Novelli Cafe and Restaurant

I really really wanted to like this place, but they failed miserably at the basics. My daughter ordered the chicken tenders / nuggets and fries. I can't recall which name they used for the dish, so I put tenders / nuggets. The chicken was soggy and pink inside. It was not crispy at all. I don't think there any children looking for soggy chicken. My daughter enjoyed no part of that dish. The sprite was the only thing she enjoyed. I ordered the chicken shis kebab because they are typically delicious at other restaurants. This was not the case at all here. With a typical kebab, the meat is meaty and flavorful. That was NOT the case here. This was a grounded up, dried bland abomination of a kebab. They had a white creamy dipping sauce with some red powder that immediately gave me an allergic reaction. The food was all very expensive, and I have zero desire to return. As for the decor, it all looks very nice. Money was spent to make the place visually appealing, but the food misses the mark by miles. I write many reviews on Google, and I give my honest unbiased opinions. The goal is to help bring about needed changes. To be completely fair, a few of the guests that dined with me and my daughter loves their meals. Those dishes were fish based. My oldest daughter had the sliders and she took one bite out of the 3 mini sliders and wanted no more. Hopefully they can make some much needed changes. I must commend the wait staff, as they were on top of everything the moment we walked in. They did everything within their power to make us comfortable, and get our orders out quickly. Unfortunately, they have no control over the quality of the food. For me, the dining experience was terrible as me and my daughter's found our food not fit for consumption. As you can see, only a single bite was taken out of the sliders we brought home, and only a chunk was eaten from one of the three kebabs.

Absolutely loved everything about this place! The food is beyond amazing and every dish we tried was packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. The ambiance inside is just as impressive: warm, stylish, and incredibly welcoming. It’s the kind of spot that makes you want to stay a while. The staff? Truly top-tier. Friendly, attentive, and clearly passionate about what they do. Easily one of the best dining experiences.

We just popped in to check it out and the surprise 😮 we got. The food was amazing, very tasty, beautiful well put together places. And I'm in love with the Mint Lemonaid. So refreshing. I will definitely be going back. The whole staff is inviting and warm. Love it.

The quality of the food is way overpriced. They charged me 7$ for 3 pieces of shrimp. The salad could’ve been better. I ordered chicken tenders and fries for my kid. The fries and tenders were undercooked. And overall my total came out to $52. So not worth it. The people, service and ambience was great but I don’t think I would ever want to come back because of the quality of the food.

It’s my new favorite place 😍😍😍😍😍 If you’re in Prospect Park, Novelli Café is a solid choice. The desserts are next-level—rich, delicious, and totally worth saving room for. The service is friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. And if you’re a fan of seafood, their seafood risotto is a must-try—flavorful and perfectly cooked. Great spot for a relaxed, tasty meal!

Went here for brunch and it was amazing! My waffle was flaky but not to hard, plenty of avocado and fresh fruit on top, the salmon was the best I’ve had in my life, the waiter was so attentive and made sure my bloody Mary was made just right. Even the bathrooms were nice, spacious and clean. I highly recommend this place, and the customer service is outstanding.

Just ordered take out and when we came to pick it up we were greeted with the most friendly smiles, so I’ll definitely be back to dine in. Got the chicken parm sandwich and the artichoke pizza and both were great. I liked the sandwich best, while my boyfriend liked the pizza best. The red sauce on the chicken parm sandwich was delicious and rich, I would eat it by the spoonful.

