NYY Steak

Great experience all around. Showed up without a reservation about 10 minutes before the start of a division series game and was able to get a table. the Hostess was very polite and ensured we got a table near a TV. The waiter was very knowledgeable of the menu and efficient with getting us in and out to get to the game. The Bison meatball appetizer was very tasty and the 20 oz ribeye was cooked perfectly. I particularly liked how it had a dark crunchy crust on the outside which gave it that extra flavor. Looking forward to coming back to try some other appetizers and desserts. Highly recommended!

Honestly absolutely not worth it. Everything was overcooked. My 40 dollar porkchop was so dry I had to choke down every bite with water. I absolutely should have sent it back. The lobster was overcooked. The steak was overcooked. The only thing that wasnt overcooked was the raw seafood.

Had the petite filet mignon, cooked okay, maybe a little overdone to my liking, but still good. Regular French fries are also good, and there are plenty to share, even for 3 people.

The steak was cooked perfectly! Shrimp cocktail was delicious. 10/10 recommend coming here with your family before the game. Great memories were made.

Bone in rib for $90 was underwhelming. Creamed spinach was the worst I have ever had. Service mid. Would have been better if exterior view was towards the game instead of the train/street.

Had dinner just before the game. At the elevator we got stopped by a woman asking if we had a reservation and we did not. She gave us attitude and said we needed to wait so she could check if they take walks in. After she lets us go up the elevator we saw the restaurant empty! They gave us a table and we thought that was the only hiccup. The waiter gave us attitude when we asked if a friend could join us last minute. He rolled his eyes and asked us to move at the end of the table. They put a chair right on the hallway where waiters and people were passing through. Mind you, we had at least 2 tables on the other side where our friend could’ve sat. Food was ok. Lobster Mac and cheese was cold but service was not good.

I stick with the appetizers. Steak is okay.

Service and food were perfect. Shout out to Stephanie for making our first time perfect. We will definitely be back because of her.

It's a Steakhouse in Yankee Stadium. Nothing more to say than that ;) Really here to eulogize their location in Manhattan that was across from Rockefeller Plaza, that was a successor, in a way, of both Mickey Mantle's (Central Park West) and the original Toots Shor's (same block of West 51st). Obvious tourist trap for sure, but gotta love when it's owned or licensed out by a local sports ball franchise. Also l noticed via Untappd that they had a good local craft beer menu.

Still the BEST Steakhouse in the Boogie Down Bronx, but the prices are creeping higher and higher. Here is the price tag for dinner for one last Tuesday, before the Yankees v Mets game: Double Kettle One and soda: $23 (x2) = $46 Clams Casino: $23 Delmonico Ribeye: $71 Lobster Mac & Cheese: $25 Glass House Merlot: $17 Plus tax: $16.15 Total without tip: $198.15 Dinner for one with tip was a whopping $232.15

Love the food here. I always come before a game because the typical stadium food is not my thing. I of coarse recommend any steak, there salads are amazing. The staff understands you are eating before the game and tries to make your experience elegant, while getting you out in time for the game. Don't miss out on this place. For sure make a reservation!!

Always a bright spot when watching a Yankee game. Top shelf food and service. Priced as you would expect but worth the experience. Quality and presentation are 2nd to none. Bring your friends. Family. Special someone. You won't be sorry.

Impressive quality for a stadium. A great spot to get warm during cold weather or get in AC during summer months, drinks are stiff and bar staff is attentive. When eating here the burrata salad and filet with garlic can't be beat. A fantastic addition to the stadium

Menu looked good, they cater to steak lovers, the seafood plater was great, well executed, good wedge salad. Staff was great a little slow I believe it was due to Yankee game. The ambiance was great lots of TV'S, friendly staff. A little bit pricey

Service was exceptional. Very cool decor highlighting the Yankees. Food was great! Got their version of an old fashion. No fancy ice, but really good. The butter they serve with the bread is divine. Filets were seasoned and cooked perfectly. We shared a Caesar salad. The lettuce wasn't super great and I got a couple bites that tasted sandy. Also got the mashed potatoes 10/10. Would definitely recommend.

