Jeremy K.
Yelp
Noir is somewhat of a disappointment. I've had a couple of trips there and although the first was rather mediocre, mostly due to a very inexperience and incompetent bar staff, my second one last night was much better albeit inconsistent.
Located just a short walk from Harvard Square, in the lower level of the Charles Hotel, under both Henrietta's Table and Jody Adam's Rialto, the bar itself is rather small. It is also dark, with a modern look to it, which itself isn't bad. I do somewhat feel that they've put more efforts into the décor of the place than into quality control.
Whether on my first or second trip there, the drinks have been extremely inconsistent - some of the cocktails even tasted extremely weird, having some umami-like flavors which were unexpected. One of such culprits is their Matinee. Although I can't pull up the ingredient list from their outdated website, I was expecting some bold flavors from the rye base and instead tasted curry powder - curry wasn't one of the ingredients in there though and after just two tiny sips, I couldn't finish it. A real shame.
Other cocktails I had there were decent, such as the Toronto which features
Rye whiskey, fernet branca, simple syrup, orange zest and angostura bitters. But while decent, $12 for it is a bit steep, especially since I could have a much better drink at... Drink for cheaper. In many ways, I feel like while the bar's location, décor and atmosphere is great, it somewhat feels pretentious that they'd charge that much for a poorly executed cocktail. Sure, maybe if the staff was well seasoned, then maybe, just maybe, you could pull it off but unfortunately I didn't feel like it was the case after much observation.
Sadly for them, there's some strong competition in the area, such as Russell House Tavern and their very own Aaron Butler who's a master of his craft and could mix this staff under the bar. And because of such, I'll probably skip Noir and head there instead for some drinks in the area.
On the upside their cocktail list is seasonal which is a plus, and one of the reasons why they are keeping three stars in my review - They have some interesting ingredients that they mix with, including some Belle de Brillet (a pear liqueur), egg whites, pom pomegranate juice and even some Ruby Port.