Ollie's Slice Shop

At work we’ve ordered from them a few times, and I recently had the opportunity to pop in to grab a couple of slices. The pizza is top notch! I suggest the white pizza, the vodka sauce pizza, and the cheese for sure! Their vegetarian special and meat special changes but they always seem to be inventive and fun choices! Their salads are really good too! I took to go as the indoor space was very small and there wasn’t an available space to sit.

VEGAN PIZZA, by the slice or whole pie, whatever you want. Thin crust. I'm happy. Good service, Nice people. I'll be back.

Ollie’s Slice Shop is a gem! Their pizza slices are delicious, with a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The friendly service and cozy atmosphere make it a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. Highly recommend stopping by for a slice or two!

Delicious! Our new favorite pizza! The pizzas are huge, crispy crust, quality toppings! Love the black olive, tons of pepperoni. Our new regular spot

I want to like this place but the inconsistency between pies is awful. I've had it 4 times now and each time it was either pretty okay but paper thin (too thin if you ask me) or twice it's been burnt to a crisp on the crust and bottom side. It's also one of the more expensive pizza places in town. The inside of the place looks cool and also clean which is a plus and the people working there are very nice but I don't see how this place is talked up so much. I wish them the best but it's definitely not for me or most native kingston people I think.

Hoping it is a one off, our first few orders have been great. This past time, the pizza and garlic knots arrived cold. The salad was nearly inedible due to the bad and wilted lettuce that we were nervous to eat it. It is pricey but it was worth it…now, I can’t justify spending $55 on garlic knots, pizza, and a salad.

Quick and friendly service. Flavorful pizza. Crispy crust - plain and vodka are my go to.

Fridays are for pizza in my house and only Ollie’s is considered. Perfect slices and perfectly vegan. Calabrian chili and mushroom are my toppings of choice. Consistently great every time and so nice to not have to drive out to High Falls. Tied for second best vegan pizza in America.

If you're in the mood for a slice that's solid but not going to change your life, this place is a good shout. I tried a few different slices, and here's the rundown: the Roni Cups slice hits the mark with crispy, cupped pepperonis that have that perfect little crunch. It's not reinventing the wheel, but it's definitely satisfying. The Vodka slice is creamy and rich--kind of like pizza's version of comfort food--but not so mind-blowing that you'll be telling your grandkids about it. The White slice is pretty straightforward, with cheese and garlic doing their thing--definitely not bad, but also not something you'll cry over in joy. Pizza - Roni - 3.8 out of 5 White - 3.2 out of 5 Vodka - 3.9 out of 5 Crust a solid 3.5 out of 5 The vibe, though? That's where this place shines. The staff is friendly and welcoming, and the interior is so clean you might think it's a showroom for dish soap. Plus, the 90s hip-hop blaring through the speakers just adds to the chill, nostalgic vibe. So, while the pizza might not be the greatest slice of your life, it's far from the worst, and the whole experience is definitely worth it. Stop in and carb out!

Ok forgive me... I'm absolutely tots grumpy pants rolling in here.. this is gonna be a very short trip. Ordered a slice of Pepperoni & a Dr Pepper & holy moly! That's a spicy pepperoni lol, but delish. My Dr Pepper was completely mucked up... nahh! The combination is my first night of my new see-food diet yup. It was quite good! I took a ic & please remind me to leave them. Thanks. In the interim, thank you Doordash. Thank you tonight's Doordasher! But of everyone involved, Thank You Ollie's Slice Shop! While we kinda just met... umm yea. I'll be back. Which is a promise not a threat... I swear! Apparently I swear a lot. Apologies! Ok y'all it's getting really cold outside now & especially at night. Please make sure your heat is on, your animals inside & if you can help another out, please please do. It does our hearts & souls good to reach out to another. I'm so done for a while, but I thank you truly for your kind thoughts & that you take care wit yourself & your beloved's. So tonight I say goodnight & please, sleep with peace y'all please. Nite

A perfect place to grab a slice and satiate your pizza craving. Plenty of options and top notch ingredients. Cut from 20" pies - I could barely finish a second slice. I recommend the pepperoni as well as the vodka sauce. Ollie's is new to Kingston and although it's mostly a take-out spot there's seating for about 5-8 people inside. According to their menu, Ollie's offers salad, slices, hot subs, Sicilian style, and full pies. The staff is friendly and the service is fast. More expensive than your average restaurant, but you get what you pay for here. Highly recommended for some of the best NY pizza in the area. Delivery available within 5 miles.

