adventure, no heat, just spiced with what tastes like oregano/paprika salt. Most customers were take out so don't be deceived by the lack of customers late at night. Most were ordering the Gyros. The restaurant is in back of the building with a generally dark appearance. There is a secret menu item called "the farmer". The list of meat is too long to list here (recommended by another customer) if you can get them to custom make it. Too much for me. Overall, this is a great place for the late night hard working force. I did not particularly care for the hard rock/ punk rock themed music / yelling background blasting from the cook area that included lyrics with the Lord's name in vain. Yelling music with g-d, bi-ch, f--k. Obviously, they had no sensitivity to an appropriate local music selection. Really guys, how about an uplifting ambiance. Restaurants are about the food and the atmosphere.

They need to slow down and actually cook the food and get it right First time I ordered to go food was raw second time I ordered food was wrong

I was very surprised by what I got at Niko's Gyros. I did not expect this place to be as good as it did, considering the reviews on this page and the nature of Oshkosh. And at a 10 dollar minimum for delivery, it is attainable food on a tuesday night at home. There were plenty of onion rings and fries. I didn't get many breaded mushrooms, but they were good. Oil didn't taste dirty or overused, which is common on this strip of businesses. The Gyro plate I got for $8.00 was pretty generous, not just in salad sides but in in actual vegetables as well. It came with two large feta cubes as opposed to the traditionally dry, highly-oxidized feta crumbles. The amount of gyro meat that came in it was satisfactory. Humorously enough, the double bacon cheeseburger eclipsed the gyro plate in overall quality. The bacon was plentiful and fresh, and it was topped neatly with fresh veggies. There ARE two big fundamental problems with the dishes at Niko's Gyros that I ran into: 1: The meat for their gyros is warmed, but does not appear to have hit hard heat at any point in time, as there is a distinct lack of char, caramelization, or any hint that it is not prepackaged, preshaven gyro meat. 2: The cajun fries are simply not cajun. They are nowhere close to cajun. These fries are doused in paprika and oregano. They would need onion/garlic powder, old bay, celery salt, pepper, cumin, and various other spices before it would need to be considered cajun. I could not get through these. Despite this, I'm pretty sure this is one of the only places in the tri-city area that is doing what it's doing as well as it is. Niko's Gyros isn't a place I'd recommend to tourists and it's doesn't speak of authenticity, but it's the best you'll get in this city. How you choose to interpret that is up to you.

Grabbed a quick dinner here. Food took 20 minutes for 2 gyros, and there was only one other person in the restaurant. They came with only tomato and onions, no lettuce or olives, which was fine. The meat however, dry as shoe leather.. pretty disappointing. Oh well...

Hands down my favorite restaurant in Wisconsin. It's the closest thing to some real Chicago food up here in my opinion and the taste hasn't changed in 10+ years. There's nothing on this menu that I dislike and the service every time I go in is great. I frequent Nikos at least twice a month and get the Gyro Cheeseburger with onion rings, yes please. Niko is always here cooking food too which is pretty cool.

Exactly what I wanted! In Oshkosh for EAA and this place came nightly recommended on yelp so I had to check it out. Nice location right next to the college and you can tell that was their main focus. The facility was nothing to brag about but the guys working were very pleasant and helpful. He suggested the gyro of course and the Cajun chicken pita with Swiss cheese. And man did that hit the spot! They do delivery and call in orders. And have a pretty big array of items on the menu. Overall good bang for your buck and I'm sure would be great late night food.

Never disappoints. Always reminds me of my college days. Heck still looks the same as my college days. Dont ever change a thing Nikos. Gyros are always packed full and Cajun fries are a party all in themselves. No one can beat a gyro as good as Nikos.

When my husband took me here, I admit I was skeptical. The place isn't decorated or even inviting, but their food makes up for it! The gyros are awesome and authentic and really affordable. I'll be going back for sure. Parking is a problem, but for pick up, it's easy to run in and out.

On two separate occasions, my order has taken over an hour and a half for delivery. My husband and I asked why there was such a long delay for two Gyros and we were told they had a rush. The delivery girl was indifferent to our concern. Over the past two months, there has been a steady decline in food and Nikkos customer service. When I called to complain because our food was cold, I was hung up on. While Oshkosh is limited for food, Appleton is not far away.

