Oath Pizza

This is one of the best pizza stores in the city and this is the only location in NYC for this franchise (as of 8/19/23). You can add a lot of toppings and do many customization. The service was great and in a timely manner. The servers were nice and friendly. They also have a restroom for their guests.

This is a wonderful pizza spot with a difference. Everything here tastes fresher and vibrant. It’s a good departure from the pizza norm with their own unique spin. Prices ($7-$12) here are reasonable as well and each full or half pizza tends to leave you filled up and wanting more the next day. The best part, you can pick your own ingredients if you want or just add to any of the tailored menu choices. They also have a unique soda machine and oh the choices on it. It felt like a flash back to the classic times mixed with modern. Menu options here ranges from known to unique. I especially love their desert cookie pizza, I usually be personalizing it with added chicken. Balances out the taste and you get some extra protein as well. They also have a salad and vegan option. The thing I like the most about them is the no artificial ingredients, the unique dough, environment, and the team. Shout to Maria and Jose, great and hard working team members at this location, as you can see by the pictures attached. If you’re still not convinced. Step in and ask about getting half off the first order. I did this and it got me hooked right away.

The dough is hand stretched, grilled and seared in avocado oil. This pizza shop is certified, ethically sourced and seasonally inspired. You can custom create your own pizza or select one of the many delicious options. They even offer a dessert pizza. The rewards program is outstanding! They also offer delicious gluten free dough!!! Try the new mushroom pizza!

The place was absolutely amazing. There’s a lovely vibe from every single employee, and it’s almost feels like the plexiglass separating the customer from the other side of the counter isn’t even there. One of the leads let us try an AMAZING desert which I highly recommend. Who knew cheese and chocolate went together so well??

Best pizza Eva!!! Okay so it’s on the healthier and on the fresh ingredients side and I like how they try to make it differently yet only making the flavors better. They are new to NYC and have only opened up in upper east and west( lucky those upper east/west siders) but they have these great hand pulled, thin crust and seared in avocado oil pizza base. The toppings are all super fresh straight from the farm. Would you say NO to such a pizza? Also, it tasted amazing. Do try the spicy chicken one. It’s so good. They have a new flavor called Bahn mi- I’m sure it’s good. They have a full pie for 11 I think and u can also do half and half of flavors. They serve cookie pizza which is a dessert pizza. That’s equally good. Fyi- it’s a thin crust pizza!!

I found out about Oath when I was walking in the neighborhood and an employee was giving out sample slices. The sample was excellent and I decided to order from them for the Thursday night football game where I was having colleagues over for dinner. I ordered a large cheese pizza with fresh mozzerella added to it. When the pizza arrived, I was surprised to see no cheese on the pizza, just the fresh mozzerella. Calling the restaurant was no help, as the kind woman who answered the phone told me “the manager said he gave you a generous amount of fresh mozzarella”. ??? While I agree that there is in fact a “generous amount of mozzerella”, I ordered the fresh mozzerella as an addition to a cheese pizza. It was incorrect. Oath offered no recourse of action outside of me coming to the restaurant, 20 blocks away, to get 5 dollars off. The subway fees alone cost more than that. Though the pizza order itself was wrong, it was still good. My only issues were with how the situation was handled.

Best gluten free (and vegan) pizza in the city! The banza crust is amazing, stays crunchy and has great consistency. My friends who don't have food allergies enjoyed eating my pizza as well, they said it was great. Oath also has regular pizza crush and cheese options! Fresh ingredients. Staff is super friendly. My online order got messed up and I went in and they without any issue made me a new pizza. The GM Marie was so kind and helpful. Highly recommend!

Would I go out of my way to eat here again? Probably not. Would I eat here again if I happened to be in the area? Absolutely. There are limited options in this area and their pizzas are creative, affordable, and are hand made with mostly fresh ingredients. It is a fast food type of chain but good for what it is. Also the workers were super friendly 👌