Pasquale's

Their Valhalla Salad (with grilled chicken) is one of my favorite salads in town. Always delicious and fresh, and the flavor combo is delish. I’m allergic to bleu cheese and there have been a couple times where I ask for either none or for it to be on the side (my fiancé will eat it) and they’ve still put it on the salad or just taken it out of the salad when I mention it wasn’t supposed to have it. That’s the only “issue” I’ve really ever had with them. Their Margherita Pizza is our favorite in town and whenever we’re craving a Margherita pie, this is where we order it from. It’s the perfect thickness and sooo tasty

I love Pasquale’s! They pizza is always so fresh, cheesy, and delicious! We have had tried many different pizzas and they all are amazing and homemade. I also love their soups in the winter and their chicken parm meal is amazing! Small place to sit. Super fresh and quick pizza!

Our favorite! Pasquale’s never disappoints. The owner and staff are very friendly every time we call or pop in. They even made an extra special pizza for my son’s birthday that made his day. Whether by the slice or whole pies delivered: it is always fresh and melt in your mouth delicious.

Took the family on a road trip from Texas to Boston and we got hungry so we checked online for a local pizza place as we were driving through. Well, I can say that we were VERY happily surprised! This place is not only super clean, and nice. The people were very kind and it had that small town, family run, local spot kinda feel. The pie was great and the atmosphere was just as great. Super fun little spot with good food, can't complain and if were were ever back in the area, we would eat here again!

Pizza was great, but chairs are not made for big butts. Limited seating. No fountain drinks, just bottled sodas. Not complaining, just letting you know. Even though my ass doesn't fit in the chairs, I'd still eat inside again.

The pizza at this store is awesome...the crust is light and crispy with a unique coating of crunch...the sauce is tasty and a little sweet...this combo makes for a truly one of a kind pizza experience!

Parking can be a little tricky for Pasquale's, use the side street as main street at this intersection can be a little hectic. I loved the bar stools by the window to grab a quick slice. This is a popular local pizzeria that makes a good slice. The cheese seems to speak to you the most as far as the most defining characteristic. The girl behind the counter was really nice and was working hard at quality customer service. I would give it 3.5 stars and would come back again..

Came here for pizza with my toddler. Staff was really nice and cut the pizza into small pieces for my son. The pizza was amazing. I will come here again

A terrific local spot that we love. Great food by great people!! We stop in often. The veal is our favorite.

Tony is an absolute delight, the pizza is phenomenal and the service is great, a must stop if you're in the area!

I really like their pizza, especially the chicken bacon ranch! Nice crispy bottom and a tasty crust.

I'm visiting my cousin and picked up a pepperoni pie. I almost didn't see the building and it could be tough to find parking around here. There was a lot of pepperoni and it was delicious. The prices seem reasonable, the service was quick and the pizzeria was clean. There's a few tables if you want to eat there. If your new to the area or just visiting, you're probably trying to figure out if you should get Roma's or Pasquales and I can tell you I've had both and they're both really good pizza, you can't go wrong.

Heard this place has been open 30 years today from the owner. It was once an antique shop. Passing by you can't tell it's open, except for the lights on inside. No "open" sign anywhere. Kinda unkept but not messy or dirty. Can't see what slices are available, except grandma and Sicilian. Soup of the day is written on a paper plate held by a magnet on the soda machine. Grandma pie was good but not what I'm used to. It was just a square piece of pizza with chunks of tomato and Parmesan cheese on it. The cheese slices were good. Tasted good. Very oily but the cheese tasted good. Large selection of bottled soda. Pizza boxes crowd the front windows. I enjoyed the pizza. I will be back and yes I recommend this place. It should get 5 stars for quality of food but everything else deserves only 4 stars.

