Original Antonio's

This is a cozy little pizzeria on the island, full of charm, with lots of fun historic decor hanging all over the walls and even the ceiling. You have two options: dine in or grab a slice. I chose to dine in and it did not disappoint me. My waiter was a lovely kind lady who made my short stay very pleasant. I ordered a small pizza with mushrooms and a garden salad. The salad was very basic yet fresh and I enjoyed it, however, I wish there were more mushrooms on the pizza. As the photo says it all, there are a few canned mushroom pieces sporadically spread on the pizza. The crust was very much to my liking, neither thick nor thin, perfect thickness. The sauce was fresh and the cheese was very fresh and delicious. Overall, it was a very pleasant experience and highly recommend giving this place a try.

The garlic bread with dipping sauce was great. The sauce was sweet at first and then just the smallest bit spicy. Everyone at the table agreed it was great. The drinks have the crunchy kind of ice which is satisfying to chew. The pepperoni pizza was ready quickly and was perfectly cooked. We especially liked the crust and the amount and kind of cheese they used. The cheese had a proper cheese string "pull", which I'm not sure how much that translates to better taste, but this pizza was great. One of the young pizza lovers in our group says it was the best pizza he's ever had. He wishes the cook would give out the recipe.

Visited on a Monday night with a group of 10. Were about to be seated right away but was some mixup with another customer who had seemingly been waiting 20 minutes for a table (they must've forgotten). Split our group up between a few tables inside and outside. Service was a little strange/not smooth. Food was good - pepperoni pizza, garlic cheese bread, and small antipasto salad to split amongst 3 people. Plenty of food, took home leftovers. Prices to be expected for area. Would recommend for a simple pizza/Italian meal. They also had slices to go.

I absolutely loved this place! The pizza was delicious, and the service from Katy made the whole experience even better — she’s the best! Highly recommend this spot.

The establishment had a stylish interior, and the service was exceptional. The pizza was especially enjoyable, with a crisp and well-prepared crust that we truly appreciated.

Want one of the best pizza's ever made....PERIOD? Get a chicken, garlic, and roasted red pepper with alfredo sauce. Hands down the best pizza I have ever eaten. YUMMY

I really enjoyed the pizza here, and after a weekend in Avalon, I’d say this was definitely one of my favorite spots. We had the antipasto salad, some hot wings, and a turkey bacon club sandwich, and everything was a hit — no complaints at all! If you’re looking for a quick and tasty bite, this is definitely a place to try.

Best pizza i’ve ever had in my life. Number one. You have to try it😍, friendly people. They all smile in your face.