Jessica B.
Yelp
I had VERY high hopes for Pelato after reading reviews and following them on Instagram. After eating there, I was VERY disappointed.
I'll start off with the environment. I love what they did with the B&B space. It was still open up top and had a lot of natural light coming in. They did cram A LOT of tables in there, though. Trying to walk to our tiny table in the corner was frustrating since they had about ten thousand employees walking around. A lot of the servers had a second server with them, people were running plates, people were running drinks and others were clearing off plates. Just so many bodies moving around at once and not a lot of space to do so. The tables were all very close together. I probably could have laid my head on the shoulder of the person at the table next to me.
Our server and her partner were great. Attentive, knowledgeable about everything on the drink/food menu and incredibly nice. No issues there at all!
The drinks were pretty solid, I'll give them that. My partner had a mocktail which was delicious. I had a glass of wine and the Pelato Breeze which was A+. The drinks did take quite a while to come out, but I didn't see but one or two people working the bar for the large amount of tables in the restaurant + outdoor space + two bars people were sitting at.
Let's move onto the food... All of the plates are considered "small plates" and "shareable". I find that laughable as the plates were very small and some could be finished in one or two bites.
Prosciutto Plate - cut fresh when ordered, tasted as prosciutto should taste. The parmesan on top was delicious and the balsamic was a nice touch.
The meatballs - Listen, I love a good meatball. Our server had advised us that this was made with breadcrumbs, which was weird to tell me but I suppose if it would be a dietary restriction it is nice to know. There were three in a bowl. Presentation look good, so I was excited to try them, especially after reading great reviews online about them. I was a tad disappointed when I realized that they were ground Italian sausage. Don't get me wrong, I like Italian sausage - I've just never had it in a meatball form when there wasn't really any other kind of protein with it (beef, pork, etc). If it was ground up in a sauce, I may have enjoyed it more - but this was too much like just eating a sausage link. The marinara/sauce was very watery and lacked flavor.
The burrata crostini came next. I love a good seeded bread loaf. After seeing it come out and having sesame seeds on it, I was so happy! Reminds me of the loaves I'd get from the bakery down the street in Brooklyn with my grandparents. Once it was placed on the table, I became a little sad seeing that the marinara/tomato sauce (whatever they call it there), which as I mentioned was very watery, had made the bread super soggy. It wasn't crusty at all. The burrata on top was topped with something SO SALTY that I could barely eat it. I like flavor and salt in my food, but this was way too much. I only took one or two bites before deciding I couldn't finish it.
Next came the Pelato Rav. This lacked....everything. It was 3x3 squares, but not cut, just making it one large square. If that makes sense. I posted a photo with this review so you can see. It was just a sheet of ravioli, which was very al dente and kind of hard to eat. The filling didn't have any flavor to it. My partner basically folded it over and was able to eat it in two bites. It wasn't hot, either, which was sad.
The campanelle shrimp limon was our next dish to come out. The shrimp was overcooked and made the "o" instead of "c" shape. They were rubbery and tough to eat. The flavor of this dish was pretty great, but the black pepper on top wasn't a good addition to it. The pasta was also undercooked.
The chicken parmigiana was received last. I had seen photos and reviews of this and was looking forward to one dish I didn't think could be messed up - especially if you call yourself an Italian restaurant. Our chicken was SO thin, we could barely tell what what chicken and what was breading. Some parts of the chicken tasted burnt (either from the breading being burnt or the oil not being refreshed). I have made so many chicken cutlets in my life for a lot of Jewish holidays and gatherings. I've messed up and burnt some before but I would never serve it to anyone. The cheese on top was slightly melty but the rest of it seemed as though it sat under the broiler too long. With the red sauce, which lacked flavor, this was a very underwhelming dish.
Desserts - the torta di mele was so so so dry. The apples on the edges tasted really great, but the cake itself was not good. The rainbow cookies made me want to cry. As someone who grew up in Brooklyn eating rainbow cookies and has rainbow cookies delivered ever year to her from there, these were nowhere close to "Brooklyn Italian". It lacked flavor and were so tiny.
I will probably not return to this restaurant or recommend it.