Not the best customer service out there. I felt absolutely rushed during my order. Asked questions but answered very rude

Probably my favorite steakhouse in town. Fried plantains and pickled goat are especially good.

Addictive deliciousness! Get the double meat gyro. It's flavor bursting good! The cajun fries are the perfect side too. While Nikos says they deliver, it's clearly a takeout place. Delivery could take quite a while. Prices are very reasonable.

I will admit not my favorite place but I am giving it four stars because everyone else I hear talking about has but praise for this hole in the wall.

The namesake item here, the Gyros themselves are what you should go for if you pay a visit to this place, as they are fantastic! The pita bread is cloud fluffy and the meat is succulent and tender. Portion sizes here are also quite generous, which is a tad unusual for a Greek restaurant, but I suppose any the type of cuisine can be "wisconsinized" after a period of time. This place also does delivery, which is awesome. Nice to have a delivery option that is tasty and does not involve Pizza or Chinese food.

Love the Gyros here! Had a few issues with them taking over an hour and a half with delivering the food and calling to find out they were going to have to remake the food because of how long it was taking. Also had issues with cold deep fried mushrooms. But have always loved the gyros, they're huge! :)

Love these guys! Always accommodating & they don't act annoyed or inconvenienced when we come in & it's later on when we're here. Best place to be at bar close

I have had Nyko's gyro plate with side salad several times and I love it! The side salad includes tomatoes, cucumbers, onions (I omit the onions), pepperoncinis, Kalamata olives, and feta squares. The gyro is a plentiful portion of savory meat on a pita with onions and tomatoes. The salad is served with Italian dressing on the side and gyros are served with a side of Tzatziki sauce. I recently had the large salad with a side of gyro meat delivered for lunch, and it was enough food to feed a hungry family! I had enough for separate three meals. The place itself is a little underwhelming, but it is an ideal location for late-night college bar goers. I personally enjoy getting the gyro plate for lunch and having the leftovers for the next day. The serving size is large, as other reviewers have mentioned. But, who doesn't enjoy some cold gyro the next day? Just me? If you prefer your Americanized Greek food served on fine china instead of in a styrofoam takeout box, Nyko's won't be your first choice. But for a thrifty grad student looking for the best dollar value for a nice gyro and Greek salad, I highly recommend Nyko's.

This is always a fave especially for the weekend hours. Generous portions of gyro meat, tasty cajun fries crispy baklava. The mushroom swiss double burger is fantastic too.

A dumpy college restaurant with decent gyros. We usually order for deliver or pick up. It's just to grimy and college-y to eat in. The gyros are stuffed full. There is no way I could eat it all in one sitting. If you're not big on gyro meat they have chicken gyros which are also tasty. Don't forget to order Cajun Fries!

My favorite gyros in the valley. Gyros just like the ones in Madison. Plenty of meat off the rotisserie, and thick tzatziki sauce. The Greek salads are great too. Parking is tough, but it's worth it!

One of the best gyros I have had in my lifetime. I can't believe I've been living in Oshkosh over 3 months now and just discovered this place.

I used to have a five star review, until I received my delivery tonight. I have a very severe fresh tomato allergy, and I received an order with notes on my box that my food may or may not be contaminated by tomato. Thanks guys. I really enjoyed not having dinner today.

Fine food. Fries are good salad was ok. Chicken was ok. Would like more flavor in the meet and salad dressing. It's an average fir me.

Just had a gyro here and it was delicious! Good pita bread. Tasty onions. Great Greek mystery meat. That white sauce. I guess I really don't know much about Greek food other than it's generally really good. And this place was no exception. Thanks for a great lunch.

Way better than I was expecting, and I had even read the previous reviews! I knew it would be good, but not to the point of being blown away. Everyone seemed to endorse the gyro plate, so I had to go with that. The salad was crisp and fresh with a wonderful vinaigrette. The cajun fries were good. The gyro itself was delicious. The meat was real tender and juicy, the veggies and rice in it were well seasoned and just added nicely to it. The place itself is nothing too fancy, just a small hole in the wall. They do however have an old space invaders knockoff arcade system in the corner. The service from the staff and food though will truly set this place apart. I will definitely stop back here the next time I"m in town.

