Robert D.
Yelp
Turning 50 called for some extravagance and such was bestowed upon my humble self with a long weekend stay at the famous Broadmoor, complete with dining and activities...... yes I am beyond lucky! Now one of the highlights was to be the full on tasting menu at the equally renown "Pemrose Room" at the top of the South Tower, thus the missus and I got dolled up and ready for some high end, elongated dining!
Right off the bat we already knew how legendary the service was to be as frankly, the Broadmoor specializes in impeccable service from top to bottom-- one of the most notable features of this ultra lux property. This of course was no different as we were eagerly seated despite arriving 30 min ahead of time to soak up the ambience and maybe a cocktail to get the mood set.
Ambience: this is where I find myself a tad stymied: the only way I can describe the dining room is as follows: cruise line mid 70's-- from the low ceiling with gaudy chandeliers, to the seemingly ancient and ornately colored carpet, I felt like I stepped out of a time machine.... the "jazzy trio" that supplied the evening's entertainment also looked as if they once headlined the cruise ship circuit back in the 70's down to the dress that the singer wore..... some graced the dance floor throughout the evening which enhanced that kind of awkward "wedding / bar mitzvah" vibe that I couldn't decide whether it was endearing or corny to the max! So be it..... the food will dazzle, right??
The Chef's tasting menu consists of "about" 5 courses and with the added cheese course (we added) and bonus items that our chef added, it came to more like 8 courses total.
The standouts of the evening were the black cod, which was wonderfully delicate and served with a cauliflower purée and black garlic reduction, and the Hamache served with dolloped salmon roe, rice crisps and fresh cucumber. The scallop dish was served also with cauliflower, this time a seasoned cross sectioned floret topped with a chimichurri and an ornament of sweet curry and cumin. The main course was a Colorado lamb chop served sous vide and seared atop asparagus, a layered potato cake and a red wine demi reduction. The lamb was, of course, high quality but I was puzzled by the thick fat layer that was left on the chop, that is usually carved away, giving this cut it's famous "lollipop" shape. Maybe some enjoy the fat?? For me it was a let down of sorts as lamb fat tends to be very gamey.
The dessert courses were fine-- the cheeses offered up were good but the array unbalanced-- 4/5 were hard cheeses and the only soft rind was a blue goat. The sweets were their signature birthday chocolate ganache and a refreshing merengue, mango, sorbet which paired well with the moscato provided as the wine pairing.
We were treated to a visit by the executive chef whose resume bullets include French Laundry and Alinea, despite the fact that he looked like he could be 17 yrs old. Nevertheless it's always nice to meet the chef when you are being offered his very best.
All in all the price came to slightly under 800.00 for the evening, which I thought was "ok?" But frankly, I have had much more creative and daring tasting menus in dining rooms that didn't evoke an evening in the Catskills. I doubt I would return to Penrose any time soon, but for what it was it was a "kitschy" and decent evening of high dining.
In any case, go to the Broadmoor a lease once in your life!!!!!
Robbo, Parker, CO