Pie Society

I love this place! I am Jerseyian girl, and I grew up in Jersey City, and Hoboken . I always hope there are authentic NYC pizza restaurants, and I found this place. I was so HAPPY this place is so similar to the NYC pizza! Especially, foods and cocktail prices aren't bad!!! I asked a black guy who works from this place, to made Shirley Temple cocktail. He did an excellent job creating it. Pizza and drink are excellent! I will definitely bring my family and friends who are from NYC and NJ to this place when they visit here. You are the best and I love y'all!!!

Pretty solid food, my whole table agreed. I would say slightly overpriced for what it is, especially the custom pizzas where you pick your own toppings. The individual slices are huge, though, and they have great specials/deals on those. The inside is very nice, and very clean. Lots of space for all parties. A pretty good place that I would keep around for special nights, but probably not somewhere I’d go or order from regularly.

The pizza is incredible, from the light flavorful tomato sauce to crunchy robust crust, and the toppings are equally as premium, each identifiable on their own but when you’re chewing they combine perfectly! The only thing better than the pizza is the service, Trinity took my family’s order and was incredibly patient and knowledgeable, definitely a great first impression, then Toby took excellent care of us at our table, keeping tables clean and overall being very attentive and friendly! Food, service, atmosphere, drinks 10/10 !!

This hype location can fill you need for cool vibe. The pizza is not your standard pizza so it is a nice break. We personally love the strawberry goat cheese salad. Has fantastic local brews!!

Conveniently located next to Texas State University, the pizzas are big and shareable, plenty of seating, for friends to gather and socialize. Pie Society has Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free pizza options that taste great. We're also impressed with their no name brand beverage options.

This was one of the best pizzas I had in a long time. I opted for a thin crust 1/2 pepperoni and pineapple 1/2 veggie delight. The crust had just the right amount of crunch. The beer and atmosphere perfect. I so glad my daughter has a place near her apartment where she can eat and hang with her friends. Thank you to the manager for making us feel welcome. I know we were the last ones to leave but you never made us feel rushed even though you guys were cleaning up.

A chill atmosphere with everything you'd want; great pizza, good drinks. The only complaint I have is that their mules don't come in copper mugs.

Good taste, not amazing, not worth the money to be honest. Honestly it’s just the size of the pizza, if it was bigger then it would be a lot better just not really best size for how much it was. (I have small hand btw)

Good drinks and good pizza. I didn't realize that I could order a half of one type, along with a half of another pizza. Don't forget to check out their happy hours specials, one of which is a 16" pepperonI & cheese pizza discounted. They don't take reservations m even for large groups. We had 12 in our party, and had to chance it without reservations. We were fine because we ate early, otherwise you might want to go elsewhere. We'll be back!

Hey, the pizza was good. The service had a few issues. I ordered on their website and went to pay, and an error popped up and indicated that the website could not process any order over 100 dollars. There was no indication prior to the error dialogue box. Okay, so I called and the young lady, told her that I had an order for pickup, and suggested I try another website...and I asked if I could place the order over the phone. She said we don't do delivery over the phone. I continued, restating what I was trying to do, oh okay. I told her the order, she read it back to me and gave me a total. So far, so good. When I arrived she said she was adding a large party gratuity, but don't worry, it's only 24 dollars. I asked why I was being told after the total over the phone...and she said it was policy. I just wish she would have said so at the time of the order so I could check with the group because, you know...that's how I thought things should work. The point is I didn't feel like I was appreciated as a customer, and I generally don't keep going back if I get less than what I think I'm paying for. I also don't think a tip is appropriate on a to go order. Tips in a restaurant, yes. Just know before you go, because this night was too full of surprises for me. I like things to be easy when I'm paying.

Considering how much of my money goes to Pie Society by way of my Texas State Student, I had to give them a try for myself. I know for my child they go there partly out of convenience, but even college students have standards, especially when spending other people's money. Personally I was impressed enough that they have become our go to place for grabbing dinner when in town to see our child perform in the nearby performance hall. I appreciate that they have creative pizzas that they offer by the slice. My favorite is the Balance of Power with spinach, spicy sausage, crushed red pepper and Texas honey. Their toppings are fresh, the sauce is nicely seasoned, and the crust is thin but holds up to the toppings well. Their by the slice prices are reasonable. I also give them props for having Stubborn sodas on tap. The atmosphere is warm, bright, and open inside and also has tables set up outside. The restaurant and restrooms have been clean and in order everytime we've been. Staff have been friendly and service has been quick.

