Gordon Y.
Yelp
Cuisine: 6
Service: 9
Decor: 7
Value: 8
Overall: 7
I will say that I came into this omakase for one reason and one reason only. A post on FB showed one of their soft opening courses to be Shirako (Cod Milt), which I absolutely love. It is something you will never see at any run of the mill sushi omakase restaurants. Therefore, I immediately contacted the owner and booked six seats for Friday night and canceled the original sushi omakase reservation my group already had elsewhere, opting for a new experience instead.
Long story short, a few more friends wanted to join the party and we ended up reserving the entire sushi bar for 12. Almost everyone coming were sushi veterans who have eaten hundreds (probably thousands) of sushi omakase combined, including some of the best around the world, so it was a real tough crowd to please.
Let me start off by saying, the owner Chee was extremely kind and did everything he could to source shirako for my group that night. We had messaged prior to the meal when I reserved seats and he said that he would do his best. Though Chee failed to procure the shirako, he was able to secure my favorite fish - Nodoguro (Black Throat Sea Perch), which he included as part of the omakase. He didn't have to, I would have paid extra considering it is a very expensive fish. His efforts and generosity were much appreciated. Service is not just measured during a meal.
Before I go any further, here is a breakdown of our $99 omakase on 11/22/2024 below.
Appetizers:
Monkfish Liver & Scallop w/ Caviar
Octopus & Ikura
Kumamoto Oysters
Snow Crab, Uni, Ikura in Rice Cracker
Nigiri:
Madai (Sea Bream) - lime zest, sea salt
Shima Aji (Striped Jack) - ginger, garlic chip
Kinmedai (Golden Eye Snapper) - ginger, scallion
Botan Ebi (Spotted Prawn) - wasabi stem
Masunosuke (King Salmon) - foie gras, onion sauce
Hamachi (Yellowtail) - fried shishito pepper
Akami (Lean Bluefin Tuna) - truffle
Nodoguro (Black Throat Sea Perch) - mustard seed
Otoro (Fatty Bluefin Tuna) - chop toro, uni, caviar
Hokkaido Uni (Sea Urchin)
Interlude:
Foie Gras, Chopped Toro, Peach on Toast
Nigiri:
Hotate (Scallop) - yuzu jelly, rice puff
Japanese A5 Wagyu (Beef) - scallop, uni, caviar
Dessert:
Pana Cotta w/ Caramel Sauce
As you can see, the patrons get a huge variety of seafood for the price. The quality of the ingredients were also relatively good. The chef does not seem to cure or age any of his fish, but everything was fresh.
With that said, my group thought that there is plenty of room to improve for Omakase Omukaa to be considered a sushi destination. The first thing is the all important rice. Texture, seasoning, acidity, and temperature all need slight adjustments. Another is to allow the main ingredient to shine and not be masked by the sauce or too many unnecessary pairings.
I have shared these details and other small tips with Chee and thankfully he is very receptive. I have already seem some things I mentioned put into action. An owner who listens to his customers is the kind of person who I want to support.
Given time, I truly hope that this establishment finds a foothold in the competitive world of sushi omakase in NYC. I sincerely wish the restaurant good luck and hope it becomes successful.