Prime Pizzeria

We’ve always enjoyed ordering from this pizzeria, but unfortunately, our recent experiences have been disappointing. The first time, our mozzarella sticks were missing, and although we requested contactless delivery, the driver knocked and rang the doorbell several times while my husband was in the shower and I was putting our daughter to bed. Last night, we ordered the “pizza bread” with pepperoni, but it arrived without pepperoni and wasn’t toasted. We had also scheduled our delivery for 7:30 PM, but it was delivered at 5:45 PM instead. When my husband called, the response was simply that the pizzeria was very busy and they would call him back. Thankfully, we happened to make a quick stop at home during the delivery, as we were out trick-or-treating with our daughter—one of the reasons we had requested the later delivery time. Also, we did not receive a call back as they promised we would. We’re truly disappointed with these experiences and, unfortunately, will not be ordering from here again.

Wow!!! Stopped in there today for the first time. My wife and I started with a slice each. Amazing sauce and the slice held up great undercarriage no slump very crispy. Fresh ingredients I had the Sicilian and my wife had the Margarita. 10+ on both, took a Sicilian home. Owner and staff are great people, had a great conversation with them about the business. Must have type of place....

Just moved to the neighborhood and received a "Welcome to the neighborhood" mail gift. A free personal cheese pie. Turns out they changed owners ~2 weeks back (at the time of writing this 10/11/25) and suddenly do not accept the coupon. A wise business decision would have been to let me have the personal and if I actually liked it - probably would have came back for more. But now this place is ran by someone who clearly doesn't care & just wants to make a quick buck. You're in New Jersey - there are plenty of other pizza places on the same block. You're better off.

This has easily become our favorite pizza place in town, so we decided to order from Prime for our family holiday party and once again they did not disappoint! Food is incredible and customer service is unmatched. Thank you Prime for putting a smile on all of our faces with your delicious food!

My takeout order was delivered to the wrong address and the people accepted it fully knowing it was not intended for them. So rude! Im sure my name and address was on the receipt. I paid by credit card and when I reached out to the owner who is new to Prime he would not refund my order or send a new one. Mistakes happen but in the service business you need to satisfy your customers. That is what keeps them coming back. Needless to say Prime has lost the business of a loyal customer. I will give out to shout out to Annie that works there who did her best to make things right!

We all wanted pizza on Labor Day and everyone said let’s try the new place just opened . We called in our order for their supreme pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Place was very busy and lots of people inside eating and coming to pick up stuff. The owner and his crew were working as fast as they could to get everyone their food. Pizza smelled fantastic on the ride back . Opened the boxes and they looked as good as they smelled . They tasted fantastic ! All the toppings were nicely chopped and mixed into the pizza on the supreme. There are a lot of pizza places in the area and we have tried them all. Will definitely be back here again.

I ordered a “medium” cauliflower crust pizza (the only size available, apparently) with a few toppings. It cost me a whopping $35, and I almost canceled the order at that point but I figured I’d get a couple meals out of it at least. Nope! It was barely bigger than the size of my hand. Not a medium, barely a meal for one. And to top it off, it took over TWO HOURS to deliver this stupid snack-sized pizza, and it honestly tasted like crap. I called twice during that wait time and all they could say was that they were busy. Extremely unimpressed.

We were in town for a funeral and after a couple of grueling days, wanted a bowl of "comfort food." Being vegan, I called Prime Pizza to ask if their tomato sauce had cheese and was assured it was vegan. I mentioned pasta primavera, which is not on their menu, and was told to please come in, they would create something for us. Our big bowl of pasta had very generous portions of fresh broccoli, mushrooms and carrots. The sauce was flavorful and delicious and the veggies were perfect. It was just what we had hoped to find. Owners/employees---the staff--couldn't have been kinder. Highly recommended!! Oh, and Sinatra playing in the background was great!

This is by far the best pizza in the area. I can't comment on any other food they serve because I haven't had it. If you don't think this is the best pizza place in the area, you probably also think dominos is fine Italian dining. Since trying this place I haven't gotten pizza anywhere else because it's not worth it. The crust is thin and crispy the way pizza is intended to be. Pizza crust shouldn't be an inch thick, we're not in Chicago here. The sauce is good but doesn't taste artificial like half the pizza places in the area.

Fantastic pizza! Just got a couple of slices and a soda for less than $10. Thin crisp crust that supports a fold. No droops. Taste is legit. Nice, big slices. Friendly staff. They know what they're doing here. Will definitely be back.

AHHHHHHH-mazing!!!! Formerly from NJ and one thing we always miss is a good Jersey pizza. Just dropped our son off to school in VT and had to satisfy our need. Stopped in here based on the reviews and it did not disappoint! We talked with "The Boss"......... he told us he's new management. He and staff were great! Recommend!

Delivery took 3 times more than they said. Food was cold when arrived. Never going to this place again for sure

This review makes me sad to write because for years Brooklyn Pizza- as this place was called under previous ownership- was our go-to place. Best local pizza by far. Under new ownership it's taken a nosedive. The pizza we got last night was awful. Too thin (we didn't order thin crust but got it anyway). Seriously overcooked to the point that we had to throw out the leftovers because reheating them would have meant basically eating charcoal. So much oil it took multiple paper towels to sop it all up before it was edible. And then it just didn't taste good. It was just eh, like every other pizza place in the area. It's so sad because this place used to have GOOD pizza, not just edible pizza. Now it's just bland and disappointing like every other pizza shop. We have ordered probably 5-6 times since the change of ownership and each time it's been progressively worse than the last. Sad to say we will not order from here again.

