PieCaken Bakeshop - Shipping Nationwide on Goldbelly

At first glance it seems just like a cake, till you cut into and see its 3-4 cakes in one! And surprisingly it was delicious. It was shipped through Gold Belly from New York to Jupiter Florida and packaged perfectly. Definitely a highlight for New Year’s Eve.

I receive my order (through GoldBelly) of the red, white and blueberry PieCaken and it is inedible. When the bakery package it they did not include the dry ice. I paid $99 for this for my mom’s birthday and now I need to find something else last minute.

We got the original piecaken flavor. It was a cool experience. The flavors made a good combination. The icing could be too sugary. The apple spice cake (top layer) was a little dry. The salt was a nice touch. The dry ice was completely evaporated by the time we received the box. Overall, it was a successful merging of pie and cake!

If I could give zero stars I would. Gold belly came recommended to me so I paced my first order and it was a nightmare. I ordered bagels which were supposed to be overnighted. The showed up four days later in a wet soaked box (thank you ups) with moldy bagels. Customer service was awful and only wanted to give me store credit! Yeah right I will never use them again! When I said this was unacceptable they again offered me store credit. My credit card company was awesome and credited me back the charge. I would never recommend this company!

Beautiful Cake! I love the way it looks when displayed on the dessert table. The amaretto icing is divine. Wish I had the recipe. I was impressed with the level of care put into shipping. The cake arrived in a styrofoam container with packets of dry ice. It was frozen and beautifully intact. As far as taste goes, I didn’t get much flavor from the red velvet, and it was on the dry side. The cheesecake could have had more egg nog flavor, and the pecan pie was a bit off- strange texture, salty, and had an unexpected chocolate flavor to it. This is definitely the cake to set out for the “wow” effect!

Ordered the Christmas Cake that was a combination of red velvet cake, eggnog cheesecake and pecan pie. Absolutely the worst cake I have ever had. We couldn’t even eat it and threw it out. Fondant was hard and all layers fell apart when cutting. Pie layer was basically nonexistent and had no flavor. Aftertaste present. Can’t understand the high reviews. Horrible. Avoid.

I ordered a piecan cake for my sons birthday which happened to fall on thanksgiving this year, so this particular cake was perfect for the thanksgiving birthday! We really loved all of the layers and it was large enough for the entire family. I’ve read other reviews where people said their cake arrived defrosted and I can’t imagine how that’s possible… ours arrived frozen solid all the way from New York to Florida. I would trust this cake shop again for another holiday cake in the future!

So much hype around the Piecaken, and now so much disappointment. Had to try it. Ordered the Christmas Piecaken. Arrived on time, packaged well, instructions were thorough. The dessert was totally underwhelming. It was really hard to taste any of the flavors smothered in freezer burned frosting, and if it wasn’t freezer burned, it didn’t take anything like amaretto. So much sugar, and that says a lot coming from someone with a major sweet tooth. The best layer was the chocolate pecan pie, and that lacked in flavor. The cherry cheesecake was boring and the red velvet cake crumbled right out of the frosting. You’re paying $99 for the name, that’s all. It’s so tempting to try, but you won’t be missing anything if you don’t.