Jessica R.
Yelp
Prime and Providence for Thursday dinner.
Ambience: 5/5
Service: 5/5
Food: 3.5/5
Price: 4/5
Lobstercargot: plated like a traditional escargot but it's tiny lobster chunks. Delicious in flavor, not sure it's worth $26 but this was probably the best dish, IMO.
Caprese Salad: if the Lobstercargot wasn't at the top of the list, then it would be their Caprese salad. I would love to see more caprese salads made like this one. Yummmm! The tomatoes were ever so slightly mealy, but the basil and mozzarella were spot on. Overall, it was delicious and we loved it.
House Chop Salad: I love a good chop salad, but I wasn't a fan of this one. The flavors didn't jive, and it was not a chop salad we enjoyed at all. The dressing, I think, was meant to be a vinaigrette but it was kinda creamy, kinda soggy, and we weren't sure what was all in the salad. What the menu said vs. what we got didn't really match.
Tuna Del Mar: fantastic! Medium rare tuna steak with mushrooms, it was fire and we loved this entree. The sriracha sauce is just enough heat and flavor, to complement this dish.
Roasted Seafood Tower: I waffled between this one and the Hearth Shellfish Mixed Grill and, in hindsight, I wish I would've gotten the Mixed Grill. The tower was disappointing. I asked for some clarified butter but otherwise, the seafood tower had no sauce and minimal flavor. Maybe it's me, but I love flavors and sauces and found this one so bland. Also, the tower comes with 4 seafoods: king crab leg, 3 half lobster tails, 3 colossal shrimp and 3 sea scallops. The scallops and 1 of 3 lobster tail halves were undercooked (2 were fine, 1 undercooked). The colossal shrimp and the half king crableg were perfectly cooked. I'm glad I asked for the butter, but found this whole tower bland and tasted like a burnt grill.
Oysters: might I recommend an oyster flight? I wanted them all, and ended up with none. Sad, I know. But I didn't want 6 of any of them, I wanted 1-2 of all of them! May go back to try just the oysters.
Broccolini: what a disappointment. It's sweet, I don't do (most versions of) sweet broccoli. We each ate one bite, I spit mine out and we left the rest. It wasn't good...actually it's terrible. Perhaps I'm a savory eater but the miso whatever brown blob was on top is not complementary of this vegetable.
Flowers Pinot Noir bottle: good choice, we liked it.
We plan to go back and try more items, but we know what we won't be trying again! For a $350 meal in WDM for 2 people, I do expect a little more quality than what we got. Service was fantastic, food runners were spot on, it's unfortunate that some of the dishes were subpar. -- at Prime and Providence.