I own a local campground and ordered 4 18 inch pizza pies for visiting campers 2 were ok and 2 were not I called and spoke to assistant manager who asked for my email and said he would send a way to get replacement for the 2 pies. THIS DID NOT HAPPEN. I called back later and the manager Bruce answered and asked many of the same question and many more. The bottom line is Pie Society caters to TSU students and don't care about the rest of the community. The pizza was burned on the bottom. I've never gotten a burned pizza in my 64 years. This place doesn't only burn their pizza but then they argue with you about it SAD Just read some of the other reviews the consistent thread is poor customer service

We couldn't have been more pleased with the way Bruce handled this very large order! He delivered 32 pies and they were hot and fresh. Delicious!! He kept me informed until delivery time. We will be back!

I was excited to try this place for good reviews and highly recommended by friend. The pizza we got tonight was not good, the dough was old and really disappointed.

Really fun theming, probably the most amused I've been at menu names in a while. That is until my friend pointed out how similar it was to the East Side Pies theming. Our pizza came out super fast, though

Great pies! Excellent service! Pizza was fantastic place was clean! Enjoy the appetizers too!

Food always amazing! Service was good. Ambiance is interesting! We will return, and try something else next time.

I love this place! If you are looking for some new pizza combos, this is the place to go. If you are wanting plain pepperoni, or just plain cheese, they got you too! I make the 50 mile drive to get my son the Balance of Power. The San Martian is also a favorite of ours. The staff is always helpful and they all seem to have super cool personalities. Highly recommend this pizza place. And if you want a great salad I recommend their Strawberry Goat Cheese Salad, deliciousness!

Went back today because it's near my job and I forgot my lunch. Why is everyone so rude here? The girl with the blonde shoulder length hair who takes the food to the tables was very short and rude to me. Looked at me like I'm some kind of predator. Never coming back.

I just went in last week to try it for the first time. I asked the girl working at the front what she recommended that's gluten free. She told me all the special pizzas could be done gluten free. I went with the pepperoni and pepperoncinis and it was so good, the dough was thicker than most pizza places usually make them, and the manager that ran it to me gave me extra ranch and peppers. The place seems really clean and it had good vibes. If the gluten free pizza is amazing, I can't imagine what the regular pizza tastes like.

Balance of Power. Yup, once you've had it , there is no going back. Pie Society is our favorite pizza place in the area. Piping hot, thin crust pizzas, cold beer, the best pink lemonade I have ever had and consistent good service. They are also very family and group friendly. We will be back!

Freshly made for you every time! Calling in orders are easy and efficient. Always a great experience.

Great food and good value. Totally would be back for their pizza. Service is always good here.

Man this place hasn't changed much, in the best way! My husband and I got them to cater our wedding and still have people mention to us about the great pizza they had at our wedding, years later! We don't live close anymore but while we were in town with family we managed to pick up an artichoke dip and balance of power to go, the night before thanksgiving. Absolutely fantastic place, food, and service. Management was phenomenal for our wedding, and any staff person is very cordial and helpful. Still one of our favorite San Marcos eateries. Ps- very tidy, roomy, and clean bathroom! They had a clean and sturdy changing table in there too. Weird thing to note and take pictures of but as someone who has traveled with little ones I feel that's a great bonus.

Delicious pizza in a very cool environment. Unexpected in a strip mall near the Texas State campus! My friends had pizza, I had a calzone. Large glass bottle of Mexican Coke are always a winner for this group. Utterly fantastic music selection, nice friendly young staff. Fast service, seat yourself. Paper towel rolls for napkins. Perfect pizza place!

We so love this place we drive up from San Antonio sometimes just to get a pie or meet friends traveling through the area. They truly have the best pies. Yesterday we happened to be in town and stopped by. We ordered half Balance of Power and pepperoni and sausage. For the first time it came burnt. But being hungry and not wanting to complain proceeded to eat. Manager came by and ask how our meal was today and explained. Told us we should tell them so they can do better. Even though we were full he offered to remake for home. WOW! Where do you find service like this anywhere these days. Floored. And sure enough they made it right.

