Paisano's Pizza

TASTE (8/10): The pizza was actually good. Both the dough and the toppings worked well. I wouldn’t say it was phenomenal but definitely one of the better ones I had in the area. Garlic knots? Meh. You won’t write home about them. PRICE (7/10): Neither cheap nor pricey. Just sits on that neutral fence, sipping coffee. SERVICE (6/10): I had to wait way longer than I should. Are they secretly feeding a football team in the back? Not a tragedy, but also not cute. ATTITUDE (8/10): Staff were nice. Not “besties-for-life” nice, but pleasant. PLACE (7/10): Basic setup. Not a palace but not a dungeon either. Easy to find, parking available. CLEANLINESS (8/10): Clean enough to not think twice before eating. That’s always a win. ADDITIONAL FEES/HIDDEN COSTS (10/10): Nope. Thank you for being normal. OVERALL IMPRESSION: A solid choice if you’re hungry and nearby. Just don’t expect a pizza epiphany.

We love Paisano’s Pizza before their recent move to their new location. Now with the new sit down option, it is even better!

Me and my family have been to many different pizza restaurants but this has been the best one. The food is really delicious. The pizza is nice and crispy. The service was amazing the employees are really kind and polite. Overall the place is really good and everything looks put together. We will be coming back here.

Awesome new location for the Paisano's in Fair Lakes. The move to over near UPS Store, Starbucks and Kohls is a much needed refresh, provides more parking and less congestion than the previous location. The store now has ample seating, a drink fountain and the ability to order on touch screens inside. Happy for this team and location!!

Paisano’s is hands down my go-to pizza spot! The food is always fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. You can really taste the quality in every bite—from the crispy crust to the delicious toppings. But what truly makes this place stand out is the service. I had the pleasure of being helped by Manuel, and he went above and beyond to make my experience great. He was welcoming, attentive, and made sure everything came out just right. It’s rare these days to find someone who genuinely cares about the customer experience, and Manuel definitely does. If you’re craving amazing pizza and top-notch service, Paisano’s is the place. Ask for Manuel—you’ll be glad you did!

We stopped in for lunch for the first time and had such a wonderful experience! The front staff went above and beyond with their kindness and hospitality. Our food came out quickly and was perfect. Special thanks to Leticia, the manager on duty, for taking the time to chat with us—she made our visit even better. Can’t wait to come back!

Very inviting and helpful staff helped me all the way through my order and the food was great.

Glad that Paisano's opened this Fair Lakes branch because it's very close to my work. Service is great. Food servings are huge, filling and tasty. They have lunch specials and other mix & match combo, too. My favorite is their boneless chicken bites and chicken parm!