Alyanna C.
Yelp
Really more of a 2.5, but I am rounding up to a 3 because of the history behind this restaurant - it's been here since my in-laws started dating, so at least over 30 years. It's also a convenient location for relatively inexpensive food if you're hanging around Alki Beach since it's right across the street.
LOGISTICS
Street parking only and you could see the beach from here. You pay first at the counter to place your order and they will call you up. They also have a counter for ice cream, but they require you to pay first before selecting flavors and have no option for sampling, which is unfortunate.
Service is terse. I heard they switched owners since then, so despite the homey atmosphere of the place itself with its wooden decor and old photos of West Seattle, you didn't get a warm feeling from the people working. The lady at the counter looked really annoyed when we asked for cups of water after already paying for our meals (if it bothers them so much, just have a water dispenser out).
Note - they have a sign saying "No Public Restrooms" but when we went, there was a restroom you could use. I think they mean for non-paying customers; we were already dining in.
FOOD
Shrimp Burger: Avoid this - I never saw photos on Yelp or anyone mention this, but if you're thinking of the shrimp burger, go for something else. It's laughable - the shrimp burger is merely 3 pieces of tempura shrimp with lettuce, tarter sauce, and tomato on a bun. The 3 pieces of tempura shrimp were a little small and tasted frozen... like the ones you air fry from Costco. I've had shrimp burgers overseas where it was like a shrimp katsu patty on the bun, but this was far from it.
Double Cheese Burger: Hard to go wrong with a cheese burger... and it was a decent double cheese burger cooked to order.
Fries: Not bad, but not great either. They tasted a little stale even though they were crispy. Ketchup definitely helped here. They get points for being generous on the serving of fries though.
Onion Rings: Let me start by saying it is NOT worth the $1 upgrade to the onion rings. They're so small and less filling than the fries. They are panko breaded and quite thin for onion rings, which would be OK if there were more of them.
OVERALL
Food overall was inexpensive for a local joint in the area - the value was there depending on what you ordered (avoid the onion rings and shrimp burger). They also sold ice cream and fried seafood entrees, so a good place to go near the beach with a variety of options.
It's cool also this place is still open decades later that my in-laws are able to feel a sense of nostalgia going here. However, with the owners changing it seems the friendly local service is a thing of the past.