Aaron Lehrman
Google
The Tuesday Smash Burger special was good.
If you are reading this just after I posted it, know that the prices are fluctuating and may not be accurate.
- Smash Burger - $15: The two high quality smash patties about 4oz each (my guess).  They were well seasoned with an emphasis on pepper.  The pepper was not sharp, but it was deep.
The cheese was great.  The toppings were well balanced, though I might have added a touch more.  The lettuce texture was particularly wonderful.  I asked for no pickle and the waitress recommended getting the fancy sauce on the side since it is pickle based (good call).
The Nantucket brioche bun was AMAZING (as usual).  I’ve had Nantucket bread at multiple other restaurants and look for them now.  It was soft, full, and kept the burger together well.
- California Garlic Fries - $3 extra: Slightly smaller cut, deeper pepper flavor, a tad too much salt for my tastes, but overall the fries were amazing, cooked perfectly, and hot all the way to the end.  There was a generous amount of fries, too.  It made the $3 extra worth it!
- Old Nation | Oktoberfest:  Came free with the Tuesday special for the Smash Burger.
- Tuesday Special: According to the website, “Every Tuesday, get our Classic Smash Burger and a brew for only $14.”  When I asked about this, it was actually $15 and said that the website was not updated.  I just checked the website again after and it was still listed as $14.  I was charged $15 + $3 for the fries I asked for.  They stick to their prices even when you correct them.
They also had pierogies on the menu and I’d like to try them sometime!
- Service: Very attentive, positive, and helpful.  She caught that I did not care for pickles and recommended getting the fancy sauce on the side (she was right).  We did not wait long for anything and our burger arrived in less than 15 minutes.  Overall, great service!
- Atmosphere: Higher class, clean, organized, but plenty of people were in street clothes.  The lighting was darker, medium loud, but plenty good for private conversation.  There were booths, but mainly only larger ones.  There was also a bar, taller tables and chairs as well as standard high ones,
- Conclusion: Good burger.  I like pepper, so it was enjoyable for me.  I think the prices were fair for the quality, service, and pleasant atmosphere.  I’d recommend them.
Visited at 7pm on a Tuesday.