The BEST pregame dining experience you can imagine !!! Great drinks , well prepared feasts -above the average and plenty of it - the thick bacon app was like a main & the lobster mac made a nice side to my steak . Family was totally having a great time either way anticipating the game and the staff was as elegant as the atmosphere, you can dress casual, we wore our pinstripes , Yankees lost but Holy Cow we had an awesome dinner !! But I do add get there EARLY for your reservation & make one because it was packed , the traffic getting into the stadium pregame is crazy, if you're taking a taxi it cuts off your parking time for sure but still the backed up traffic .. Then you gotta find your line to get in...stand in a line of unknown proportions to go through a metal detector and 3 security guards ..wait for your turn to go in while people go in ahead of you .. it took 45 mins to get into the steakhouse from the taxi drop off

Went for my birthday before the game. Started off with a great bourbon cocktail then we were given a delicious, warm pretzel bun with beer cheese butter. For appetizer my mom and I shared baked clams casino, the 6 small clams topped with bacon and breadcrumbs were good. For entree I ordered the off the menu special Pat Lafrieda aged strip steak, medium rare. It was super delicious but unfortunately it was overcooked so I sent it back. Just a few minutes later they came with another steak that was still not cooked properly, between rare/medium rare and did not have the same depth of flavor but they said it was the special. My mom got the pork chop which she was in love with and we shared sides of mushrooms and garlic mashed potatoes. When the bill arrived, we were charged for the regular strip steak so I was correct. That was a bummer but still a good meal.

Once again the food and service were very good. I have to give the staff a lot of credit for how they dealt with an incredibly obnoxious customer. She clearly made the other customers aggrieved by her behavior. The staff was calm and extremely courteous. They kept their cool and showed respect to the unruly customer. They deserve a great deal of credit.

The filets we ordered were cooked to perfection and absolutely amazing. Service was fantastic and the atmosphere before a game can't be beat.

Hi Friend, Good food , good service, Yankee fan haven Prices very ,very high!!! The business is pro Red Sox's Ambiance lighting makes you feel as if you were sitting by the pesky pole in Fenway. C

This was my first time trying the Yankee Stadium Steakhouse after great recommendations but unfortunately our steak for 2 was overly charred. :( I was a little disappointed with the over seared steak but would like to give this location another shot. The ambiance was a plus and the restaurant is beautiful designed with thoughtful touches of Yankee memorabilia all throughout. Our server was very knowledgeable, friendly and did a great job checking in on us. I wouldn't run back here for a steak but I would certainly grab the oysters and a drink right before the game!

NYY Steak no longer have pretzel rolls or soup which were fan favorites. The strip steak was delicious but for the $$ a vegetable or a cup of rice would have been nice. The dessert selection was only a choice of 3 and were the common cheesecake, chocolate cake or crem brûlée. The Diet Coke was flat but service was excellent as usual! May go to HardRock next time!!

One of the most romantic nights of our lives! My boyfriend is a huge Yankees fan so I surprised him with Delta Suite game tickets and a fabulous steak dinner before the game! The restaurant is INSIDE the stadium.. so very convenient and there are tvs everywhere to catch the game up close. Highly recommend! Excellent service and food quality!

Dined here 3 times this past season. 3 different servers. Each experience as good as the previous. This is not just the best food in NYY Stadium. It's undoubtedly the best steakhouse in the Bronx. The food is outstanding. Cooked every time at requested temp. The martinis are a proper pour and always on point. The managers here help expedite the food. That's not something you see often. I cannot say enough positive things about this place. It's not "stadium food". My first time I had low expectations and each and every time I've returned I'm as more impressed with the consistency and quality. Thank you!

Pleasantly surprised by the service and experience at NYY Steak. The hostess Stephanie made the difference with explaining the specialities on the menu. I've wanted to come here for awhile and am happy to admit I plan on coming back for the service and steak!

Came here right before watching a yankee game. Of course I ordered the signature steak this place even during covid, is set up nicely. I felt this was a top of the line steak house. The colors were yankee signature colors. There were signatures on the wall as part of the decor. I would rate this a medium sized restaurant and the staff were very attentive and nice. Ok so onto the steak... the signature steak you was able to add engraving , so of course I asked for my initials. I ordered the steak medium, the steak was a little charred in some cases, probably should order it medium rare for this cut of meat. I also ordered the lobster macaroni. Wasn't really wowed by that. I feel it lacked pepper and salt. But it was ok. If i ever attend a baseball game, I'm definitely eating here again.

