Josh T.
Yelp
(This is my 100th Yelp review! Yay!)
I had mixed feelings going into Nobu. It's a chain now, and often that means there's some element that's lost. A bit too commercialised, a bit too common, it's hard to explain. But at the same time, surely all those rave reviews can't be wrong right?
Well. It was a mixed bag. It wasn't an utter letdown, and the overall experience was enjoyable, but would I go back? Maybe. It seems to be a hit and miss kind of place.
We ordered, the yellowtail with Jalepeno, the beef tataki, and the toro tartare for cold items, the chawanmushi which was a daily special, the black cod miso (of course), the duo of duck, and the pork kakuni. Hits and misses my fellow Yelpers, hits and misses.
The hits:
The Black Cod Miso. This dish was actually worth the price of admission. If you'd like to imagine what it tastes like, imagine buttery cod fish, market fresh, done like char siew. Yup. The miso was this umami-sweet coating that was just amazing. I honestly didn't expect to like this, I've had miso cod at 4-5 other places when it was all the rage and quickly gave up because I never liked it. But this... this was miso cod on another level altogether.
The Chawanmushi. A very very large portion (since it's for sharing), with tomato... relish/fondant of sorts, morel mushrooms, and one slice of black truffle. The truffle, egg, and tomato combination really works, and it was such a great palate cleanser as the dish that bridged our cold and hot courses.
Also a hit, the cocktail I had. Nobu has seasonal cocktail menus, and many many many choices look delicious (but I only had one as I had to drive). The cocktails here are legit my friends, and also worth checking out when you dine.
The service was also excellent. Friendly and accommodating. Our waitress actually handed us the wrong menu for drinks (giving us one with the autumn list even though we were squarely in winter). I noticed that it said autumn, but figured oh, maybe they haven't released the winter list yet, and ordered something off that menu. She apologetically came back later and told me I had to order off the winter menu instead... and while I was perusing, the bartender came with my original order anyway. I liked that they made it anyway, though maybe they could have explained things clearer since he just plopped it down without saying anything.
The misses? The Yellowtail. It was... sashimi, with a slice of Jalapeno. It didn't not work, flavour wise, but it didn't wow us either. The beef tartaki was just smothered in ponzu sauce and we had real problems tasting the beef over the sauce and the onions and deep fried garlic. The duo of duck was a bit hard to chew, and felt a little directionless in terms of taste and texture. The pork was... well it was melt in your mouth, but it was a bit overwhelmingly porky. There was some attempt to diversify the flavour with some spicy miso, but even that dab of sauce was lost in the strong pork taste. Now, I like pork. And it was good pork. But it was JUST pork and it got kinda boring kinda quickly.
The toro tartare wasn't a miss. But it wasn't a hit. It was an interesting dish that... well. Was a tuna tartare. I've had similar for cheaper.
So overall, it feels like Nobu is the kind of place where the menu is so wide that you kind of need to know what to order. Some of the items are definitely winners... but some of them are really off target. And while variety is great on a menu... leaving diners the chance to choose something NOT amazing is generally a bad idea.
My last thought is that I'd definitely not describe the cuisine here as Japanese. There're just too many heavy handed dishes and not enough craft and subtlety that really defines Japanese cuisine. Maybe international with Japanese influences, or South American with Japanese influences... but definitely not how they describe themselves: 'Japanese with South American influenecs'. Nah-uh.