Pizza Plant Italian Pub - Williamsville

I've been coming to The Pizza Plant in Williamsville for over two decades, and they definitely deserve some love and acknowledgment! Consistency is the key here. Their menu has barely changed over the years, and that's a good thing. You always know what you're getting: quality, comfort, and great food. I especially love the "create your own pods and pizzas"-so many topping options to choose from-and "the grow your own salads"-let you customize your meal exactly how you like it. It's a fun and flexible dining experience every time. The booth seating is a major plus, spacious and comfortable, so you never feel like you're right on top of the next table. It's a great place to bring kids, too. They hand out little dough balls and coloring supplies to keep them entertained while you enjoy your meal. One quirky thing I love and sometimes hate is the wildly diverse music playlist. You might hear Bob Marley, then the Beatles, then some strange, completely obscure song that makes no sense-but somehow, it just adds to the charm and makes me laugh. The servers are always friendly and attentive, and it’s nice to see familiar faces—many of them have been there for years. There's also a nice big bar off to the side if you just want to grab a drink or eat in a quieter spot. Reasonable prices, reliable service, great for families, and always a relaxed vibe! After all these years, it’s still one of my go-to spots. Thanks, Pizza Plant!

Wonderful experience for my family and I. Our server was very helpful and attentive, the environment was very homey and comfortable. And of course our meal was amazing! GREAT prices for appetizers entrees and dessert.

4-13-25 add on… Can you please open up a Rochester establishment. Jesus, food is so good, and just did the sour power event!! Love the rare beers. And the Cinnabon bread pudding was so freaking good!! This is a place for Beer Gods!!! We come to Buffalo from Rochester just for their stout events. Just did the Imperial March of the Stouts, and man the stouts on tap you can’t get anywhere at else. Stars Wars and stouts?! Um yeah!! 6 different Bourbon Counties since 2019, and many others. Got an imperial stout from Sweden that was off the hook there. If you’re a Beer God make sure to be ready to drop some money cause they also have a huge list of bottles and canned beers you won’t find anywhere else. Oh, and their pizzas and desserts are insanely good. Also, do yourself a favor and get a beer club card! Oh, and their Pod City Italian ice sour and porter are insanely good!

We heard that they had good pizza/Italian food. We were there early at 5:30pm because of an earlier appointment. Just a few patrons were there. Nonetheless, it took too much time to be seated. I spoke to the bartender about seating ourselves at a high top table in the bar. He told me to go back to the vacant hostess stand and wait. She finally showed up and seated us, but without menus. After another wait, a newly assigned waitress came over after we attracted her attention. We ordered drinks and perused the overly complicated menu. That is never a good sign. The atmosphere was dingy and cluttered. Beer boxes were stacked against a wall. We decided to finish our drinks and leave after telling the waitress we received a call & had to be somewhere else. There was something disconcerting about this place. My husband regretted ordering an apple cider martini served with a dried piece of apple as garnish. He said it was awful.

Everything was perfect. The food was delicious and all three of us (picky people) liked our food. The milkshake was excellent. Our waitress Desiree was super attentive, upbeat, friendly, and just did an amazing job. Note: The Caesar salad is listed as vegetarian but the dressing contains anchovies

So nostalgic! Love that they were busy for an early lunch on a weekday. Sat by myself and the waitress and staff couldn’t have been nicer or more efficient. Chicken sausage pod was no nonsense and delicious as usual! Salad was also great as usual. It’s amazing how rare it is to get chick peas on a house salad but it makes the plant the best when I’m back in town! Keep it up for another 100 years!!!!!

Wonderful experience at Pizza Plant. Great service, yummy food and lots to choose from on the menu. Would definitely go back.

The Northtown Plaza location used to be so much better in the 90s. The Texas Torch pod was undercooked and the manager was unjustifiably hostile. I used to look forward to ordering lunch when I worked at Village Green Books and Monro. Had a problem with an order a couple years ago that was an oily mess, but it doesn’t seem like much has changed since.