Terrible service. Sat for 20 mins at the table. No server came over. Walked out. Not even a glass of water.

Ok, the french onion soup was decent. The soup itself was bold and flavorful and the melty, partially crispy cheese covering the top was wonderful. The toast was a bit burnt, but other than that it was perfect. Unfortunately, that's all I had here. Apparently you need reservations in advance for one of the tables, but we sat at the bar and received pretty terrible service. It was awkward trying to have dinner at the bar. Even the ascent via the elevator to the restaurant and waiting at the hostess stand was awkward. But the other restaurant was full. It seems like dining at the stadium is the thing to do and even as the first pitch was made, there were still people eating. If you're planning on eating before the game, eat elsewhere, maybe before your commute because the neighborhood area is pretty sketchy. That, or make a reservation way ahead of time.

Wonderful experience, at the now retired downtown Manhattan site. Please if she is working up in the Bronx location ask for Ashley Startek, she was the greatest waitress I have ever I had the pleasure of dining with!! 4 Stars on Food and Atmosphere, 5+ Stars for our waitress Ashely.

Food amazing. Staff amazing. Decor amazing. Would go back again tomorrow if I lived close by. If you have to eat anything on that menu, eat the Au Gratin potatoes. Best this I've eaten in my life

I have been there multiple times and this was the worst. Service was ridiculously slow, food was average at bast and there was an annoying guy a couple tables away that wouldn't shut up. I can't see returning for a $400.00 meal with no alcohol.

Yummy in my tummy Server Manny was fantastic. Would love to go back again. The delicious volcano desert with liquor was bomb yummmm

I have to admit that this steakhouse exceeded my expectations. I honestly thought that this place was just about the name. I thought to myself "okay yea great there's a steakhouse in Yankee Stadium" but lo and behold it was fantastic. I went with a large group so I was able to try quite a bit of things. For appetizers we had the onion rings, lobster mac & cheese, NYY bacon and garlic mashed potatoes. All of the sides were great. My only critique is that the lobster mac & cheese definitely could have had some more lobster but none the less the flavor was there and it was delicious. For my entree I had the Delmonico Ribeye with the au poivre sauce on the side. The steak was cooked perfectly and the au poivre sauce was the perfect touch. Not sure if they offer specialty cocktails but I had a basic drink from the bar which was fine. Just as a note you do need a ticket to the Yankee game for that day to get in. If all you want to do is eat here you can easily get a nose bleed ticket for $15 and walk around the stadium after you eat for some entertainment, the energy is always great at Yankee Stadium. I would definitely recommend and I will definitely be returning.

The food here was delicious came after the game. The big flint stone steak is big enough To share but it was my anniversary gift to my hubby so we each got one so we could have leftovers for the weekend. The chocolate cake was delicious.

Great experience. Very friendly staff and well attended. Were seated on time for our reservation. The food was absolutely delicious. I ordered the pork chops, and it came with a mushroom oyster sauce, that had a feint but very delicious flavor to it. My friend ordered the Ribeye, which was absolutely delicious. Pretty cool thing, if you order the ribeye, they engrave whatever word you want into the bone, looks so cool. My friends also enjoyed some lobster mac and cheese. Nelson was an amazing server, very timely, efficient and had a good attitude, which goes a long way, he made it all worthwhile. Will definitely be going back soon.

Best. Steak. Ever!!!! What a way to watch the Yankees win and chow down. Awesome seeing the special knives the players use whenever they come. The plates have Yankees numbers on them. The theming is on point. View is great. And best of all, the service. Go Yankees!

