Samantha N.
Yelp
Let me be honest. As I was researching the in and outs of Mackinac Island so I could plan our days and write out a checklist, fudge was mentioned non stop. Seriously, the love of fudge was real here on Mackinac Island as there are fudge shops literally steps from each other.
Being who I am, I had to try "the original" first and foremost. I thought it was over hyped but as I walked towards this shop, the aroma of real fudge wafted into my senses and I knew I had to spend my money here.
Are you skeptical? Try a free sample! As they spread, scrape, fold, and cut the delectable and smooth fudge, there are pieces you can taste freshly from the marble table. We were fortunately enough to try Double Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt, Double Chocolate Dark, and Chocolate Pecan. Well, fortunate as in we kept going in there to buy more haha! It was not a fluke. We even went to other fudge shops to sample theirs and then we had to come back to "the original".
Yes, it's just THAT good. We went two days and then we also ordered fudge and had it shipped to our family members. Don't miss out on this yummy slice of Mackinac Island's fudge that has been a part of their history!
Our favorites:
Hubby: Triple Chocolate Espresso
Myself: Double Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt & Espresso
Maddy (12 yo): Double Chocolate Dark & Espresso
James (7 yo): Chocolate Mint
Linc (3 1/2 yo): Chocolate Cherry