Petee’s Pie Company - Hell's Kitchen

It’s only pie I’ve been bringing home for last 12 years I’ve been a loyal customer of Petee’s Pie Company for over 12 years, ever since their original Lower East Side location — and I can confidently say this is the best pie you’ll find on the East Coast. They’ve just opened a new shop in Midtown West, and it deserves way more love than it’s getting. This area has fewer tourists and a lot of transplants who may not know the Petee’s legacy yet — but trust me, this is a NYC institution. Standouts (though honestly, you can’t go wrong): • Hudson Valley Apple Pie — absolute perfection • Chocolate Chess Pie — rich, deep, and balanced • Banana Cream Pie — next level And I have to say: if you’re thinking about Magnolia’s famous banana pudding… skip it. Petee’s banana pie is WAY better. No contest. So happy to see them expanding while keeping the same quality and soul they’ve had for years. Midtown West is lucky to have them — people just need to discover it!!!

I work a few blocks away and noticed the opening of a new cafe. Today, I had the opportunity to visit and ordered a slice of pumpkin pie and a Cortado. I must commend the exceptional quality of the pie; it was truly delicious and perfectly prepared. The Cortado was also excellent. The establishment's ambiance was cozy and understated, offering ample seating. The pricing for the pie and coffee was quite reasonable. Furthermore, the young lady who took my order was very polite, and I experienced prompt service. I'm looking forward to my next visit. Next time I'll post pic of the 🥧

Great pie with a fair price! We ordered the cherry crumb and a eggnog custard. Both are very tasty!

We ordered a whole pie to celebrate New Year, and when I took a slice, I found a piece of hair in it.🤢🤮

Cozy place with some delicious pies. I've tried the cherry crumb and eggnog custard, both higly recommended.

I cannot find words good enough to describe Petee's. I am not exaggerating. Just walking in is a culinary delight. The delicious aroma of baking is the first thing you experience. But the pies are the best part. I think Petee's has about 14 choices to try. I love a good cup of coffee and Petee's outdoes itself on coffee, too. The workers are so helpful. And although I bring my order home, Petee's decor is delightful. Hells Kitchen, please treat yourself to this diamond in the rough !

The best pies in the world. The best service. ! A little confusion about our order fixed fast and perfectly! We are regulars for special occasions and our friends and family count on it!

Very underbaked pies with mostly not so great flavore. Banana pie is good though.