This is easily Kingston's best pizza place. You get huge slices and the quality is perfect. This isn't your typical rubber cheese cardboard crust pizza you'd get in Kingston. They don't overdue it with the cheese or the sauce so each ingredient comes together perfectly. You get what you pay for so if you want great quality pizza you gotta come here. 10/10!

Really good toppings and sauce. They have vegan cheese and unlike most other places I don't think they charged extra for it. I wish the toppings were a little cheaper since I like to have a lot of different toppings but otherwise no complaints.

Small slice shop on Broadway with just a few tables to grab a slice. Prices are high for the quality. Regular cheese pie is decent: great crispy and flaky crust as a NY-style pie. The sauce could have been sweeter. Our white pie did not go over as well--just a lot of cheese. The vegan and gluten-free pie did not go over well either, as not having a lot of taste. I'd try the Vodka Sicilian slice next time since it looked great but otherwise would try other pizzerias.

the food was terrible. like how do you mess up a simple slice of pizza? everything was nasty and burnt, don't even get me started on the 100 billion pepperonis that are BURNT, NASTY, and OILY. the pizza was a good 1/10 the only good part of this nasty pizza was the cheese and it was very lackluster... do better. don't go here if you don't want your stomach to bubble and turn. this is not the best place in Kingston NY better off going to vincenzos!

the pizza got better! I just received delivery of a great vodka pie and was so happy they got it together. the salad was limp tho... but better than round 1!

The best pizza shops in the country don't charge this high for its pizza. You're in Kingston NY serving decent NY style slices. Prices are absurd

This place has fantastic pizzas, seriously the best tasting pies in kingston. Which brings me to why im not rating it higher, the price point, over 30$ for a large plain is ridiculous, and unfortunately for the same price you can get multiple pizzas of lesser quality elsewhere..which if you are trying to feed a family, makes a big difference. The staff is lovely and the individual slices are great (definitely how id recommend experiencing this place). If these folks start offering a weekly 2 for 20$ or something similar to every other place they would surely put themselves as a kingston institution. It's pizza folks, it shouldn't cost so much.

I don't know what all the hype is about. The pizza was dry and very unremarkable. I know classic, greasy, yummy Brooklyn pizza and specialty, creative, gourmet pizza and this was neither. The feng shui was horrible as well. Don't fall for the gaslighting.

Best pizza in Kingston hands down if not the entire Hudson valley. It's not cheap but they use very high quality ingredients and you can taste it. Classic slice shop vibe.

Overpriced hipster-ass pizza... very rude service unless you're already friends with the employees.

30 for a plain cheese pie ? Seriously ? 50 bucks for a pizza with a topping or two ? Absolutely ridiculous. Refuse to pay more for a pizza than I do for a plate at a high end local French spot .

I had a plain slice and a vodka slice today (pizza Friday of course). Seriously good pizza. The cheese and sauce both had a ton of flavor - the vodka sauce even better. Nice thin crust, good char. One of the best around now. Pure pizza - cheese for me! I had never been to their place in High Falls but passed it many times. I'm sorry now that I missed out all that time.

Like others have said...this is definitely a slice shop. I picked up a whole pizza to go for my girlfriend and I. Nothing crazy, just one of their 'special' pizzas. Including the 20 percent tip I left, the total was over 50 dollars....for a single pizza!!! The pizza is decent but nothing better than the 30 other pizza places that are available to order from..I must be missing something to justify the outrageous price...Maybe the owners are counting on the city people coming here and not balking at the price..I don't know...Locals should avoid! I should add that I am a local and have worked in local restaurants since I was 16, I'm 34 now, so I have a bit of a bead on the local restaurant scene.

Unfortunately after spending almost $50 on a meatball and black olive pizza I came to the conclusion that the olives were definitely expired as they tasted as if an entire bottle of Morton salt was dumped on top of it. This horrible salty flavor was baked throughout the pie and I ended up having to throw the whole thing out!

The food is good and the pizza is crispy but the menu is unclear in that it says TOPPINGS and goes on to reveal that these toppings can only be put on whole or half pies.. why? idk but the pizza is good

Great slice shop, reminds me of a small version of Paulie Gee's in Brooklyn. Enjoyed the Sicilian and two specials they had - a broccoli pesto and one with hot peppers and diced bacon. Imaginative and a great NYC style slice. Only a handful of seats inside - this is not a place to sit down for very long which may have thrown off some other reviewers. But I think it's one of the best NYC-style slice places in this area.