Jane S.
Yelp
Some of the negative reviews here make me think y'all have never seen a community theater company before.
Yes, the quality of the performances at the Pentacle tends to be highly variable. That's because the actors, directors, techies, etc. are volunteers working day jobs. Everything you see is a labor of love, and labors of love have a tendency to turn into soppy messes. It's the risk you take when you buy a ticket - you might see something awesome, or you might see something lousy, or you might see something that looks like an art school drop-out self-combusted all over the stage. The only certainty is that you'll see something that a lot of people worked really hard on. That's just what local theater is like.
No, the productions are not above criticism. If John E.'s description of Pentacle's production of A Midsummer Night's Dream (which doesn't seem to be up here anymore) is accurate and they really did do a homeless-themed staging of the play, then yes, please criticize that play. That really does sound problematic, and not because it's a "modern dress" version of the Bard. I didn't see it, so I don't know. Anyone who's been to enough Pentacle productions has been to at least one that just didn't work. Maybe the right members of the local talent pool didn't sign up, or the director's instincts weren't the best. Maybe all the techies had colds. But then you go to the next one, and it's a different sort of play altogether put on by a different set of people, and you give it a chance. If you don't come into the experience with your cynicism on your sleeve, you'll probably enjoy it or at least get some satisfaction from seeing your friends, relatives, and neighbors put on a show.
If you're expecting consistency from your theater experience, spend a few hundred bucks to squint at touring companies at the Keller Auditorium. And hey, local Yelpers: learn the difference between being a critic and being hyper-critical. Having high standards doesn't mean you have to be a cynical asshole about everything. Read your Ebert.