Adam J Hamersky
Google
Nugg’s Ice Cream is hands down one of the best ice cream spots in Denver, and I was really excited to check it out based on all the great reviews. The quality of their ice cream is fantastic—super creamy, rich flavors, and clearly made with care. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, and the staff is friendly and efficient. They’ve got a solid selection of flavors, from the classics to more creative options, and I appreciate the variety of toppings they offer.
But here’s the deal: they don’t have Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups as a candy add-on. I honestly can’t wrap my head around this. Reese’s is one of the most popular ice cream toppings out there, and somehow, it’s missing from their menu? Every time I go to an ice cream shop, I’m hoping to see it as an option, and time and time again in Denver, I’m disappointed. It’s absolutely frustrating.
I’m not saying this is a dealbreaker for everyone, but for me, it’s a big miss. Peanut butter and chocolate are a classic combo, and plenty of other ice cream places across the country recognize that. Why not here? It’s such a simple fix—just add Reese’s to the topping menu, and this place would be an easy 5-star spot for me.
I really want to love Nugg’s completely, and I’d be more than happy to update my review if they fix this oversight. Until then, I’m sticking with 3 stars—great ice cream, great shop, but missing a key topping that should absolutely be available. If you don’t care about Reese’s as much as I do, you’ll probably love it. But if you’re like me and want that peanut butter-chocolate combo, just be aware you won’t find it here.