The pizzas from pie society are SOOOO GOOD. I used to work in a pizza restaurant like this one in high school and I feel right at home here. They have a small but good beer and cider selection too.

Pizza was delicious and staff was great! We took a basketball team and parents to eat here and they were so accommodating. Highly recommend and would definitely come again.

Awesome pizza and drinks. Great atmosphere. It's close to campus and easy to get to. Sometimes parking is tight but worth it.

While in San Marcos, you gotta visit Pie Society! Seriously such a great pizza spot. Wide selection of pies, starters, salads, and calzones. We went in for a couple slices and split the Greek salad and some garlic knots as well. Got The Pyramid (Garlic infused extra virgin olive oil, fresh spinach, ricotta, fresh mozzarella, Texas goat cheese) and the Balance of Power (Fresh spinach, spicy sausage, crushed red peppers & a touch of Texas honey) slices and wow they were both phenomenal! Everything we had was amazing. Great atmosphere, super friendly staff as well. Ordered a Live Oak Hefeweizen to wash it down because it's one of the best craft beers in Texas. Can't wait to go back and try more of their pies!

Excellent pizza. Crust crispy and toppings fresh. Meats tasty and veggies fresh. Good value.

SO delicious it's my favorite pizza place ever!! i've been going here for years and the pizza and service is still great. I love the outdoor and indoor seating options and the decoration is so fun.

Creative pizzas with obviously well sourced ingredients. We had the Texas Goat Cheese, Garlic Knots, and a large Balance of Power. All of it was perfectly cooked and portioned for the price!

The pizza is amazing! We shared a small 18 inch since the small is large. It was amazing Great job ya'll

Plenty of signature pizza options for vegetarians. We ordered the garden of Eden pizza and Greek salad. The shareable size is good for 3-4 people. I loved how the salad came out first. I personally thought the salad had a little too much dressing, but the flavors from the capers and olives was fresh and tangy. The pizza was served hot! It looked amazing. The crust is extremely thin, right up my alley. The tail end of the crust is flaky, almost like a croissant. I am not a big soda person, but my dad mentioned that they have a local brewery supply their fountain drinks and the flavors are very unique. The prickly pear cactus lemonade was tangy and good.

Ordered the 18" holy grail. Pepperoni and mushrooms. Live oak Hefeweizen on tap., What else do you need?

Definitely has the "college student hangout" vibe, but on a Tuesday night mid-June, the clientele was more reserved. Order at the counter (booze and food); pay or open a tab; and have a seat--everything is served to your table with a smile! Margaritas and Palomas were sufficiently strong and tasty. Goat Cheese appetizer would have been SUPERB if it had had a few more toasts (we had way more toppers once the toasts were gone) and if the roasted garlic had been all the way roasted (delicious but not even semi-soft). The honey on that goat cheese plate was delicious!! Pizza was exactly the right amount of greasy (not too much) and the crust was perfectly chewy-crispy!! Will be back next time we're in San Marcos!

Ordering is a little awkward. The fountain drinks are really tasty and refreshing. Seating and bathrooms are pretty accessible. Staff seems nice. I like the garlic knots, very big and fluffy and comes with marinara but you can also ask for ranch. Deserts come from a local business. I didn't get the pizza because I don't like thin crust pizza, but my friend does and she says it's good. Can get individual slices

Whole family, kids included, loved our pizza. We liked the option to buy a slice and will take advantage of that next time. Bbq was our favorite.

Always a good environment, friendly staff and quick and easy to order and enjoy your meal! Absolutely worth it

I love everything about pie society from the ambiance to the food! I go at least twice a week! I would recommend the el Diablo and the balance of power :) one of my favorite places in San Marcos!

Pizza is always excellent, our go to favorite is the "Justice" with House-made fennel sausage, New York-style pepperoni, local mushrooms, red onion & ricotta. Absolutely delicious. We have lived in Indiana, Kansas, Colorado, Florida and Texas. This is one of the best Pizza's we have ever eaten. The only comparable Pizza's would be the "Feast" from Pizza King, on Tillotson In Muncie, Indiana by Ball State University and The "Motherload" at BeauJo's In Idaho Springs, Colorado.

