Brett F.
Yelp
Yelp does not allow me to give this the 3 1/2 that would be more accurate, but please understand that I think Pizza Bones is better than a 3 but not a 4.
With that said...
This is a pleasant place in Church Hill that basically does one thing--pizza. And it does an OK job of it. But this is pizza, and when you are charging $14 for a medium cheese pie, you need to be better than OK, because the competition is fierce.
The selling point at Pizza Bones is that the crust is made with sourdough. That may well be true, but I didn't notice any difference between their dough and a typical thin crust dough so I don't know that this is much of a differentiator.
Pies come in one size--the 14" medium. We ordered two--a double cheese pie and a double cheese and pepperoni pie. They came out a little overdone. A blistered crust is nice. A burned one is not as nice. Looking at the pies, it is almost as if the oven is not heating evenly or that the pizzaiolo is not moving the pies around as needed while cooking. The pies are also VERY greasy. I expect that (although not to this extent) with the pepperoni, but not the plain cheese pie.
Cheese and pepperoni were of very high quality. This did not taste likeover-processed food service "pizza cheese blend" junk. For pies that were ordered with double cheese, there was not a ton of the topping. I hesitate to find out how sparse a single cheese topping might be. That said, double cheese is only $1 extra which is very reasonable. The pepperoni was the smaller type that "cups" when heated. It was quite good with a nice spiciness. Unfortunately with the amount of grease from the pizza, the pepperoni cups were filled with oil which wasn't pleasant. More problematic was the very poor distribution of toppings. See the photo below. This is not how it is done.
Non-alcoholic drink options are FAR too limited--Mexican Coke, Topo Chico water, or Richmond City Water. We need some Diet Coke and other options. Not everyone wants to drink beer and wine--although nothing wrong with it if you do.
Look, it's an OK pizza. But at the price point they are setting, it just is not able to match the neighborhood's high-end pizza competition like Anthony's and 8 1/2. Don't avoid it but don't make a special trip either.