Decided to go to NYY Steak at the Yankee Stadium after one of my good friends recommended it. A couple of friends, my fiancé and I went to watch the Yankees vs Brewers. My friend had made reservations for 7:30pm a day before. When we arrived to NYY Steak around 7:20pm and right away the host told us our table is being prepared. They sat us down 2 minutes after. Nelson, our waiter was excellent, he was very respectful and helpful on explaining the entrees. I ordered the Berkshire Pork chop ($36.00) which were outstanding. They serve two chops. Both had great flavor and texture with a creamy delicious oyster sauce. Also, I ordered a side which was the lobster mac and cheese. It's a perfect serving with chunks of lobster. My fiancé ordered the Ahi Tuna ($35.00) which was served with edamame purée, shiitake mushrooms, ginger soy sauce. I tasted it and was delicious. My friend, Franklin ordered the NYY Signature Ribeye ($78.00). It's a 27 oz. prime dry-aged long bone ribeye. You can even have words spelled onto the bone. My friend had "friends" spelled onto the ribeye. I tasted the ribeye and it tasted amazing. The restaurant is kept well maintained and very elegant. Has comfortable chairs and has great lighting. If you're out watching Yankee game then I definitely recommend NYY Steak!

This place is delicious. Amazing service and steak that melts in your mouth. We had an incredible dinner. They have a steak that's aged in beeswax that will blow you mind. The wine selection is on point. If you are visiting NYC this is a must! You won't go wrong with any of their meat selection. Don't pass on the bread and butter!

We dined at this Yankee Stadium location today. The service was great as well as the drinks but the food/appetizers left a lot to be desired. The martini with blue cheese will set you bac $18 but it is a well made martini. The only food item that was good of the three we ordered was the iceberg salad, it was crisp and had good flavor (it is hard to mess this up, as it's a pretty basic salad). The tomato Burrata salad did not have fresh tomatoes. The tomatoes were very soggy and looked to have been sitting out a while (see photo). The burger was good however the bread was burnt (see photo). I emailed the GM Henry Gordon (as listed on the NYY main website) and one week later still received no response. Poor customer service.

5/10/18 Yankees vs Red Sux. You can make reservations up to 15 days prior to the game you're going to and yes you need a ticket for that day's game. Also, while not required I would strongly suggest making one - this place can get packed. We had a reservation for before the game yesterday. Pros: Service was top notch - friendly and attentive without being overbearing. There is a separate entrance to get into the Hard Rock and NYY Steakhouse, if you get the big bone in they will etch something into it for you - we went with the classic "Red Sox Suck", and given the location I would expect to pay more for our meal here than I did Cons: As far as steakhouses go the seating seems pretty tight - you're pretty close to being seated with the people at the next table (at least the chairs are comfy), the bar area was packed and after ordering or first round of drinks took about 20 minutes to get to the table. It is noisy (but I didn't come here for a quiet evening Bottom line if I think about how much I would spend on 2 beers and 2 hotdogs for myself this isn't that much more expensive and a lot more satisfying. Salute and it's at least worth checking out.

This was my fourth trip to NYY Steak but the first time with just two of us. While the food was excellent, we ended up moving to a bar table over the restaurant as the two-tops are packed so close together that you feel that you are "family dining" with the people next to you. In addition, they are extremely wide so everyone is talking loud because their table mate is so far away. The bar tables, otoh, were a little too small for this type of dining but at least it felt like you could have a conversation. The food was, as usual excellent. I had the small filet and my friend had the salmon. Both were perfectly cooked and delicious. The thick cut bacon appetizer was also outstanding. Asparagus was fresh and the bearnaise was perfectly prepared. Overall exactly what you want out of a higher end steak house. Recommend.

Food & service were fantastic. Just a word of advice for anyone who makes a reservation before the gates open for the game. You can no longer enter through the Hard Rock. We were told to wait on line till the gates opened..which wasn't going to work since our reservation was an hour before gates opened. Thankfully someone from the Stadium told security to let us in. So according to NYY Steak, the security firm used are not employees of Yankee Stadium and the firm took it upon themselves to no longer scan tickets from the NYY Steak entrance (located in the back of the Hard Rock, past the bathrooms) Someone at the Stadium needs to rectify this problem. It caused unnecessary confusion & made us late for our reservation.

Went here on 4/25/13 for a special dinner with my nephew from Texas before the Yankee-Jays game. All that can be said is that everything was superb! Pricy, but superb! We shared the onion rings stack for an appetizer. It was enough for 4 ppl. Crazy, looking more like a stack of donuts than rings. I posted a photo of this. We each got steaks. He got the 8 oz filet, me the 12 oz NY strip. We shared baked potato and asparagus sides. The steaks were grilled perfectly with a heavy char on the outside and juicy on the inside. Oh so tasty! Our waitress Katie, was lovely, very friendly, great sense of humor, helpful, and honest about everything we asked her. I love a server with opinions, and she was the best. All the servers couldn't have been more accommodating. They all justified a great tip. I recommend getting there early before the game (2-3 hours) so you aren't in the large crowd rush before the game. It's not a romantic atmosphere. But if you're a Yankees fan, its like a very high end sports bar with the Yes network on and great old photos and signature walls of the Yankees of years gone by. Save up your bucks and have a wonderfully delicious experience at NYY Steak. GO THERE!!!

