Bo W.
Yelp
We ordered four things: 1) Cheese and Jalapeno Stuffed Bread, 2) San Marino Pizza, 3) The Classic Pizza, and 4) two bottled import beers. It seems like a lot of food, but the Pizzas are very small. The Cheese and Jalapeno Stuffed Bread was the best part. Really, really good stuff and I recommend getting this appetizer despite being a little overpriced. My wife loved the San Marino and I loved The Classic. The toppings are fresh and very tasty. We really enjoyed the pies.
Why did we only give the place 3 stars instead of 4 or 5? It really deserves 3.5/5, but doesn't deserve 4/5 stars (so we rounded down). It earned this score because of the prices. A Hamilton for each of their pies felt a little overpriced. In NY, we payed this much for twice as much food. Their beer prices are $4 and $5 (domestic and import) a bottle, so this is not a place to go for beer/pizza (shame I didn't see a TV either).
Pi - Change two things and you'll have some loyal customers. 1) Lower your prices or increase the portions. 2) Provide reasonably priced draft beer (say $5 domestic pitchers). Till then, we'll have to keep searching for "our" pizza place here in Rochester.