Paulie's Shoreditch

Great food and really warm friendly service! The pizza is super crispy and thin - the perfect NYC slice. The cereal milk soft serve was delicious, not too sweet and a unique flavour 😍 I’d love to see a few more non-alcoholic drink options as someone who won’t drink coke, but it was great to try root beer for the first time!

Great service, amazing pizza, and a delicious soft serve for dessert to round it off. What a great spot for pizza!

Really excellent slices at such good prices! Immaculate vibes, beautiful interior and lovely staff. We missed having a great slice shop in Shoreditch and this is such a perfect spot for lunch. Can’t wait to come back and try more of the menu!

I visited for lunch on a Thursday. Arriving at around 12pm it was fairly empty but it did get a bit busier shortly afterwards. They offer most of their pizzas by the slice, and even at 12pm they had a full set of 8 pizzas all sliced up and ready to go. I tried a slice of the White (mushroom) pizza followed by slice of Burrata pizza, plus a hot honey dip. The slices were taken from the counter and reheated before being served. This was some pretty solid pizza. The crust was firm and crispy - it passed the flop test - and the toppings were decent as well. The hot honey dip was ok for a short time but I was bored of it by the time I finished my second slice. The dip selection in general was not enticing. While offering pizza by the slice naturally appeals to solo diners, I think the rest of the menu was designed for sharing - at least I assumed so based on prices (e.g. £9 for a Caesar salad). My lunch cost me around £15 and I was reasonably full afterwards. Overall an enjoyable meal and I would recommend it, although Crisp W6 easily remains my favourite for NY style pizza in London. 4.5 stars.

Pizza is exploding in London. There is no shortage of incredible options, with Detroit Pizza, Spring Street and Breadstall being personal favourite. Paulie’s is now firmly joining this list, with incredible pizza, drinks and soft serve. 10/10 and will be back.

Definitely some of the best New York pizza in London. Crisp, hot and tasty. Definitely coming back

Hands down the best pizza in London. You ain’t going to find anything as authentic as this if you’re after a NY slice. Also shout out Ryan for the hospitality.

Great pizza, had the vodka & sausage, white and Paulie pie, which was our fav, all washed down with a lagerita! Good music also and the owner is a nice guy. Great spot.