Robert G.
Yelp
I looked at the map. It's the one near the UMaine campus. I looked at the photos. I remember the old school ceiling. Yep, this was it ... the downtown Orono (and possibly original location) for Pat's Pizza, an institution in the cluster of towns around Orono, Maine and which include Bangor.
Before I looked at the distribution of ratings, I knew what I'd be giving Pat's Pizza. It would be a 3 stars. However, it's a very strong 3 stars. I wonder how much of the upper end ratings are influenced by local bias toward an outfit that's an institution. I'm being a realist and am not trying to be a jerk.
As for the food at Pat's, it was definitely pretty good. I had a small individual sized pizza and a drink, along with some bread sticks to dip into a tomato based sauce, presumably marinara. It made for a nice lunch on a beautiful New England autumn day. The issue was that this little pizza, although very fairly priced and satisfyingly filling, had a crust that tasted a little bit overcooked and thus slightly dried out. Maybe this was an isolated situation, but it was my only experience eating here. Please pay a little more attention to the crust because it's probably the biggest factor in the enjoyment of a pizza.
This eatery is cool without being "too cool for school" (it's walkable to UMaine). I like eateries and businesses in small Northeastern towns which have addresses with 1 or 2 digits. That adds to the charm. The ceiling, of which I've seen shiny (faux) copper renditions, adds to the ambiance, as do the jukeboxes at the table. I don't recall if they were in working order. With a counter area with bar stools and some big guys in plaid flannel shirts sitting there, I wasn't exactly going to load it up with dance music to test the jukebox ... and the patience of the big guys in plaid flannel shirts sitting there. The server was friendly, perhaps because she was not dealing with unruly UMaine students, and my lunch arrived quickly.
I really wanted to give this place, Pat's Pizza, 4 stars. They seem like cool people and probably listen to people weighing in on social media. I remember thinking, "If only the pizza crust could be moister and chewier ..." I could eat a small pizza, a small salad or a cup of soup, and a non-alcoholic beverage almost every day for lunch, although I don't, and these people have the goods. I live far away but I'd sure love to come back someday to savor the pleasant old school vibe of the store and a small pizza that's a tad better, not to mention the incredible beauty of this area close "enough" to Acadia National Park.