Pizzi Farm Ice Cream

If you’re going by what’s posted on Pizzi Farm Market & Ice Cream’s Instagram, you may leave disappointed. Luckily, we were already in the area and didn’t make a special trip just for this. Their page advertises a variety of fall specials that look amazing, but the reality didn’t match up. The shop itself feels run down, and when I asked about the pumpkin cannoli fall specials the worker had to check with someone else to even confirm it existed—only to come back and say it was frozen and unavailable. I also asked about the caramel apple sundae, and again, there was uncertainty about whether it could be made. I pulled up a photo of their fall specials from Instagram and asked if they could make any of them. After checking the ingredients, the worker said yes, and thankfully, the sundae I ordered turned out to be yummy. The employee was polite and tried to be helpful, but the lack of knowledge and preparation was frustrating. I’m taking off stars mainly because I’m tired of businesses advertising seasonal specials that staff don’t know about—or worse, can’t make at all. None of the fall items were posted anywhere at the shop, so unless you bring up a photo yourself, you’d never know what’s available. Maybe things run more smoothly on busy weekends, but my main takeaway is this: stop advertising items you can’t actually serve. If the cannoli is frozen and unavailable, it shouldn’t be marketed.

Great place usually, but an interesting development ensued. We arrived Sunday afternoon to a long line. A 40 minute line. Now thats not an issue. I knew what I was getting into. It took us 40 minutes to get to the front. There were 4 windows “open”, but two hard working girls actually serving at two windows. Not a big deal. Again this place is good so you know the lines. Each lady was working diligently and they were super friendly and were super quick. We get to the front of the line and go left. The woman in fromt of went right. We start ordering. And we are at the second order and the woman who was in front of is and went to the other window went to the last window to the girl who was suppose to serve her and said can I order. And the girl said im busy. Ok so she walked away with a lot of customers to do something else. Hey maybe she needed a bathroom or a break. But with dozens and dozens of people in line she decides to start crumbling up cider donuts ina tub of cinnamon and sugar. And not just one. Cause maybe she needed one for the next order. But the whole tray, and then got some more donuts in the backroom. I dont know why at that moment in time those donuts had to he taken apart. Maybe she knew the next 15 people were going to order cider donut sundaes. We were really all surprised and the lady in front of us who was now behind was upset. Could have said im going on break etc… but no im busy. There was another employee somewhere in the back because he came out to help someone with propane right away. The ice cream is always good. The frappe isnt made out of a milkshake machine it comes out of a machine that just makes frappes. So you wont see balls of ice cream put ina cup with syrup. It was soooooo good. There isnt plenty of parking ever, especially with the pizza food truck but we always park across the street at theschool. It is handicap accessible. Easy to get to from 95. Plenty of flavors. Although ILL say if you know you’re this good and this popular probably working on staffing. Those girls were working hard. Will continue to drive there from Boston.

Good place for people who love sandwiches. They have a great selection. Lots of outdoors seating and plenty of parking. They have ice cream with lots of choices. Overall pretty good place. Call before coming, last time ice cream was closed in the middle of the day until 3pm. So call ahead to make sure.

The fact that they took heavenly hash off the menu is a crime….but the new flavors are pretty creative. Make sure you scan the QR code for flavor descriptions!

Enjoyed ice cream here. Friendly staff. Good choices. Can get busy but my experience they are always good with timing.

Excellent ice cream. I had the peanut butter cup ice cream with peanut butter sauce, and hot fudge. It was a rich flavor with peanut butter patties that were not too hard or not too soft. The ice cream was creamy but not too think, my daughter enjoyed her chocolate ice cream with chocolate sauce, and rainbow and chocolate sprinkles. Would go back in a heartbeat.

I HATE to give this place a one star review. But the amount of people who come here to get ice cream and then just smoke weed in their car is insane. I just want to get an ice cream with my small children. I don’t need to get suffocated by the stench of weed while trying to eat it. Maybe it’s uncomfortable, but you gotta start asking these people to leave. Also, maybe a sign “keep your dogs restrained” would also be nice. We all don’t want to pet your dogs people. They can be for you. They don’t need to be for me.

Stopped here for lunch. Great sandwiches all around. Big too. Most of us only ate half. Awesome market with candy and snacks too. Uber friendly service and fast. The guy making sandwiches was a machine. Great place.