Pancho's Antojitos Mexicano

Mexican restaurant · Upper West Side

Pancho's Antojitos Mexicano

Mexican restaurant · Upper West Side

964 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025

Highlights

At Panchos Antojitos on the Upper West Side, casual vibes meet hearty burritos and tacos bursting with flavor, making it a go-to for tasty, no-fuss meals.

964 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025 Get directions

$10–20

@infatuation

"You’ve been hitting the books, hard, all day long, and now it’s 8:30pm and you realize you have absolutely nothing for dinner, and a long night of studying ahead of you. You could end up spending way too much on delivery, or you could walk down to 107th and Amsterdam and get a torta from Panchos Antojitos. The cheese is creamy and gooey, the bread is crusty, and it’ll run you $10. If you’re a bit hungrier, grab a burrito, stuffed with rice, beans, and your choice of meat. The tortilla is the star here—it’s chewy, flaky, and crunchy from where it hit the griddle. " - willa moore, sonal shah, neha talreja, will hartman

The Best Restaurants Near Columbia University

View Postcard for Pancho's Antojitos Mexicano

@infatuation

"Every time we’ve visited Panchos Antojitos, a counter-service spot with a few tables on the Upper West Side, we’ve encountered people who rush in looking flustered, order a carne asada burrito or a chicken torta, and walk out with a smile on their face. We’re coining them the “I can’t believe I forgot to buy groceries and now it’s 8pm” customers. But these people have good instincts, because Panchos Antojitos is extremely reliable, has warm, chewy flour tortillas, their meats are well-seasoned, and food comes out fast. So whether you’re grabbing Panchos to fuel up for a trip back to the library, or just heading home after a long day at work, the spot is fast, reliable, and satisfying. Food Rundown photo credit: Will Hartman Burrito Definitely ask for salsa verde with your burrito, no matter the meat you choose. These big-boy burritos cost $14, but they’re massive, filled with rice and beans, and served with a salad. photo credit: Will Hartman Torta We’d recommend these for the Oaxaca cheese alone. It’s gooey, it’s stretchy, it’s creamy, and it perfectly blankets whatever meat you go for (we like al pastor, with little chunks of grilled pineapple)." - Will Hartman

Panchos Antojitos Mexicanos Review - Upper West Side - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Pancho's Antojitos Mexicano

Matthew Magardino (Matthew Magardino)

Google

Has that real authentic mexican food that is hard to find in the city. Its not some $15 for 2 tiny taco kind of place. Got the queso birria tacos and it was pretty amazing. Definitely cheesy and a bit greasy but the birria dip was awesome. Next time ill probably get a burrito but worth trying the birria Atmosphere is good i like having the grill right in front, but definitely not upscale or anything. I like holes in the wall places

Linda M

Google

Think NYC diner with Mexican food options: American breakfast, burgers, salads, sandwiches pizza, gyro, Mexican omelets, tacos, burritos, torta, coffee, etc. My lengua torta ($11) was average in size and taste; meat was very tender. Dining partner’s taco was fresh tasting but not cheap at $4.50 for chicken. The 2 eggs with toast was over priced at $8.50 (should have been like $4-5). Due to hi cost/avg value, I doubt I would return with so many options in the neighborhood. Feb 2024

Dan Rosen

Google

For vibes and atmosphere and the energy and warm smile of the man behind the counter, it’s 5 stars. But the food — at least the night I went — was, quite simply, boring, bland, and basking in mediocrity. Every dish we ordered was clearly missing a healthy dosing of salt. The green hot sauce is tasty and definitely helped, but it lacks any real depth of flavor and is so thin & watery that it was easy to forget it was even there. The tortilla chips were delicious and hand-fried to order (these were unsalted, I prefer either orientation). But the rest of the meal tasted like nothing that I couldn’t make at home. At least I would remember to season my meal. I can’t speak to the authenticity of the food because I don’t know all the intricacies and intimacies of different styles of Mexican cooking and cuisine. But for my palette and for my money, I would much rather go somewhere — anywhere — else.

Andrew Leach

Google

Love, Love Pancho's. Zero pretentiousness, friendly staff. The star of the show is the food. Every dish is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients that burst with flavor in every bite. I particularly love the overstuffed tacos, which are filled with generously portioned meats that are perfectly seasoned. And if you're in the mood for something a little more substantial, the entrees are just as delicious. And the prices are more than fair for the quality of the food you're getting, especially when compared to some of the overpriced chains in the area.

Samik Andhare

Google

Best tortas I’ve ever had! Great service.. love this place!

Meagan Bender

Google

The chicken taco was so good that I came back the next day and had an al pastor and chicken taco. Friendly service, cozy atmosphere, fantastic food. If I get the joy of staying in this area again, I'll be back 😊

Jason

Google

These are the BEST tacos in uptown IMO. I'm so glad I found this place! The hot sauce is amazing, and every taco is fantastic.

Diego Lorenzo

Google

Top notch mexican breakfast. Highly recommend it. Vegetarian burrito and chorizo and Oaxaca cheese omelette were excellent. Omelet comes with a ration of potatoes and two slices of bread. Perfect to get some energy before exploring Harlem.