Brett L.
Yelp
They stole paradise and put up a local music bar!
I dunno what happened. Been coming to the Pike forever! There was a time when I would actually make sure friends got to experience the Pike ... but something happened.
I dunno if it was the Pandemic or what, but it's no longer the great restaurant-bar that also had great live music on the weekend.
First, the food just started to go down hill last year, my wife and I, and our friends, just wrote it off to a new cook(a) that was/were still learning ... but it never got better. For example their signature dish, Fish and Chips, (the one dish you always told people to get) repeatedly came out soggy, certainly not crispy, the breading on the inside still not cooked, and the chips were hit and Miss burned! Other dishes just weren't that good either.
Then here a while back, someone decided to take better than half their parking lot, which was already full much of the time, and all of the western curb frontage and turned it into outside dining!
Try as we did a half a dozen times over the last 6 to 8 months, we could never find parking ... so we would give up and eat elsewhere.
Well today the wife suggested we try at lunch. Given it was 1:15 in the afternoon parking shouldn't be a problem, and it wasn't.
We walked in and "Whoah!!!" All but two booths, gone! Replaced by standing tables with barstools. Along the back wall the is now a running bench with really small tables (for drinks, not eating) an a single barstool. In other words, seating for three (max) with a table for two!
So my wife and I tried to sit in the one booth by the bathroom ... and actually started laughing! I am 6'2" and 270 lbs ... that was just not happening.
So we moved to the wall bench and bar stool ... my wife hated the bench, she said the seat felt 'short', pushing her forward. As for my barstool ... not only was I sitting lower than her, but the barstool is just high enough you can't put your feet on the floor, but there is nowhere to comfortably place your feet! So, it was off to the hard, bare-board, picnic table by the open front door, one of two inside.
Very disappointed now, we actually discussed just leaving and going elsewhere ... but we hadn't been able to eat here for almost a year ... so we stayed.
Sadly, we should have left. The food was horrible. It was the downhill slide of the fish and chips to rock bottom! Just this side of burned, not at all crispy, the breading in the inside raw, the chips soggy in the middle, crispy on the outside edges but only because they were burned. I am not kidding when I say the only thing right with my meal was the coleslaw.
My wife got the shrimp and chips and expressed the same issues with her chips ... she said the shrimp was cooked perfect except she held up 3 shrimp all died together as a single blob. But as she pulled them apart she laughingly said they were still good.
As we sat there and talked, we concluded they had taken the place and converted from a restaurant to a local night club. Which explains why their menu has been reduced to at least half the offerings and why they don't care if you can't find parking ... they only care about the 4th street crowd. Clearly those of use coming from across the city aren't their target customer base.
So sadly we agreed as we left we were saying goodby to a friend for the last time.
And both my wife and I want to be clear, the server was awesome, the Pike has always had great peeps working there as servers!