I enjoyed my slices, and the ambiance is pretty cute! I stopped in at 2:30 on a Saturday to find one other guy waiting for his full-size pie and garlic bread. I was served my two pepperoni slices right away, and consumed them both while sitting at a charming window facing the street. I really wish they had the slices out for inspection. They keep a grandma pie and Sicilian pie ready, but too far for short old me to see. They also have a plain pie that they hide somewhere if you'd like cheese or pepperoni. There was just a hint of crunch on the tip of each slice, which was easily the highlight. Pepperoni flavor came through. That said, it was really oily. I blotted everything with napkins a few times before consuming. It'd be a toss-up for me between Pasquale's and Roma the next time I'm in Boonton.

My kids favorite pizza place. We do at lest once a week take out. Reasonably priced.

Pizza here is good as long as you don't order it by the slice. You'll notice they dont advertise pizza by the slice in the front like most places. The slices they have in the back are old and not worth it, definitely order new. Service isn't the best the owner and his cooks give you crazy stares as if you weren't a customer or something.

Well, we love the pizza but after tonight & the "service" I received, I'll never order from them again. The website for online ordering asks when you want your order. You can select ASAP, the normal send it when it's ready, or "later today" - or even another day all together. I selected "later today" and chose 6:15 as the time. My pizza order, to my surprise, arrives over an hour early. At 5:04. First of all, it's a good thing I was even home, and second, now the food will be cold by the time I get to eat it. When I called the restaurant to ask why, the woman who answered the phone HUNG UP ON ME after I finished saying "My delivery order for later was delivered really early" - she didn't give me a chance to say anything else and she didn't say anything other than to answer the phone. Is that really how you all treat people? Unacceptable. Even good food doesn't make up for terrible treatment of customers.

we ordered 2 subs, one was a meatball park and the other a sausage parm. there was no sauce on either sub. the sausage had been cooked too long that it was all dried out and the meatballs tasted like bread. on top of that they charged almost 20 bucks for each of them. no thanks!

When you come into this town you have to check out this pizza spot. First we went on a waterfall hike down the street which was amazing. Then we were so hungry we looked up restaurants that were in the area and we found this little gem. The owner or manager Tony, was so amazing he asked us what we were in the mood for and told us all about his menu. We ordered a medium margarita pizza, garlic bread, tiramisu and a cannoli. We waited about 15 minutes and Tony came outside to make sure that we didn't have to come back inside and wear this mask that we all Envy. We received the food with plates napkins and everything hot and fresh. We then drove back down to the area where we did our hike and found a bunch of picnic tables and sat. We opened our box of pizza and stuffed our faces. By far this is the best pizza I've had since I've been to Italy and that was in 2018, so when I say I recommend this place 100% to the fullest recommend this place. Please do not miss this place in this cute amazing town. Good JOB TONY! Great place and people.

We bought a group of Girl Scouts here after a hike. The pizza is fabulous. The Grandma is first rate, as is the white pizza. The plain and the Margarita also did not disappoint. The staff and owner were very friendly as well.

I LOVE Pasquale's. They have some good pizza. This is the first time I've ordered their Sicilian and I am rather disappointed. First, the pizza is thin, especially for Sicilian pizza. Second, for some reason there is sauce on top of the pepperoni. I do not mind the extra cheese, but no sauce on top of the pie please. We had to use our pizza cutter since it was not cut all the way through. Sauce too sweet. I'll be getting their normal pizza from now on.

I have to say the Grandmas style pizza here was overly satisfying. I loved it! I took my girlfriend back the next week to try it out. They use crushed tomatoes I think making it a little bit more hardy. The service was fine all though it seemed like they had a new employee working. She was bright and positive which is all you could ask for in a pizza joint. I DID find a couple things comical inside this place but I won't mention them. lol. Also the town of Boonton is really neat. Go here.

Best Sicilian and Grandma pizza around!! Highly recommend for takeout as there are only a few tables for dining in. A must place to order the best pizza in the area!

Fantastic mom and pop pizzeria. Amazing pizza and ridiculous tiramisu. Right in the middle of a nice little trendy "Main Street" style downtown area.

