Evan G.
Google
This has become our go-to spot for a quick, cheap and tasty bite before Broadway shows. The food is significantly better than you get from most chain sandwich shops (as of this review they have six locations around NYC) and they even have a happy hour until 7pm during which a couple of their sandwiches are only $6. That's a steal in the Times Square area.
We generally go with the pulled pork (highly recommended), but there is also a chicken sandwich available at happy hour prices that we've yet to try. If you like spice and need more to eat than just a sandwich, the side order of slaw is also very good.