Cookie C.
Yelp
I've been Old Town Sarajevo's biggest fan since my first visit on 2012 - 12 years ago. I've brought friends and family here numeous times and recommended it to others. This restaurant has done no wrong.
Until tonight.
I haven't been in for quite a while. It is still adorably European and cute inside. We were greeted with a smile by a friendly server. There was only 1 other table with guests. The prices have gone up considerably since the last time I was here post-Covid. Everything has. But some of the items are 50% more expensive than they were. To be fair, the prices used to be VERY reasonable which was one of the reasons to love this place.
We placed our order: Pileci sendvic, Bosanski lonac, spinach and cheese pita and cheese pita. The server asked me what bread I wanted with my stew-grilled or fresh baked. The pita was the first to arrive. Now, pita is the item I have had the most times, both eat in and take out, from here. It has always been a fluffy golden brown with melted cheese inside. These were dark, dark brown to almost black in places yet, at least for the spinach and cheese pita, parts were actually cool to the touch and the cheese was not melted in either pita. Neither one was hot.
The Pileci Sendvic and the Bosanski Lonac were good, but not as rapturously good as in the past.
The server finally came to refill our waters when we each had about 1 bite left. When she returned with the water I asked for a takeout box because I would take the pita home and heat it properly. At this time we were the only 2 customers in the restaurant. Ten minutes later she still had not returned with the box so I walked around the corner to the counter where she was deep in conversation with a colleague and asked for the box. She brought it a few minutes later and cleared our plates. Clearly we were done. We waited some more then had to ask for our bill (maybe that is a European thing, though). When we got the bill, the Pilec Sendvic which was priced at $12.99 on the menu was $13.99 on the bill. The bread, which she had not mentioned was extra, was $1.50. I know, not much, but - please be upfront with your pricing. We did pay it without remarking.
After improperly prepared pitas, disappointing service (again, we were the only people in the place for 90% of our meal), and inaccurate pricing we walked out with a slightly bad taste in our mouths after 12 years of fabulousness.