This tiny little gem is tucked away at the very start of Main Street. We participated in a dinner to go night here for my school district and wow...I know now the portions are huge. I have chicken parm (tender and delicious and not my favorite Italian dinner but would definitely order their version again) and my biggest test...pink (vodka sauce is NOT red) creamy vodka sauce tossed in penne for days! Excellent food at a reasonable price, definitely will order again.

The best pizza I've had in 4 years. Possibly the best in North Jersey. Got a "grandma's pie" take out with a side salad and it was perfectly cooked, not too greasy since I ate a slice in the car on the way home. So flavorful, I wanted to down a second slice while driving. High quality cheese, tomato and crust! I thank you, and assure you there will be no leftovers.

Quality food!! Great atmosphere! AWESOME employees! Really make you feel like family just walking in the door! I'll be a regular from now on!

I've decided to pit the two best-reviewed pizzerias in Boonton against each other. Pasquale's was up first. Shots fired. I ordered a bacon mushroom pie - Top of the Park doesn't even have bacon. Great thin crust, the right amount of cheese, generous toppings, plenty of bacon - actual strips, not bits. The sauce is flavored just right. This is pizza. The only downside is it's a bit hard to park there for pickup and dining space is quite limited. The interior is completely old-school NJ pizzeria, walk in and you're already at the counter. Friendly staff inside too. This is going to be tough to beat, or even match. But I'm not opposed to ranking two competitors both with 5 stars if it comes to it. Your move, Park.

Pasquale's is the best pizza in town, I would agree - but right over the border is Reservoir Tavern, who has legendary pizza. I used to order all the time from Res Tavern, but I've since switched over totally to Pasquale's. Why? Simple. I can get just as good of a pizza (or better!) from Pasquale's without waiting an hour to go pick it up, without having to virtually crowd surf to get to the cash register, and easier parking. Pasquale's has a perfect plain cheese pie (as far as the NY/NJ style goes), and their toppings are fresh and delicious - but the grandma pie is the real winner. Sadly it does take almost twice the time than a normal pie does (it has to bake twice, I think), but it is totally worth the wait. Definitely try the other pizzas in town (and nearby), but know that you're gonna come back to here after you do.

Outstanding pizza! We live in Texas but are native New Yorkers that last lived in NJ. So when we come back to see family & friends, we have to have pizza. I mean NY/NJ pizza because nothing can compare. I used Yelp to find this place and the pizza is superb!!! The owner and staff are super nice. He even let us try his "Grandmas" pizza, another little edible delight at this amazing find!! Bravo Yelpers, you're right on the money with great reviews.

Pasquale's has the best pizza in town! The service is very awesome, too. We highly recommend this place! For the generous portions and fair prices, you can't go wrong with this fine establishment.

I came to the place 30 minutes before closing and was pushed out immediately and said i had to order to go.First time going not coming ever again

Best pizza in Boonton area for takeout! Medium crust thickness, good tomato sauce flavor, perfect amount of cheese. Classic old school pie, get it well done for extra crunch with no burn. Can grab a slice while waiting- their slice pie is amazing since it seems to be thinner and crunchier. There are maybe 3 tables inside just to inhale your slice and run. Their catering menu is solid, with old school chicken parm, meatballs, chicken francese, etc. Be prepared for a short wait at dinnertime.

As soon as I looked at this pizza I knew it was horrible an it was omg sucks first an last time ill go ther .. nobody shud go ther the worst pizza in New jersey

This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is always freaking delicious. Tony (and the other guy behind the counter) are hilarious. This whole team is awesome. It's also great to support this local business.

I ordered the Grandma pie. The guy said I would enjoy it, and I did. 5 stars for predicting the future.

I ordered a Grandma pie last night for pickup, it was my first time here. I met the manager and he was a super nice guy. Now to the important part, the pie was insane! It was one of the best Grandma pies ever! The sauce was on point and it was cooked perfectly! I'm a huge fan and definitely will be returning. Pat

I would love to give a picture of the grandma's pizza but couldn't it was too good to wait to take a picture.

