Prime Pizza

Staff is friendly and polite but I was highly disappointed with my order. I had ordered a large. Pepperoni and garlic with extra sauce took about 10 minutes to get freshly made. When I got home I could see that the pizza was swimming in the extra sauce to the point that it was literally spilling out of the pie as you can see in the bottle left. We tried to eat the pizza anyway due to how much sauce was put on the cheese just rolled off the pie to point that only the dough was left. I have never had issues getting pre made slices before.but today I was very disappointed after paying 19.00 dollars for what was given.

Yo who cares it's in a gas station good pizza that is reasonably priced the way Pizza supposed to be hell yeah! Don't let the gas station fool you

Got a huge slice of cheese a huge slice of pepperoni with a free drink only costed me six bucks this place has the best pizza in Salem it’s hard to believe it’s located in a gas station in the point I think it’s time for them to expand and find a new location because where they are doesn’t give this place justice

The veggie pizza was missing half the ingredients listed on the menu.

Somehow has the best pizza in salem.

Gas station pizza. Truly one of my favorite slices around. Large pies or slices to go. Buffalo chicken is the best.

We love Prime! Moved from NYC 12 years ago and searched endlessly for NY Pizza. We finally found it at Prime. Great food and great service.

I do love this pizza but the guy doesn't show up for work on time. I've only had it when my gym orders it for events, but I can't seem to get it any other way. They say they open at 10:30 am (that's early for a pizza place), I call and call and no one answers. I drive there after 11 - he hasn't come in yet. I tried another day at noon - he hasn't come in yet. I went there a few days ago at 1:20!! He hadn't come in yet. One of the young ladies at the gass counter told me to come back at NOON. I reminded her that it was 1:20 (lol). I tried calling that same afternoon around 5 pm and the phone just rang and rang and rang and rang and rang...

Way too much salt on the cheese pizza and even on the steak and cheese sub. Guess I should have looked at the previous reviews and seen they were from years ago. Sub was manageable but the pizza I just couldn't do.

Surprising review for gas station pizza. It's what you expect inside, a convenient store with a pizza counter to the left. We ordered ahead and picked it up. There are no tables inside. They do pizza, pizza by the slice, and also do sandwiches. The pizza we ordered was finished quickly and actually had good flavor. The crust was soft, abundant toppings, and plenty of cheese. Well done!

Yes this pizza is from a gas station. Yes this pizza is delicious. And hell yes you should trust me!! Thin crust Italian pizza that won't disappoint !! Pumped about this find as you will be too!!

Flies are every where in this store they dont care about the Flies in the store and the Flies eating from a slice of pizza dont risk youre health buying from them

Hands down, the best pizza in Salem. With a thin crust and just enough cheese, it's probably the closest thing to NY pizza you'll get around here. The prices are great too!

Good stuff, solid price. Will return fool! yummy yummy in my tummy. nom nom nom nom.

Fabulous pizza great price. Friendly staff. Nice menu. Close early but working on being open later & delivery into Marblehead

Yes, I was skeptical at first (the last time I had a meal at a gas station, my stomach soon had a violent reaction), but this pizza is excellent. I've been there twice, and the pizza is some of the best in Salem, even when it is reheated. The crust is perfect--thin, tasty, and crispy and chewy at the same time. Good cheese, nice sauce--the perfect combination. And the price cannot be beat! I recommend the buffalo chicken and plain cheese. Not much seating, but great for takeout.

I love this pizza . I'm very particular about pizza. The crust is thin and a little crisp but still soft and chewy. The perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. No sweet Greek pizza taste. True Italian pizza. By far my favorite pizza in the north shore!!! Also the price can't be beat and the slices are HUGE! The chef is a really nice man who really cares about his pizza and customer being happy!

Well I don't know what happened, even though he doesn't have the ingredients I love ie: anchovies, (he claims nobody ever asks for them), I decided to get a slice of pepperoni pizza. He didn't have any made so he took a slice of plain, threw on a couple of pieces and threw it in the oven. To be honest it just was not good pizza. Nothing like what I had about a year ago. He's lost interest or some other issues are going on but his pizzas are just not good.

Best pizza in Salem, by far! Don't let the fact that it's inside a gas station fool you. This is fresh, made to order Italian style pizza. Great subs, pasta and calzones too! And make sure to try their fries!