Albert T.
Yelp
After a day exploring Traverse City, we were looking for a place to eat and after driving by Oakwood Proper Burgers not once, not twice, but three times going to various places, we decided - hey, might as well give them a try. As we stepped in this rainy day, we were greeted warmly at the counter and placed an order. The restaurant has three main seating areas - firstly the entrance area by the grill, then a number of seats outside, and finally a number of tables in the building across the patio. Since it was raining, the interior seating areas were quite full but we managed to squeeze in.
The person at the counter seemed quite used to seeing tourists eat there, as during our time there, we saw an additional 5 or 6 parties walk in and she gave the exact same spiel about the menu! We ended up just getting a single burger and a full order of fries, since she explained that the fries would be a full pound.
Oakwood ($15.50) - This is a smashburger patty that honestly isn't smashed that thin, but has great caramelization, forming a crisp crust along portions of the patty. It's cooked until past well done, making the burger a little on the dry side, even when adding in the moisture from the other ingredients. The burger is quite salty, and the added thick bacon (cooked well, but not shatteringingly so) makes everything even more salty. There's a slice of white cheddar cheese melted on top and a bit of caramelized onion, adding additional fat and sweetness. The patty is on a scant bed of shredded iceberg lettuce - really not much there and probably could be omitted without much difference. Everything is on a hand sliced bun which is nice and fluffy and has a buttery taste. The bun is baked just down the street at Old Mission Bakery. Overall the burger seemed to be a bit overpriced to me, but looking into it more it seems like it's due to the higher quality of the ingredients. The burger comes with a bag of chips as well. (4/5)
Garlic Parmesan Fries ($7.75) - This is at least a pound of freshly fried fries. They add a generous amount of lightly browned garlic (probably jarred pre-chopped garlic given the taste) and a large amount of shredded parmesan. The fries are served hot and the parmesan is able to melt to a stretch in some portions. The fries are crisp to start, but must be eaten fast, or they start to become limp. They are not overly salted which is well appreciated. The fries come with two small containers of Proper Sauce, which seems to perhaps be a mayochup with pickle relish added? There's ketchup available, which adds a hit of sweet flavor compared to the more creamy Proper Sauce. It's great to alternate the dips as you work though the mountain of fries. (4/5)
Overall we thought the food at Oakwood Proper Burgers was quite good and we would return in the future the next time we are in Traverse City.
Bathrooms - Single room behind the order counter.