Natalie H.
Yelp
My boyfriend's parents came here years ago during one of their trips to Kyoto, and they loved it. However, when we visited Gion Nishikawa earlier this year, it had deteriorated. With 2 michelin stars and having to make a reservation weeks in advanced, we expected the food to be amazing, but it was not. Even though they used high quality ingredients, the preparation was lacking. Some of the courses were pretty good, but for the rest, the flavors were either off or bland. The quality of the ingredients saved it from being bad.
Because it's kaiseki, the menu can be different each time. For us, the first course they served was puffer fish, which I thought was a pretty bold move (if not prepared properly, you can die from the poison). Other courses were more ordinary, like mochi, but even if it was special, we wouldn't have known because the chefs didn't speak english. You don't get a written menu either, so sometimes, we didn't really know what we were eating... It was incredibly filling though. Both me and my boyfriend were not able to finish every course. After the third or fourth course, I was only able to take a bite of each one.
The dining experience and everything else made it an enjoyable experience. Service was great, and the restaurant itself was classic and elegant. It was pretty hard to find, since it was dark out and had no signs. There was just a subtle gate off the streets and a walkway that led to the entrance that you would probably think was someone's house. Even our taxi driver had a hard time finding it.
I think for the ambiance, service, ingredients, and michelin stars, the price was worth it, but we probably won't be coming back. There are many other restaurants in Kyoto that are like this but with better flavors and preparation, though they may not have any michelin stars.