Pie Box

We came here on Memorial Day weekend around Noon and a lot of the pie slices were sold out. Come early for all the flavors! The Pie Box is for take out pie slices, whole pies, pastries, and fudge. The restaurant is inside the general store in the middle. If the Pie Box is out of the flavor you’re looking for, you may be able to find it in the general store. There are cute little spots outside on the patio and behind Pie Box to enjoy your food. The lemon meringue was the best I’ve ever had. It came from the fridge and was refreshing for a hot day. 🍋☀️Full of fresh lemon flavor and a good balance between sweet and tart. The crust had a good crumb and wasn’t too heavy or thick. The pecan pie was pretty sweet. It had fresh pecans and the filling wasn’t too heavy. Would be great with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream! If you’re looking for a bigger slice of pie that’s very rich and sweet, this may not be for you!

Hands down the best banana cream pie I’ve ever had—and that’s saying a lot because I’ve tried many. The flavor, texture, and balance were absolutely spot on. If you’re ever passing through and you love banana cream pie, this is an absolute must-try. I can’t speak to the other flavors, but the banana cream alone is worth the stop. Individual slices in the fridge FTW!

Oh wow. You have this beautiful rustic bakery that focuses on pies, right by the highway. It's on a barn on a farm type of setting - not pretentious and rather nostalgic. The decors, the vibe, are all authentic and reflects the past in a welcoming way. Head over to the slice fridge and grab various flavors of pies. The bourbon pecan is to die for. Perfect blend of pecans, the gooey stuff, cinammon, and crunch. It is literally one of the best pecan pies I've tasted. The coconut macaroons were also crisp and chewy - brilliantly done. Just with these two, I already was in a happy mood. I don't think they used fresh peaches for the peach pie but oh well, you can't have everything (or perhaps it is not peach season). The only catch - $7 per slice of pie. Yes, it's quite pricey. But I'd have to say, it is worth it. If you're driving up/down to the north of Phoenix, Pie Box is a must stop. Just do it. You'll be grateful that you did.

Great pies and if you have time then plan to enjoy it there on their patio. Pies are phenomenal. Bourbon pecan was my favorite.

This place came recommended by a local as being a staple place to visit. However, coming from the south the pies were a little basic. Although I enjoyed the variety of options to choose from, looks can be deceiving. Some of the pies missed the wow factor. We ordered apple pie, key lime pie, strawberry rhubarb, and a sticky bun. They keep the slice of pies in the fridge, so luckily enough they had a microwave on site for me to warm my pie as I don't like it cold. Overall, we loved the atmosphere, but not sure it was the best pie I have ever had.

Things have changed - worst pie crust ever, fabulous cinnamon rolls. I have been coming here for decades and recall when the original restaurant added a 3rd pie case, well before The Pie Box opened. I bring out-of-town guests here but admit it has been 2+ years. We entered and the first sense was a complete lack of butter scent in the air. In the past it was everywhere and I had told my guests about it. They looked at me with raised eyebrows. We selected Cherry pie and a Cinnamon roll for $43 total Tax/tip. At home the pie crust was DENSE and lacked any flakey texture or scent of butter. We did not finish it and were so disappointed For years these have always been $30 pies but over the last 5 years I commend them for not raising prices yet finding other ways to cut costs to maintain a price point.

Hands down the best banana cream pie I have ever tasted. Every bite was creamy, comforting, and just the right amount of indulgent. I would come back just for this pie!

The BEST pie ever! To get the full selection the Pie Box has to offer one needs to get here early. However, the selection of pies we had was sufficient! There is covered and outdoor seating. The shop is small so if you have strollers or small children knowing what you want and having 1 person pay would help. Highly recommended!

Man these pies look so good I forgot to take a picture. The KEY LIME. Thats all I got to say about that! Kidding...... it's the best pie I've ever had. I didn't even know I'd eat key lime, but I'm addicted The Jack Daniel's Pecan is the best pecan pie I've had My Dad is addicted to the blueberry crumb The carrot cake- trying that later today but the gals swear it's so good I better get 2..... that is by the slice. $8.45 a slice better be good lol You get a free Rock Springs pie cutter/server knife when you buy 3 pies! We bought 4 pies today and 2 slices of cake

I was passing by the area so decided to spontaneously stop by for a slice of pie. It was 106° outside and the pie box was air-conditioned and very peaceful, a great place to just enjoy a slice and relax. Everyone was very friendly and helpful and made my visit to this historical location that much more enjoyable. Rock Springs was established in 1918 and has a pioneering history to it that is very interesting. More things to do here than just eat pie, a great stop along highway 17 on a road trip.

You want Pie! Because this place has pies of all types. It's like a little country store. The pies are huge and the staff was friendly. It's a little drive or ride from Phoenix but so worth it!

Always have to make a stop here anytime we head south on I17. The pies are so good and the decor inside always takes me back in time with all of the relics they have on display.

Every type of pie you can imagine was here! They had cherry, apple, strawberry rhubarb, lemon, banana cream, chocolate cream, bourbon pecan, and blueberry. They also had cookies, cinnamon rolls, and breads. This place was so fun! It's pretty small in size, so be mindful of where you step.

The pies were incredible! Freshly made and quick and easy service! Calm and quaint feel in and out! Great little pie store! Has a nice patio outside

Not sure how many times I've pulled off the highway traveling between Sedona and Phoenix, for the sole purpose of shopping the Pie Box's, "Rock Shop", only to find it closed. Again. I'm certain, however, that this time will be the last time. I think it's also worth mentioning that every single thing sold at this tourist trap is over priced...all the way from their $10.00+ dry cinnamon rolls to their $4.39 gal gas, which I just paid $3.09 for in Cottonwood less than an hour ago. I will never stop again.

They ship! Ordering rhubarb crumb when I get home. Yummy!!! Worth the stop on my way to the Phoenix airport.