Went in hungry and left with an entire pizza. You can probably get by with one for two people.

Reliable pizza pies in a laid back atmosphere. Love going in to get slices and a drink. The staff is always super friendly and silly.

Tried this place after first moving to San Marcos. Got the 79-666 it was a real crowd pleaser with all. Also got the the justice. Amazing pizza with ricotta cheese. Pretty sure we found our new pizza place in SM.

Great slices. Love to come here when I'm trying to find tasty food my vegetarian friends can enjoy as well.

Decided to stop by Pie Society after seeing so many good reviews and hearing so many good things. I can agree with most other reviews on here that the pizza is delicious! They are willing to make dietary accommodations and have vegan and GF options. For me they even made my pizza half with cheese and half without since I am lactose intolerant but didn't want to buy two pizzas just for me and one other person. The pizza is good size and a good value for the quality of pizza you are getting. Staff was very friendly on the phone for ordering and in person even though they were slammed. Beer and drink selection was good and you are able to order a drink while you wait to grab your pizza to go. Ordering to go was about 1 hour wait. Would recommend to anyone wanting some good pizza and cant wait to go back!

Perfect! They were so clean, so friendly and the pizza was SO GOOD!! If I loved close I'd be in trouble!

After a long and endless day of shopping at the outlet malls in San Marcos, my husband and I drove the back way into San Antonio and stopped at Pie Society to grab some lunch. I called before arriving to make sure they had gluten-free crust and the girl that answered double checked to make sure they had some available. Once she confirmed, we headed that way and I'm SO glad we did! My husband ordered the Illuminati which is like a margherita pizza, he loved it (though he did wish they would've added more cheese, it had a few bare spots so you may want to ask for double cheese). I ordered the Justice which was so freaking amazing! The fennel sausage is CRAZY good and the local mushrooms took it over the top. And their gluten free crust is made fresh daily and is officially now my favorite gluten free pizza! I was so impressed. The strawberry goat cheese salad was delicious and I loved the garlic balsamic vinaigrette to pour on it, and I couldn't believe how inexpensive it was! I saw on the table that they have a happy hour where you can get a slice and a beer, so you may want to call for details. They have indoor and outdoor dining and a bar. You can even sit and watch them make the pizzas. I definitely recommend, I'm willing to take the drive from San Antonio to San Marcos anytime for this pizza.

Great pizza! I would have preferred a bit more spinach if I'm being picky, but the pizza was great! The young lady at the counter did an excellent job explaining the menu and giving us recommendations. Definitely give this a try over the regular take out places.

We've been happy with Pie Society ever since they opened years ago- best pizza in San Marcos! They have gluten free crust and dairy free cheese too!

My family of 5 got a 16' pie that was half Balance of Power and The Enlightenment. The pizza tasted great - a thinner crust pizza that has good flavor. We also got the Texas Goat Cheese appetizer and I found it to be super good. Instead of using the crostinis, I would spread the garlic and goat cheese on the pizza crust ends. Spent round $45 for 2 pizzas, 1 appetizer, and drinks. Will return if I am ever back in San Marcos.

Excellent customer service and the food was delicious! It was a very large to go order.

This was our first time ordering from Pie Society. As I entered to pick up our to-go order, I was greeted by several friendly and upbeat staff. My family thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and salads. Definitely recommend Pie Society!

Fresh ingredients, friendly wait staff. Got a cauliflower crust and it tasted like the real deal. Very good pizza place! And I'm from Chicago, so hard to impress for pizza.

We were on our way back from Big D back to Bulverde and were craving some pizza. Really enjoyed the atmosphere and the staff were very welcoming. Pizza was a solid 4 out of 5 and that 5 rating is a very tough rating to achieve. We would definitely do that again!

Pie society was amazing. The environment was chill and very appealing. The pizza was also incredible. I had the pyramid pizza and I fell in love.

My favorite pizza spot in the world! I always order half diablo, half pyramid. Diablo is the perfect mix if you like meat and spicy, and pyramid is just the perfect vegetarian pick! The freshness of the pizzas is amazing! The staff is always happy to help and like to spoil my dogs! The place has plenty of parking spots and even outside seating!