Leora B.
Yelp
This place came up on my feed the other day and I realized I haven't been back since 2020! Reading my review made me just HAVE to return. My husband and I got the pirogies again for a starter and I have to say I don't like the new ones as much as the pirogies of 2020. They are now coming with a side of caramelized onions with sour cream. I miss the creamy cheese they had before. I still love the fresh slaw, it is still a fresh and light addition. I'm sad about the number of pirogies. As a couple we usually share a an appetizer, in 2020 there were 4 and now there are 3. No biggie though. I'm full at the end of the meal sooo meh. For the main I had the Michigan pear salad with grilled chicken and hubs had the smash burger. If you're deciding between the two, get the smash burger! That burger was messy and juicy and so yummy!! The fries were over salted however. The salad was over dressed and the char on the chicken overpowered even the overdressed salad. The main flavors were char and vinegar based dressing. The server promptly offered to take it back and get me something else but I can't and won't waste food that is perfectly edible no matter how much I don't prefer the flavor. The ambiance is on point! It is upscale, classy, and intimate. Service gains 5 stars today, ambiance 5 stars, cleanliness 5 stars, food freshness 5 stars, quality will be 3 stars due to the salad but if I had ordered a smash burger with my husband it old be 4 stars due to the salty fries. Anyway I think it's fair to say One Twenty Three Tavern is still pulling out an average of 5 stars. Great job guys. Can't wait to come back and try the French Dip. Hopefully sooner than 2030.