Michael S.
Yelp
There's a thoughtful imagination at work in the kitchen at Ottenthal, that, combined with a well-trained and focused crew, delivers well-prepared, delicious, food with surprising touches, complemented by excellent wines from Ottenthal's list. My wife and I were so delighted with our first dinner at Ottenthal that we booked a second meal there during our three days in Berlin.
The restaurant itself is a long, narrow room, a warm, comfortable space with a bar at one end where you might want to consider dining if the restaurant is full, as it was both nights were there. On our first visit, we joined a few other couples and large groups of families and friends: it felt like we were slipping into a friendly, neighborhood scene. On our second visit, the restaurant was full of large groups of businesspeople attending a trade show in the city. Both nights, though, service was friendly and our servers spoke decent English, compensating for our non-existent German.
From the reviews I read, I expected good-quality food and Ottenthal delivered. But beyond being tasty and well-prepared, our meals had many unexpected touches that showed that someone in the kitchen was paying attention to more than just quality preparation. Here's an example: at our second meal, my wife ordered noodles with chanterelles. The dish was not only delicious, but it was beautifully garnished with herbs that complemented the richness of the (cream) sauce that dressed the noodles. At our first meal, we both had Arctic Char that was accompanied by an arugula pesto and a fresh salad of frisee, arugula, and other greens. Not simply a garnish, the salad was a crunchy and slightly bitter contrast to the perfectly cooked and more unctuous fish. That night, my meal opened with a salad of wild, bitter greens that included arugula, chervil, and a number of herbs and lettuces that I couldn't identify. All I know is that they were delicious.
At our second meal, I ordered the Chicken Supreme--a seasoned, lightly breaded and fried chicken breast served with that mixed frisee salad and delicious, light herb dumplings. The chicken was not only perfectly cooked and juicy, but it was totally greaseless.
We're fans of Austrian wines and I was delighted to find so many great choices on Ottenthal's list. Dozens of vintages of gruner veltliners, blaufrankisch, and zwiegelts, along with blends. On our second visit, we enjoyed a 2011 Meinklang Graupert, made from grapes raised in a vineyard that hasn't been pruned or weeded. There's a wine store in the restaurant where you can pick up something that catches your fancy.
Many of the dishes are made from organic ingredients and the wine list features organic and biodynamic wines.