Pepe Giallo

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Papa Giallo is the kind of neighborhood gem that feels instantly reassuring. The room is quietly inviting—relaxed, unpretentious, and designed for lingering—while the service sets the tone from the start: attentive, gracious, and effortlessly warm, the sort that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit. Consistency is the restaurant’s greatest luxury. The kitchen delivers with calm confidence, turning out pastas that are precise, deeply comforting, and reliably excellent. The Narcino stands as the house signature and an enduring favorite—rich yet restrained, soulful without excess, and executed with the kind of assurance that comes from knowing exactly what works. Papa Giallo doesn’t chase trends or theatrics. Instead, it offers something far more satisfying: a polished, dependable dining experience that feels timeless. A must-stop if you’re in town—and an easy habit once you’re not.

I must say this was one of the best meals I have ever had. The food was excellent and Chris so kindly helped us choose the best vegetarian options and drinks. Also desserts are very good. I will definitely come back next time I visit NY! I certainly recommend this place.

Great food and house wine at a reasonable price. This Italian spot is our go-to when we can’t decide what to eat. The food is good at a reasonable price, so does the house wine. I always go for their truffle norcia pasta and husband always gets their special pizza. Consistency can be improved as sometimes my pasta is watery than other times. We used to love the fried calamari, but it’s been a little disappointing lately as the fried veggie outnumber the calamari Have 3-4 outdoor tables (small) so 🐶 friendly! Overall, a lovely place with reasonable price items

We stopped in on a rainy Monday afternoon. Early dinner before an opening. We were happy to find an establishment open so early on a Monday and serving dinner. Nice atmosphere, open kitchen with a large pizza oven. The staff were very friendly. The Caesar salad was good and we shared it amongst three of us. Two of us shared the sausage pappardelle which was very very good. I really enjoyed it. They noted it was all homemade, including the pasta, and it tasted like it. My plate was wiped clean. If in the area again this is a come again restaurant.

A really great spot we stumbled upon! The fried calamari and zucchini was great, the basket was filled to the brim! I loved my pasta and fresh bread. I had the spicy sausage pappardelle which wasn’t very spicy to me but still very fresh and tasty! My partner had the chicken parm which was also great. Our server was extremely attentive and kind. Definitely will be saving this place! Very cute inside.

Great atmosphere and enjoyed the food. The service was quite slow and the server didn’t know whose drink was whose on both occasions.

I have been dining here for over 20 years . The food always amazing and the owners are wonderful. It’s constantly a great meal. I’m finally reviewing although I would have said the same 20years ago . Grazie Mille 🍷 4/5/23 Back again for another great meal . 7/12/23 Happy Hour if fun too. 12/15/ 23 Back again for an always wonderful lunch. 5/17/25 Fun lunch outside

Highly recommend to ask for the seating in the back room, it was gorgeous. We reserved a table for 7 (can't select more), and they were happy to add another table to accommodate 2 more. The back room is beautiful, although the acoustic is not great. We had another group seated close by and it sounded like they were shouting. The food was also great, all the kids found something to eat, and enjoyed the desserts as well. The main downside: The service was not great. We waited a long time for our waiter, who didn't check if we needed anything after we ordered, and it was impossible to get his attention even when he came to a nearby table. Also waited for a long time to get the check, and then to pay it. If you are not in a rush, and have patience, I recommend it.