I've dined in restaurants before where the chef was working and have been to some of his catered events. He is pretty talented. Was looking over he menu for the new steakhouse at Yankee Stadium! Can't wait to try it. Sounds delicious. Will repost review soon. Go Yankees! :-) Plenty of Big Screens in here Date Rating: TBD (Definitely a 10 if your date likes sports!) Pick up Scale: N/A (probably easier to meet interesting people here if you're a baseball + Yankee Fan! If you're feisty wear some Red Sox Garb.)

I came here during the 8th inning of the yankee game I attended. The pretzel bread they give you (on a diamond shaped plate) w/ the cheddar cheese mustard butter is yummy! I had the 14 oz NY Strip with a side of creamed spinach. The steak was a perfect med rare and so flavorful from the marbeling in the steak, the creamed spinach were also wonderful. Also, I got a side of the lobster mac and cheese (large enough for 2-3 to share $12) which was sooooo good with large pieces of lobster claw in it. This place is incredibly delicious and the prices are on par with any other great steakhouse and well worth it for the portions and quality of food. I rank it with Gallagher's and Ruth Chris but nothing can top Peter Luger's. I would go back here in a heartbeat!

My boyfriend and I decided to try out NYY Steak at the Yankees stadium after we read online at AM New York that their burger was rated one of the top burgers in NYC. It was a nice change of scenery to go to such a nice place on a game day at the Yankees Stadium instead eating at the concessions. We started off with a round of drinks. I ordered a mojito which was tasty, but nothing special or unique about this drink. Nonetheless it was tasty. While previewing the menu for lunch, we noticed there wasn't even a burger on the menu. We were very confused, since we really wanted to try this burger! We said to the waitress that we wanted to order the burger, and she didn't hesitate or say anything about it not being on the menu. Could the burger be a secret dish that isn't on the menu? The burger either came with french fries or coleslaw, and we chose coleslaw since fries just seemed too heavy. For the $17 cost, one would think that it would come with fries AND coleslaw! No such luck! The burger came to our table, and at first glance it seemed great! We soon realized it was missing something. From the reviews we read, and the pictures we saw, it was supposed to include onion jam and aged gouda. The waitress never asked us about toppings and we just assumed we would receive the burger the way it is supposed to be prepared. The meat you could tell was great quality and cooked to perfection, but the missing toppings were a great disappointment. All that was included on ours was lettuce, tomato, and pickles. The coleslaw was very light and not overly creamy, just the way I like it! The burger meat was quite delicious, but I am not sure I would rate it one of the top burgers in NYC, since it lacked excitement . I was hoping for the burger I saw in the picture from AM New York, but this didn't compare. It was like seeing a picture of a McDonald's burger in an ad, and then getting disappointed by the burger you receive. Hopefully next time they don't forget our toppings, if there is even a next time!

Well been a while. Came in middle of the game practically empty. Service was great and food great. Was warm which the cold drove us in.

Came here for a friends birthday and it was a very relaxed and chill vibe.... great start , because most Steak House restaurants are loud and annoyingly busy.... The salmon was to die for!! I recently stop eating meat and was worried I would be disappointed with the seafood option but thankfully that wasn't a problem. I had my salmon cooked medium and it was perfect. It came on top of the most delicious sauce ,, soooooo good!!!! Along with the fish I had creamed spinach which was also amazing!! My cousin had the calamari and Mac n cheese and that was also amazing !!! At first I thought this place was overrated but they really surprised us!! The service and ambiance was also good!!! The drinks were nice and strong as well. The only complaint I had was the truffle fries were very salty, like burn your mouth salty.... other then that we will be back!!

