Nhi B.
Yelp
3.5 Stars
A glamorous piece of Boston's history! The moment you step into the hotel, you can definitely see why the Omni Parker House is a relic of Boston's elite past with it's beautiful drapes, tall ceilings, and grand decor. You definitely feel transported.
I've wanted to check out the birthplace of the Boston Creme Pie ever since I moved here and it seemed opportunistic when we found Travelzoo deal ($69, dinner for two -- two apps, two entrees, two desserts). It was simple to make the reservation and we arrived on Saturday at 7pm.
Our server was really nice. She came, got our orders promptly, and checked on us throughout entire night. I had read reviews of the spotty service, so it was a pleasant surprise. Water service was also good; they refilled the glasses before they even emptied. The bread was a bit slow, but it was a busy night.
We ordered oysters and crab cakes as our appetizers; lobster tails and filet mignon as our entrees; and Boston Creme Pie (of course) and strawberry cheesecake for dessert.
The apps were pretty good and came out quickly; though they had the feel of being rushed. My oysters were very fresh and came with a mignonette sauce and (homemade?) cocktail sauce. However, they didn't give me a spoon to scoop any of the sauces, so I had to get creative with a fork (not helpful the vinegar-y mignonette). The quality was good; execution was just rushed. The crab cake was full of crab and it was super tasty.
We both also enjoyed our entrees. The lobster was a little small, but as it isn't lobster season, that's on me. The filet was tender and cooked perfectly. When the server came by to drop it off, though, some asparagus fell on the ground and it wasn't replaced. So, not a big deal, but...
Dessert was okay. I really liked the Boston Creme Pie. The cake itself was super fluffy and the frosting was just the right amount of sweetness. I also liked the texture that the chopped almonds gave the cake. I can see why this cake is their trademark. The cheesecake was a bit disappointing; it was very close-textured and had a stale quality to it.
Overall, it was a good meal and I'm glad we had it for such a steal; but, I wouldn't go back if I had to pay full price because it didn't really compare to other places in its "bracket". There wasn't anything outstanding that really justified the price-tag for me. Hence, the 3.5 star rating.
Pro-Tip: If you only want the Boston Creme Pie, go to the bar!