Paulie's Shoreditch

Great slices. Pepperoni was so flavourful, almost too salty. Voda square was amazing, what an amazing experience of high moisture dough. The Ranch. Best ranch I’ve ever had outside the US. Wish my ranch obsessed colleague who’d bring back kilos of hidden valley sachets would be here to testify.

had the best experience ever!! The food was absolutely delicious and it arrived so quickly. The atmosphere was so cozy and welcoming. The person that served me was named Mattie and omg she really made the experience!! She was so friendly and helpful. Will definitely be coming back again n

Great service, the vodka sauce is also amazing and the pizza is banging. Will definitely be back for more. 14" is enough for two but if you're starving and with a party of 2, go for the 18"!

THE BEST NY pizza in London, hands down! Seriously so glad we’ve finally been able to find good, delicious, authentic New York style pizza in London. (NY Fold which closed down was meh, and Alley Cats was awful, tough, small, not authentic - severely overrated). It was so good we had no choice but to keep ordering more pizzas. We had almost everything on the menu, but the must-have is the Classic NY. Chocolate chip cookie was good too!

Paulie’s Pizzeria is a slice of heaven. The pizza? Absolutely spot-on: crisp base, perfect chew, and toppings that taste like they were picked just for you. But the real showstopper? The chocolate cookies. Rich, gooey, and dangerously addictive! Easily contenders for the best in all of London. The vibe is super friendly, with upbeat and caring staff. The only tiny drawbacks: it can get pretty warm inside, and the seating might not be everyone’s cup of tea comfort-wise. Still, for pizza and cookie lovers, this place is pure gold.

Visiting from NYC and had to try this place. After having several great experiences at the Detroit Pizza location (definitely don’t skip that place either, it’s amazing), I figured Paulie’s would be equally delicious, and I was correct. Pizza had a great flavor and the crust was spot on. Don’t skip the ice cream either. 10/10!

Never thought I’d find a pizza spot in London that has slices that rival the ones back home in NYC. Absolutely incredible. Can’t recommend enough! And the people who work there are OUTSTANDING. Can’t wait to visit again in April

I visited for lunch on a Thursday. Arriving at around 12pm it was fairly empty but it did get a bit busier shortly afterwards. They offer most of their pizzas by the slice, and even at 12pm they had a full set of 8 pizzas all sliced up and ready to go. I tried a slice of the White (mushroom) pizza followed by slice of Burrata pizza, plus a hot honey dip. The slices were taken from the counter and reheated before being served. This was some pretty solid pizza. The crust was firm and crispy - it passed the flop test - and the toppings were decent as well. The hot honey dip was ok for a short time but I was bored of it by the time I finished my second slice. The dip selection in general was not enticing. While offering pizza by the slice naturally appeals to solo diners, I think the rest of the menu was designed for sharing - at least I assumed so based on prices (e.g. £9 for a Caesar salad). My lunch cost me around £15 and I was reasonably full afterwards. Overall an enjoyable meal and I would recommend it, although Crisp W6 easily remains my favourite for NY style pizza in London. 4.5 stars.