Alison C.
Yelp
4.5 stars
I had come across the Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room while researching a getaway in the area. From what I could tell, it was THE destination restaurant in that rural area, and from the booked dining room on the evening we visited, I could see that was definitely the case. While the restaurant looked like a basic, yet large, house from the outside, it was like a spacious log cabin inside. The bar area and main dining room were beautiful, and there was also a large balcony for the summer months.
Our gracious server made sure to constantly check in with us, starting from our first few moments where I ordered a Blood Orange Margarita. The tart and potent cocktail included Gran Agave tequila, blood orange puree, Cointreau, and lime. I enjoyed my beverage with slices of the heavenly Onion Bread and chive butter they had provided.
For my main course, I opted for the Oven-Roasted Atlantic Tilefish, which I had been told was resembled a Snapper. It certainly had a similar mild flavor, but was meatier in texture. The fish was cooked perfectly, but could have used a bit more seasoning. The small filet was served with Dark Horse Farm golden beets, dill, and roasted potatoes, all over a celery root puree. My boyfriend had selected the Wood-Grilled Sirloin Steak, which had a flavorful char on it and was laying in a light smoked tomato butter. The meat was plated with roasted, RSK Farm fingerling potatoes and sautéed kale. I tried the kale and thought it could have been cooked more; it was too tough. He also got a side of Mashed Potatoes that he really liked.
The Peekamoose Restaurant & Tap Room was a drive from our hotel and on long, dark, and windy roads, but we thought it had been worth it for such a quality experience.