Dave J.
Yelp
The perfect, if pricey, fusion of excellent and meticulously prepared food, warm and engaging service, and gorgeous and elegant, if boisterous, ambiance.
Went there for the first time with my wife on the recommendation of a good friend. This is a typical hot new restaurant, we could tell when we called for reservations that it was 'jumping' as the background noise was so loud we could barely make a reservation, which is absolutely mandatory.
We had Wagyu strip steak, Dover sole, and risotto, which we split as a side. Everything is a la carte here. The Wagyu was well prepared and a nice portion size for the price. I got fancy and ordered black truffle shavings for the top, which added nothing to the meal except $10. I'm not a truffle guy I guess. My wife's Dover sole was exquisitely prepared, served table-side with surgical precision. Somehow this fish surgeon extracted the endoskeleton with such skill that my wife could enjoy freshly prepared whole fish (nice portion) minus any bones. We split the squash risotto, which was delicious, a symphony of ingredients. The overall palate of these dishes was sophisticated over spicy. Since my wife isn't a big fan of spicy, this suited her well.
In the drinks department, we enjoyed a pleasant enough glass of rose and I sampled some Nc'nean single malt, which was delicious. Scotch lovers, beyond this treat, the single malt selection is quite banal; standard Macallan, Glenfiddich, a Benriach, and the aforementioned Mc'nean. If they're hiding other bottles, it's a mystery to me.
Dessert, because we had to, was an airy slice of mousse cake with various accoutrements that was light and a delicious way to end what was really a wonderful meal.
Ali, our server, was warm and engaging and extremely helpful, as was her assistant and everyone else who helped out (including our fish surgeon).
The ambiance was sophisticated but boisterous. This is not a place for a quiet dinner. It is a place to get caught up in a swirl of happy energy while vicariously enjoying the pleasure others experience being here.
Well done and we have a new downtown Rochester destination which is superior to our previous excuse to venture from the suburbs, the departed Morton's, which, on its best night, was not as good as Patron Saint.
Finally, in all this praise, I would be remiss if I didn't mention that all this came at a substantial price, almost $300 with tip for dinner for two. That said, you get what you pay for.