Paulie's Shoreditch

Delicious New York style pizza. Crispy, thin pizza base with just the right amount of toppings. Their ‘NYC slices’ are the main event. If you buy a single slice it’s enough pizza for a decent lunch or a modest dinner. If you’re feeling a bit hungrier you get the best value if you order a ‘whole pie’. Their ‘signature squares’ are great if you want a thicker, doughier base. From what I’ve seen you can’t buy a whole square pizza, only by the slice. We had the ranch dip which was delicious, and a perfect accompaniment for the pizza crust. They have Modelo beer on tap and a small selection of bottled beers available. There’s not much seating inside but it’s a cozy atmosphere. If you don’t finish off a whole pizza they’ll give you a box to take it home. Recommend if you’re in the area!

We went for the classic NYC Classic cheese 18” (Margherita without basil) - keeping toppings, sauces, and dips minimal so you can really taste the bread and the base itself. Overall, we enjoyed it quite a bit, though it’s definitely a heavy pizza. There’s a generous amount of sauce, which actually works in its favour - the sauce itself is really tasty and well-balanced. It held together beautifully with zero flop, which is always a win for NYC-style. That said, the crust felt denser than ideal; it seemed like a lot of the air had been knocked out during proofing or shaping, so it didn’t have that light, airy interior rise you sometimes get in the best New York versions. It’s substantial and filling, more so than some other spots in London (no names mentioned). It makes sense that the owner - known for his excellent Detroit-style pizza - leans into a thicker, heartier dough; that thickness suits Detroit pies perfectly. Still, for pure NYC style, it comes across as heavier by comparison. These are minor nitpicks, though. The quality is solid, the flavors are on point, and it’s legitimately one of the closer approximations to proper New York pizza you’ll find in London. It’s not necessarily the absolute best in the city (tastes vary), but Paulie’s is absolutely on the map and worth seeking out if you’re craving that classic foldable slice. We left happy and satisfied.

Finally there’s proper pizza in the UK. Paulie’s is people from New York so it’s authentic and I love New York pizza. This is the first time since visiting there that the pizza has been worthy of the name. I highly recommend this place if you want to see what the fuss is about NY pizza. Try the classic NYC slice. That’s the best way to check how good a place is - the more basic ingredients. As a bonus they have really nice chewy cookies there too. The people are very friendly there and seem to have a great pride in providing quality food.

Really gorgeous spot for some delicious NYC style pizzas in the heart of London!! they have some delicious flavours with such generous portions (we were absolutely stuffed) and a great vibe! Definitely recommend the buratta and Caio e Pepe slices with a drizzle of hot honey!! Missed out on trying the chocolate chip cookie which looked fab so will definitely be back soon •ᴗ• Highly recommend for some yummy pizza

Some of the best pizza I have had in a while. Truly lived up to the hype. Was my first time trying new York style pizza and I loved it. The Paulie's pie was so good. The pepperoni and hot honey worked together so well. Will definitely be having that again. The classic new York pizza was surprisingly very light almost felt like an appetiser. The atmosphere was good. We didn't have a booking and went during an off peak time for dinner. It quickly filled up but the atmosphere was really good. The staff are attentive and service is quick.

We were welcomed to a new special for feb, 18” for the price of a 14”. Ordered Paulie’s Pie and ranch dip(delicious btw). This pizza is incredible, my partner and I have quite the appetite, also frequented a number of pizza restaurants in London doing NY style and we were defeated with two slices left. Old school hip hop on sound system and clean. I’ve never been to New York but I felt as if I was in a local pie dealers. Thank you so much for, dare I say it, the best pizza in London. 🍕 🧡

Decent pizza place serving NY style full pies and single slices. Unfortunately I felt it slightly missed on the hallmarks of a great NY slice - the dough was a little too thin and over crisped, such that there was a bit too bitter, and the sauce wasn't as bright as I'd expect. The toppings were good though - the pepperoni and hot honey packed a great punch. I enjoyed the crust on the square slice better, but the crust was still too burnt for my liking.

Really great, and I’d definitely recommend visiting. I wanted to try a couple of things. I ordered a Paulie’s NY slice. It was delicious. A great combo of flavours with a touch of chilli. I wanted to try one of the “signature squares” as well but wasn’t sure what to get. The lady at the counter suggested the Vodka Pancetta square, and I couldn’t be happier that she did. I think I have a new favourite pizza place; it was really great food and friendly service. Also worth saying: I got 2 big slices of pizza and a drink, and there was change from £15. A very reasonable price, especially for central London!