Pegasus Pizza West Seattle

The pizza was good. The artichoke dip was okay. The atmosphere was lively & full of laughter. This business is popular. The decor and interior design were gorgeous. I wish I had captured more pictures—many people were dining inside, so I refrained from taking photographs in specific directions. The waiter was attentive and friendly. I will visit again!

Wow, what an awesome pizza. After eating at the chain pizza places these last few years i forgot how good an old style pizza can be. We got the Hercules which has pepperoni and sausage amongst other toppings. Nice atmosphere with view of water. Parking can be tough . Very nice and good beer on draft choices.

Fast, friendly service. Happy hour beer 3 p to 6. $5.25 Corona. Lunch special 2 loves of 2 topping pizza avd a salad or soup. Both delicious. A little greasy but not u tolerable.

Great little pizza place but busy so it means it good right?? Well we came we seen that it was packed it was 30 min for a table and we decided to come back some other time but it’s clean and warm and if you make a reservation you won’t be in a jam like we were but it has pizza drinks and a warm atmosphere with good smells! The bathroom is nice and the views are to die for!

Pegasus has been around forever and it’s still great! I avoid it during summer months since it’s so crazy their but come back afterwards. Due to COVID we did takeout but dine in is available. The service is always friendly and the restaurant is clean, so dine in if you please. We ordered a small salad which was enough for 2 helpings and it came with a big bowl of dressing which gave us enough for dipping our pizza into! Hope they are there for another 20+ years!

A bit overpriced, but the pizza is worth the money. They have 10” 12” and 14” pizza selections with so many toppings combinations. I especially like that they have seafood pizza (shrimp), which I don’t often find anywhere else. But they don’t have many options for vegetarians.

They have a nice Greek salad that I had with my two slices of Hercules pizza (like a meat lovers times infinity). It is kind of a medium deep dish pizza which I wasn't expecting but it was good. I was so excited to eat it I forgot to take a picture. I sat outside to people watch and enjoy the slivers of view of the water between the parked cars. The only downside was a couple of boys who were rough housing in the doorway and impeding the servers and hosts from doing their jobs. My food was almost dropped on me because they got in the server's way. Other than that it was a nice lunch on Alki.

Bullet point version: *I paid $25 for a Small pizza to bring home *It was disgusting, had to throw it all away *Called the restaurant hoping they would correct it or offer a solution *They barely gave me an “I’m sorry” *Wont be going back - Disappointed Detailed version: My daughter and I ordered two small pizzas online last night, for a pick-up order. My daughter drove to the restaurant to get it and came straight home. Her pizza was okay, basic pepperoni pizza, hard to mess that up. Well it’s hard to mess up any pizza, or so I thought. I always get the Tom’s House Special, my favorite pizza. But last night I could barely eat one piece. They went a little feta cheese crazy…an entire layer of thick feta cheese covered the entire pizza, under all of the toppings so I could not scrape it off. I love feta cheese but this was overkill. Usually it’s just a few crumbles. So tonight I tried to scrape off the cold feta and heat up a piece…no luck. There was just so much covering the entire pizza. I had to throw it away, which after paying $25 for a small pizza, was disappointing to say the least! Upset that I could not even enjoy my expensive treat, I decided to call the restaurant and let them know my experience. Thinking maybe they would offer to remake it or give a coupon for my next order. If they wanted to see the disgusting food they served first I would understand and would have been more than happy to bring it back, possibly a teaching moment of what not to do. But again, no luck. They barely seemed interested and only told me ‘sorry’. I’ve had better pizza from Little Caesar’s for only $5 , but the lack of concern or offer to fix the problem is what will turn me away for good. I’ve had friends tell me they don’t go to Pegasus Pizza anymore…I guess I will be joining them now too.