I asked for a few slices with mushroom to go and they cut up some mushrooms and threw them on top uncooked. That was the first and last time I ate there.

This is by far and wide the best pizza in the Boonton/mountain lakes area. The storefront is tiny but cozy and the owner is friendly and accommodating when I ask that my pizza be light on the sauce and cooked crispy. I will always order from Pasquales.

The owner would not stop staring at me and making me very uncomfortable, he was sitting in a chair very unprofessional, their food isn't authentic Italian food‍ isn't worth it there is other Italian places in boonton that are wayyyyyyy better. Save ur money

I came to eat here exclusively because they were so highly rated on Yelp. It did not disappoint. This is some of the best pizza I've had in a very long time. The food is great and the people are friendly. The atmosphere is relaxed and the prices are reasonable. I recommend the Sicilian and the Grandma's pizza but everything on the menu looked delicious. Worth the stop.

The owner of this spot recently purchased a vehicle from my company. He was kind enough to bring in a Grandma's, Sicilian, and Plain pie as a thank you. Let me say this...without a doubt, the Grandma's and Sicilian were the 2 best pies I have ever had...my colleagues (and my wife) all agree. The grandma's is a notch above the Sicilian...but it is a virtual tie. They are that good.

Pizza is always on the money. My go to for a plain pie and always have good friendly service. Inside could use some work, but have never really mattered to me based of how the pizza tastes!

My family and I made a pit stop for Pizza on our way back home to TX. We couldn't have chosen a better pizza place even if we tried. Employees were so incredibly friendly and welcoming and their food is AMAZING. It doesn't get better than this. We will make it a point to stop by the next time we visit this way. The portions are huge and pact full of flavor. Thank you Pasquale's for your hospitality. We enjoyed everything!

I was in the mood for a slice. Got one here and it was delicious!!! I'll be back!!!

Even if we are starving we will still go pass every pizza place along the way to go here. The crust is thin and cooked through the sauce is the best I've probably ever had and the people couldn't be more down-to-earth and friendly quaint small place with killer pie

Was there 2weeks ago.. the only thing I can say the service was great. Calamari was horrible & I speak for my self my pasta with meatballs did not go down well. Our apps & meal came at the same time.

Love their pizza. Nice semolina coating on the bottom. Good toppings. My favorite is cheese pie right out of the oven. When cheese is super hot It's like delicious lava.

The staff was friendly and the restaurant had a beautiful modern atmosphere. My boyfriend and I sat by the window and ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza. The pizza had thin sliced sausage, with a thin crust, perfect juicy meaty sauce, and light cheese. Overall, the pizza and experience is amazing!

OMG!! We are driving from Virginia we stop because our children were hungry, we don't regret to stop, people was very nice and patient explaining the menu, food was out very fast, we were impressed the PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS, we got a Sicilian, Grandma pizza, pepperoni and cheese pizza. Please try it. Thank you Pasquale's Pizza it was a great feast!

Amazingggggg!!!!! I love pizza and this place never fails! Never actually been inside but have had there pizza may times. My brothers always get pizza from here and every time they call me to brag! Hahahahaha!!!! But really this place is pretty amazing!

You can't go wrong with any of the pizza places on Boonton Main St, but this one might have the nicest atmosphere. The grandma's pizza was quite unique!

Delicious sandwiches and pizza. Owner is very hospitable and kind. I def recommend this place.

Grandma pizza is excellent. The owner Tony is very friendly, great authentic pizza atmosphere...

The best pizza in Boonton. Tony and his crew provide excellent service. The food is always fresh.

Placed an order for delivery for mozzarella sticks and spaghetti and meatballs dinner. Food was good. Asked for light sauce-got it! A Side Salad was not included with the dinner but got a decent size portion of garlic bread.

We stopped by during a drive to the Cape. Just happened by and glad we did. Great pizza. Great service. Ingredients were tasty (pepperoni and sausage and peppers) and cooked crispy just like requested.