You truly don’t understand the amount of joy that I have to finally see a beautiful and fine establishment as NOVELLI in my hometown, MY Community!! This place brings warmth to the soul with great class, true comfort and delicious eats plus don’t get me started on the amazingly engaging hospitality you receive from entry to departure honestly from the WHOLE team to QUEEN Sabina the owner herself EVERYONE truly makes you feel right at home as if they’ve been a staple on this corner for years! I had their delicious Grilled salmon fillet served with creamy quinoa, sautéed asparagus, and a smooth lemon cream sauce. I then had the Aleppo Kebab Bide which is a Spiced lamb kebab with grilled salsa and biwas on a traditional bide base. My last entree and also my new found favorite dish was the Branzino Fritto which is a Crispy whole branzino served with steamed rice and house-made tangy carrot pickles. For dessert because I could not stop lol I had the Tiramisu made with Phyllo Dough it had Mascarpone cream layered with espresso-soaked phyllo dough, topped with cinnamon, crushed pistachios, and syrup and I also enjoyed the grilled fruit plate which was a tasty grilled skewered pineapple topped with toffee sauce and served with vanilla ice cream. Having Novelli in the heart of the neighborhood is a dream come true and I know the community truly loves and appreciates it from the esthetic to the hilarious and amazing beings like Saint and Bing and PLEASE don’t get me started on Justin the bartender whom has THE BESTEST skills behind the shakers no other around and the sweetest the hostess Logan and her inviting smile — two years in the making and it honestly was worth the wait !! see ya’ll soon for more !!!

A+ restaurant! The ambiance has a classy and romantic feeling. The service was so friendly and accommodating. Great menu selections all around. My dish which was the prime rib was made with love and tasted so good! I cannot recommend this restaurant enough.

Novelli is a great addition to the neighborhood. We've been waiting for a fine modern dining place in or near Prospect/Lefferts for years. It's spacious with a separate dining area, bar and takeout counter for pizza, pastry and coffee. Service is incredibly friendly and fast, and excels with personal service by the bar tender and some interesting cocktail creations. They have a Neapolitan pizza oven and based on the yummy pita with butter served upfront make a very decent dough. Next time we'll try the pizza for sure. This time we went for appetizers and starters from the regular menu. The lemon hummus was a standout with a lovely addition of some mint leaves and the ability to replace the pita with vegetables for gluten free customers. The dishes are however on the pricy side. In particular the tuna tartare wasn't great. It seemed over-cured, turned slightly grey and tasted fishy - though the combination with kiwi for the curing is certainly a great idea. The seafood risotto could do with a couple more mussels or an addition of calamari. Aside from that it tasted good and the rice was cooked perfectly - but be aware that it is a bit salty.

I stopped by this weekend to check out their Middle Eastern and Italian fusion menu -- they have a wide variety, from pizzas and burgers to seafood dishes.The fattoush salad was super fresh with a bright, delicious lemon sumac vinaigrette - it is perfect for summertime as it's so refreshing! We also had the spinach artichoke pizza (super cheesy), cacio Pepe (yum), and the cheeseburger. They also have a great cocktail list, and the bartender can mix up whatever you're in the mood for.But whatever you do, definitely don't miss the tiramisu -- a unique blend of both cuisines that melts in your mouth. Honestly worth visiting for the dessert alone!!!

New customer here and the food was not great at all! We had a girl opened the door which was cute. The prices is not worth the food! They should have cut the bananas and the crepes were so small! The pizza was dry, did not have enough sauce. I also ordered the two different types of drinks and it was surgery. I spend $54 for bullshit!

Food, service, ambiance- 10s across the board. Obsessed with this place so bad. Lucky it's in the neighborhood!!

Our two meals here have been very tasty and the staff is remarkably friendly and attentive. I've enjoyed the salmon, risotto, burrata salad and panna cotta most.

The chocolate trio waffle was delicious an so was the strawberry lemonade. Service was amazing. Lots of seating.

Absolutely loved this place! The salads were fresh, the risotto was perfectly cooked, and the panna cotta was incredibly delicious -- light, creamy, and full of flavor. The service was excellent, very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is so cozy that you just want to stay and relax for hours. Portions are a great size -- satisfying without being overwhelming. Can't wait to come back!

Overall the food and service is Amazing! You won't regret experiencing a new chapter in your life at Novelli!

So the 18% service charge plus my 20% tip equaled 38% of the bill not food related. I definitely won't be returning, but I do wish you the best of luck !