Julius D.
Yelp
I was told about this place sometime before the pandemic, summer of 2019 let us say. A buddy of mine who worked at the local liquor store, Matt, told me all about it and was further corroborated by another employee who also spoke positively about it.
So what is the Old Stein Inn? As the name suggests, it is a German-themed restaurant, complete with a 'biergarten' - literally 'beer garden' in German; an outdoor place where you can relax, eat and drink beer. It is actually very nice, outdoors, but secluded- there's greenery, the parking lot is just beyond the walls but it is still relatively quiet and more importantly, neat. There's an outdoor bar so you don't have to wait for someone to come from inside the restaurant to get your libations, and the full menu is available out there. When the weather's nice, it tends to fill up before the restaurant does. As I don't care to eat outdoors, we always opt for the inside bar area, which is small and cozy, with a few intimate booths and a dozen or so stools up to a bar that runs the length of the room. It is full service but of course they specialize in German type beers and liquors. If you've never had it, I suggest the pear schnapps chilled as a starter, with a Schwarzbier (lit. 'black beer') chaser. Be warned, the schnapps goes down easy and has a pleasant, slightly sweet pear flavor and you'll get a number of them down before you realize that maybe you should not have.
The menu is salted with German terms and German-inspired dishes; they feature a number of types of sausages- we're partial to the Bavarian Bauernwurst ourselves, which is a smoked pork sausage in natural casing (reminiscent of kielbasa) that is grilled, and served with German potato salad and sauerkraut. They make their own mustard there and it pairs perfectly with the sausage (or hot soft pretzel, we're fans of that as well). I opt for hand-cut inn fries instead of the potato salad, just because I like them better, though the salad is good as well.
So we more or less waited three years to try it and though we wish we'd tried it sooner, I'm glad that it is still open for business. As I said, we like to sit in the bar area; on weekends the bartender is usually Barry, a friendly, gregarious type that you find in good bars everywhere- knowledgeable about the menu and the array of beers and liquors and more than happy to answer questions and give opinions.
Since our first visit a few weeks ago, we've been back three times- it is quickly becoming a favorite watering hole that we have to save for the weekend since it isn't exactly close, but not so far away that the drive is onerous. We'd never been that far down Central Ave prior to visiting this place, it really is like another world down there. Quiet, quaint with a quality you normally see in lesser traveled parts of Maryland. By the water, a lot of the beaches are private access only, the public side is currently closed for construction; I could definitely picture living back up in there- quiet, tree-lined streets with water access. If that's your thing, you couldn't ask for more. Anyway, back to the Inn- if you like German-inspired food and drink with good service and a nice, lodge type of ambience, give the Old Stein Inn a try. You never know, we may even see each other, because we're definitely going back. I bet this place is hopping during Oktoberfest, can't wait to find out!