Katie V.
Yelp
I ended up at PJ Leahy's because I was in LIC to take photos of the Manhattan skyline on a Saturday night and happened to notice that it wasn't unbearably busy as I walked past, but also wasn't empty. I'm not a fan of crowds and I purposely seek out bars with available seating and a seemingly laid-back customer base. Based on what I observed from peering through the entrance, PJ Leahy's appeared to fit the bill, so I decided to give them a try.
I sat at the bar and was tended to right away. I ordered a seabreeze with citrus vodka and started a tab. In addition to being courteous and prompt, the bartender was friendly. Her sister also works there and was equally amicable.
Fellow customers, several of whom I later learned are regulars, were very welcoming and included me in their discussions. I had gone into PJ Leahy's expecting to hook up to their Wi-Fi and play on my phone all evening, and it was a pleasant surprise to engage in face-to-face conversation - something that is a true hit-or-miss in NYC bars. While I don't always enter a bar with intentions to socialize, the down-to-earth atmosphere here was an unexpected bonus.
My original plan was to have a few cocktails here and move onto another bar, but I ended up enjoying myself enough to stay for the remainder of my evening. As the night wore on, it became pretty crowded, but maintained a relaxed atmosphere.
The drink prices here are extremely reasonable. When I closed out my tab, I was surprised by how low it was.
There are a few things to keep in mind about PJ Leahy's. First and foremost, it is very obviously frequented by off-duty law enforcement. If you have something to hide or don't want to be around cops, it's probably a good idea to avoid the place.
Moreover, PJ Leahy's is a no-frills establishment. I didn't try the food. It looked and smelled pretty good, but based on observation, if you're expecting something beyond typical bar cuisine, I'd recommend going elsewhere. I was attracted to this bar because of its subdued and simple appearance - something many people seek the exact opposite of. It's not a place I would suggest to tourists or people craving an upscale experience.