Pie Bar

Cocktail bar · Capitol Hill

Pie Bar

Cocktail bar · Capitol Hill

1361 E Olive Wy, Seattle, WA 98122

Highlights

Quaint, late-night shop offering fruit & savory pies, plus pie-infused cocktails.

1361 E Olive Wy, Seattle, WA 98122 Get directions

thegenuinepiebar.com

@piebarcapitolhill

@infatuation

"You might recognize this bar as that place next to Rock Box, the rowdy karaoke spot where you can openly laugh at the people butchering “Aaron’s Party (Come Get It) in the front window.” While its neighbor is a glorified fraternity party, Cure is a calm cocktail spot with maybe only a dozen seats inside, and it’s a cozy spot to start or end a night out. Drinks range from classic palomas and gin rickeys to mint martinis and flutes of rose with cotton candy on top. Also, a big charcuterie board is a must." - aimee rizzo

12 Bars That Are Quiet Enough For A Conversation

View Postcard for Pie Bar

@infatuation

"If you’ve ever snuck out of your bed on Thanksgiving night for an encore slice of pie and glass of bourbon, Pie Bar will be your personal Disneyland. And instead of your aunt catching you with your whipped cream-covered face in the fridge, you’ll be surrounded by other happy people eating delicious pie a la mode. It’s all excellent, whether you go for the warm apple crumble, whiskey chocolate pecan, the peanut butter mud (our favorite), or one of the rotating specials. If you’d rather drink your dessert, the pietinis made with fruit, cream, and a crust crumbles are very boozy - and very good. Open till 1am every day." - aimee rizzo

Where To Get Dessert After 11pm

View Postcard for Pie Bar

@infatuation

Pie Bar Review - Capitol Hill - Seattle - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Pie Bar

Jodi Hufendick

Google

Okay, I know that this is an "after you've been partying" food place. And we definitely went there because we saw it on Instagram and it looked fun. It was 8:30 at night, none of us were drunk, and none of us were high, so maybe that's why it wasn't a phenomenal experience. It was definitely awkward when we walked up. There were two people having a smoke in front of the place and there was a chain saying wait here for a table. Turns out one of the people smoking was on a break and actually was the person that let us in, which was never communicated so it was AWKWARD. Most importantly, for a place that is called the Pie Bar, the pie was not very good. I consider myself a pie connoisseur. I get pie for my birthday every year because I don't do cake. I had the peach crumble. The crumble was way too thick and way too hard and in fact did not crumble, so you couldn't eat it with the peaches which defeats the purpose. The mud pie wasn't what I recognized as being a mud pie. There was hardly any chocolate. ?!? My friend got the coconut cream pie and she said it was really good. I don't know that I would make the trek back, but if you're already there and you've been partying, it's probably a great stop.

Lacy Jones

Google

This was a cozy, homey atmosphere. It is very limited on space but was very nice. We got the apple crumble and desert island along with the lemon meringue pietini. Some of the best pie we've had and having a to-go window! Top tier! So smart!

Pablo Zayas

Google

I guess I had low expectations and the place did not even match those. Look at the pie. 🥧 It was not worth the visit or money. I opted for the steak pot pie. Steak it was not, just ground beef. It was dry and the vegetables looked straight out from the frozen vegetables section. The dessert (coconut cream pie) unfortunately was one note, without much of a coconut taste. I will try another location and see if there's a difference.

rob smither

Google

This was some of the saddest and smallest pie I’ve had. This order was 20$ at the take out window! Chocolate cream and desert island pie. Completely not worth it. I just started to go to alamode pies and they’re 3 times the size for 8$, still pricey but at least they’re kind of worth it and tastes a lot better

Ashley Elliott

Google

We ordered for the first time from Pie Bar to celebrate our 9 year anniversary. We decided to “splurge” and pay $25 to have one slice of pie delivered to us. The pie was $12.99 without tax, but the DoorDash fee and taxes amounted to $25. We ordered the banana cream pie. Unfortunately the crust was burnt and we were unable to pierce through it with our fork. Also, there were no banana chunks, so we peeled our own banana and added it to the slice. Much better with real banana! Aside from those things, the taste of the filling was very good. Pie Bar, please change the crust to more of a graham cracker crust and that might help with the texture!

Aaliyah Morris

Google

My friends and I (group of 3) were excited to make it in time before 2 am to order some late night pies after drinks. We were rudely shut out at 2 am when the 2 customers before us got their pies. We were clearly the last customers because we arrived around 1:50 PM waiting for a while in the rain enjoying some fun karaoke from inside the bar. No one was courteous, and kindness can go a longer way. Boo Pie Bar you guys are really lame for last night.

David Schermerhorn

Google

Very limited space, limited staff and the pies were nothing to write home about. (Burnt and lacking flavor) Bathroom had no paper towels. Drinking water did not taste very good. Despite having three staff members present in the space the size of a walk-in closet service was minimal.

D Tor

Google

Killer pies. Good beer. Friendly (but slow) service. Great atmosphere with cool folks, killer 90s rock music. Easy on the wallet.