The meal was wonderful, the location was wonderful but what made the entire experience GREAT was our server, "Lauren". She made my wife and I feel special from the moment we sat down. When we come back again, we will insist on having Lauren with us. It was worth the trip from California! Thank you!

Again. Holding steady at 4 stars. On a rainy even snowy, opening day, this place was an excellent respite for a $17 sliced steak sandwich that was only $2 more than the prime rib sandwich that I get in the stands. Attention to detail is not lost, with varying numbered, retired player plates, and blue and white cloth napkins. Overall a fine experience for the discerning baseball fan. The bread alone (in the shape of a pretzel) is worth it, and is probably about a $10 savings, compared to what you'd pay in the concession stands. We were seated immediately, with no reservation, even in the early innings. This is a nice option.

We have dined here for New York Yankee games almost every time we have been to a game. If you don't reserve in advance, your chances of dining here before the game start is not good. We normally would either have drinks at the bar when waiting for a table without reservations. The Steakhouse is very crowded most of the time unlike the other NYY Steakhouse in the NY City. Their food is excellent along with their service. They have an excellent selection of wines as well. Of course, the interior is all about the Yankees with TV's to watch the game. In many occasions I have had too much fun with friends in the restaurant that we have found ourselves finally sitting in our seats sometime in the fourth inning.

The wife and I had tried calling numerous times the day of and the phone went directly to voice mail. We had heard the reservations are a must. So we weren't even going to try. When we got to the stadium we decided to give it a shot. So we went up the elevator and the restaurant was nearly empty with a couple tables scattered about the dining room. I'm glad we tried. We had a great lunch. Maybe if they answered the phone they might actually be able to fill up the dining room? But hey what do I know?!? Had a quick lunch before the game started. Food was excellent. I love the tv screen built into the mirror in the men's room! Can't miss a second of the game even when nature calls! Service was good not great. Very clean!

Really want to love the steakhouse and have been trying since 2009. Have been about 20 times and the one positive side is the servers are always really nice if you sit in the restaurant part. They are attentive, kind, and helpful. However everything else leaves something to be desired. The host staff could care less and we have been left standing there many times while they chat with each other. Not worth the price tag.

Food very good BUT OH MY LORD .... the wait ridiculous.. had reservations and they made us wait 2 hours. The hostesses were so so rude and security tried to be tough and act like the part I was with was making a scene and we weren't!!!! Oh and they wouldn't let us talk to the manager. If u talk to Theresa at the hostess stand don't trust her. She forgot about us and kept telling us a little longer. Theresa you should get a new job one that has NOTHING to do with dealing with customers and people.

Here's my pitch: These negative reviews are coming from NY Mets fans. All joking aside, this place is, by far my favorite spot to eat in the Bronx by an absolute land-slide. Here are a few must-haves: 1. Bacon appetizer 2. creamed-spinach 3. Filet mignon 4. Caesar salad Am I a Yankee fan? Of course. That is initially what led me here. After eating here though, I can say I am a legit fan of the food. Making reservations an hour prior to the game, having a delicious meal, catching the first inning or so on the screen, then walking out to the game has become a standard. The staff is always extremely friendly, and patrons consistently take the time to interact with my girlfriend and I as a simple display of decency and usually kinship in fandom. Can't recommend this place enough.

Can't understand the negative reviews. It's NYC, you're going to pay good money to eat at a nice place. The staff is the friendliest, most attentive ever. You don't ask for anything, they're everywhere and I just can't say enough good about them. Steaks are fantastic, shrimp cocktail perfect, French onion soup fantastic. I wish I got everyone's name - couldn't have been better! Highly recommend. The other thing I liked about it, you're not on top of everyone. There's actual space between tables. Love this place and will definitely return.

Took my wife for a quiet dinner before going to our seats for Tampa Bay game on 6/15.We put at a table near a large group of guys who were having a bachelor party.They were loud and cursing throughout our entire meal very vulgar.Instead of moving us or dealing with the problem the staff waited for another patron to lose it because of animalistic behavior.No apology only an explanation that it was a bachelor party.Maybe you should have cut them off and spoken to them before situation got out of control.A shame because food was fine but our night was ruined and Manager did not seem to care when I mentioned it.I work for a large company that is a major sponsor of my favorite team and would certainly not recommend the restaurant after this disgusting experience.I look forward to someone's attention of this matter.