Katy C.
Yelp
I was tasked with finding a restaurant for my family of six that would take a last minute reservation for an early birthday dinner. I checked on Yelp and then Opentable - luckily Pietro's had availability for the next evening. I used to go to Pietro's all the time as a kid, but hadn't been in years. I was looking forward to checking it out!
We were seated right away at our reservation time and our server Jasmine was great. She was super polite and on top of water refills throughout the meal, as well as taking away empty plates, etc. Pietro's isn't fancy, it's more of a homey, comfortable spot, kind of like a local version of an Olive Garden. Their fettuccine Michael is their signature dish, which you can get for free on your birthday if you sign up for their free club. Unfortunately we were there on the day before my birthday, and Jasmine said that they actually check your ID to make sure it's the actual day. That's ok, because three of the six people in our party ordered the fettuccine Michael including Nate, so I got to try it :)
The menu is pretty large with lots of options for all. I went with the Northern combination, which includes a piece of lasagna, Tuscan-style meatball, grilled Italian sausage, and fettuccine alfredo. I wanted to try a little bit of everything so this was a great option. We also ordered two plates of the calamari to share, and they provide complimentary bread with olive oil and spices for dipping. Delicious! The calamari was not the best I've ever had and a pretty small size, but it was still tasty and the marinara sauce tasted super fresh.
Our entrees came out quickly and everything seemed hot and fresh. I really enjoyed my dinner but the sausage was a bit dry. It had a nice flavor though, with plenty of fennel. The meatball was actually not dry at all, and was tender and flavorful. Both the pastas were nicely done as well, the fettuccine alfredo needed a bit of salt but otherwise the flavors and textures were pretty spot on.
We were too stuffed for dessert but I'd definitely try their tiramisu next time. I think this place might get overlooked but it feels like a GR classic to me. I was impressed with the food and service and would go back again for lunch or to get my own plate of fettuccine Michael, which is super delicious and decadent!