Dale W.
Yelp
We've been to Pezzella's a number of times, but this is my first review. We always enjoy the ambiance, great service and food. My favorite decor is in the main dining room - a cartoony painting of several chefs with big noses sniffing some cheese. It never fails to bring a smile.
This time when we entered just after 5:30 on a week night, we were told the main dining room was already booked with large groups, so we sat at a table for 4 in the bar area. The hostess served us, and the bartender also made sure our beverages (water and Coca Cola) were replenished when needed.
My son loves their Caesar salad and the dressing (no anchovies), and he also ordered an appetizer portion of the fetuccine alfredo, as he often does. He also thought we would enjoy the garlic knots appetizer, which the hostess said was an alternate take on caprese, and it was delicious. I can never have too much garlic, and my son is less fond of it, so it was just enough for him.
I ordered the spinach salad but didn't want the fruity vinaigrette dressing that is normally served, so I opted instead for 1000 Island dressing, which was very good. They dress the salads in the kitchen before they are served, so if you want to put on your own dressing, be sure to ask for it on the side.
I also ordered the jumbo prawns scampi in wine sauce which was served with chard (I requested that they omit the pasta, which it otherwise would have had). The prawns were a bit chewy, not sure why, but they tasted good. I should have asked them to remove the tail cartilage - I hate doing that when there is a sauce, as it is very messy. My son kindly offered to remove them, and his hands were very messy from the sauce when he finished.
I knew I couldn't eat much dessert but did order "one scoop only" of vanilla gelato. When they brought it out, as you can see by the photo it was an amount that would completely fill a Ben & Jerry's container. I objected but was told "that's the way it comes" so I said OK, I'll have to eat it. It was delicious, just an awful lot of ice cream. My son was too full to help me.
This is not the place to come if you are on a budget, unless you order from the appetizer part of the menu; our meal was close to $100 before the tip and that's been the case whenever we have dined here.
The reason for the 4 stars this visit was the chewy prawns, not sure why they were that way. Otherwise everything was great!
The women's restroom is just fine, nothing fancy.
They have several handicap parking spots in front of the restaurant, but they were filled when we arrived - their lot is pretty big, wrapping around three sides of the building, so if you park in back you may have to walk a bit.