Best gyro around and the Cajun fries are to die for. Awesome service too.

Food is very consistent....great! Love the gyro platter with the Greek salad..... try this place!

This was my first time ordering from here. I waited a little while for my food but no longer than any other place I've ordered from. The delivery person called me before she came to my door to make sure she went to the right and one and to let me know she was there. I don't know why but I liked that a lot. The anticipation of a loud knock never sits well with me. Anyways, the food was incredible I just got a cheeseburger and mozzarella sticks and they tasted fantastic. The prices where incredibly priced. I will 100% order there again. The tip will definitely go up too with the food and service I got.

This place is so good that I called the manager to tell them how pleased I was. It was my um-teenth order from there and there has only been one time ever where everything was not perfectly: friendly, faster than promised, very reasonable prices, and the quality of food is stellar. The time that slipped wasn't perfect, but was so funny that it still makes me laugh. The best gyro plate in town.

The food is great, when they make it correctly. My burger was made wrong (delivery) and when I called the restaurant it took me 3 times to get through. Then the person proceeded to argue with me about what I ordered on my burger. Not sure why I would ask for "only mustard and onions" when I in fact hate mustard and onions but I guess they know more than me, the person who placed the order.

It's got great food, amazing Cajun fries, and it's kitchy as hell. You go for the food and because it's as Oshkosh as EAA. I probably wouldn't go there black tie... but it would be quite the memorable date if you did.

Ahhh yum! All I have to say is Cajun fries! Amazing. Whether you have drunk or sober, Niko's is going to give you exactly what you crave (bar food). Be prepared for a line at bar close, but oh so worth it. My favorite go to other than a gyro is the double cheese burger combo w/Cajun fires. Extra cup of mayo. Yum! Nothing like getting sloshed in Oshkosh then hitting this place up at 3am. Best drunk food ever! I can thank Niko's for my freshman 15 lbs. That's for sure! So good, enough said.

The place has a 1970's look to the dining room, but don't judge a book by its cover. They have the best gyros around. It has been a college staple for many years. This is my second time I have been here and look forward to returning. Very good!

Delivery service was as pathetic as the food. The only reason they are around is because the college is right by them. Easily the most disgusting food i've ever been charged for. Not only did it take a hour plus to get here the fries were stale the mushrooms were soggy and the pita bread was wet... They should feel ashamed they serve crap but they dont

One of the best gyro places I've been to. Great quality fresh food. Big portions at a good value. I'll keep going here and recommending it!

Best takeout food in Oshkosh!! The food is absolutely incredible, and is relatively cheap! The only con is that delivery takes a little bit, but is worth it.

Best gyro's ever!!! This is a little dive with the best gyros you will ever eat. Get it with Cajun fries .

This is to DIE FOR!! Try their Gyro plate with Cajun fries... And the quantities are good tooo..

I really enjoyed Nikos. I had a gyro and Cajun fries while I was out one night. My only complaint is that I left my leftovers at a friend's house, hardly Nikos' fault.

Really great gyro with a lot of meat. Onions, tomato and tzatziki sauce rounded out this delicious mid night snack. I will certainly be coming back for more.

If you want a gyro that tastes like the metal they sliced it with, eat here. Honest to goodness the worst dining experience I've had with gyros. I decided to give them one last shot a few nights ago, awful idea on my part. Tasted like aluminum and gave me a stomach ache. So unless you're into cheap food that makes you sick, don't eat here. There needs to be another gyro place in town because it would shut this place down from lack of business, simply due to the awful food here. I rated this a 2 because yelp would not let me rare a 1

The employees are friendly, yet seem drunk or high all weekend while they work somehow manage to make the best gyros is the fox valley.

The gyros that we ordered were dry with no cucumber or whatever sauce!! the meat was dry and over cooked... had to wait an hour, which wouldn't have been bad if the results were worth the wait. Would never waste my $ ordering from them again!

The gyros and the fries were amazing and the price was great! But the smell of the place was a little weird, not to bad just very strong and not to pleasant