Amazing pizza and even better service! The owners are so kind and ensured we had the best experience!

Passing through town on a long road trip and had to have some pizza. A quick google and Yelp and we found this place. We were greeted with a warm welcome by the owners (two brothers) despite half of our party in pajamas (it was an early morning start to our long drive). Pizza was made fresh, kids got to watch, toppings were plentiful, and sauces were full of flavor. They threw garlic knots at the end- which were out of this world. Genuinely impressed!

Yes, I know "pizza" is in the name, and their pizza is SUPERB! But my wife and I enjoy eggplant, sausage, and rolls/wraps. Their white pizza was generous but not top heavy. A great crust, too. Their eggplant roll is exceptional! Lightly fried eggplant with lots of mozzarella in a light crust. My sausage roll (I added peppers) was delicious, and the peppers were FRESH. Great salads that don't overdo the onion and marinara sauce that is fresh and not sugared or oily. Delivery folks are courteous, and deliveries are on time. Good job, Brooklyn Pizza & Kitchen! And I ought know, because I'm originally from. . .BROOKLYN!

Came back after some time and just not as good. Graded on a curve because it's a Friday night but cheese had that yellowed look like it's cheap cheese. Wanted it to be great like last time but just wasn't.

Excellent food , great customer service and the staff members are very friendly. Seating is limited but very comfortable and clean facility

They make a solid Sicilian pie. Thick and plump with a crispy bottom. Will need to try some of their other menu items soon.

ordered a silcian pie on Friday worst pizza I ever had I was very surprised since this is my go to pizza place and everything I ever ordered was delicious

Was out of town and drove by and decided to stop in for a couple slices. Excellent NJ /NY pizza says this guy who lives in Hartford, CT! Thin (but not too thin) crust that was crispy. Cheese and Saudi had an excellent flavor. I just ordered 2 plain cheese slices but some of the specialty pies they had out looked awesome. 2 slices and a Snapple were $5.85 very fair. I was in and out quickly (took it to go) and the place was clean and seemed well run. Friendly to boot so they've earned my 5 star review!

Awesome authentic pizza and delicious burgers! Clean, friendly service. Love this place!!!!

Best pizza in the area. Was spoiled with close proximity to great pizza prior to moving to this area, tried em all, this is my go to. One Request: Update Slice app to include delivery to Ringwood please!

Food is really good. Portions have shrunk. I order the same thing often. It's now getting to be about 1/2 the size of when they originally opened. Still good food, a bit pricy, but isn't every place now?

This pizza is LEGIT. Benny knows how to make some seriously good pie. Just knowing this place exists makes me happy. Any time I'm in the area, I make sure to stop in for a large pizza or a sausage roll. Everything I've had is great - the dough, the sauce, the cheese...it's all just perfect. Thanks for keeping it real Benny, I'll be back next time I'm in Jersey.

When I read the reviews I was hoping that we had found a new pizza place locally instead of needing to drive to Brooklyn to my husbands old stops. Basically, this pizza is fine, not great not bad but not something I'd go out of my way to get.

Tried it for the second time today and still not impressed the pizza is average at best but then again I'm spoiled with NYC pizza greats!!! On a side note my bougie dog loves the crust!

This is the best pizza spot in town. Whenever you stop in here, the place is spotless and you can tell they are just cleaning constantly. The owner really takes pride in the restaurant and everything being consistently sanitized and clean. It makes me feel better to know that my food is being made in a clean environment. All of the workers are really nice and communicate well. We recently ordered an Everything pie for delivery and it was delicious! I felt like the price was a really good value for what we received. The toppings were plentiful and perfectly layered on the pizza and the crust was crispy and golden. The delivery is super quick from my personal experience and the food comes fresh and not destroyed and soggy like some other restaurants nearby. I would definitely recommend Brooklyn pizza to anyone !

Definitely the best local pizza we have tried since moving to the area. We don't order from any other places anymore since discovering this place. I will say we ordered today and it wasn't great, pizza was too thin, and a little tough as a result and had about 75% of the cheese it usually does. Sauce was still good and assuming this was a one off because usually it's very good. Maybe a new guy in the kitchen or something. Pepperoni roll was good. Also thinner than usual but not as noticeably as the pizza. Traded our usual broccoli roll for a broccoli calzone and won't make that mistake again. Entirely too much dough (also rolled too thin) and not enough "stuffing" to go with the excessive amount of too thin dough. Overall we love this place and really hope tonight's experience was a one off and not the new normal.

Good pizza, period! Yelp wants me to write more so, ghjkk borer hujjf Fredrick fghhg d

MAMMA MIA NOW THATS A PIZZA!!! I love this pizza! fresh ingredients and made to order this is a great pizza place!

This review is long overdue. The first pie I had from BP&K was good. A, maybe, better than average NY/NJ slice. I liked it. But then I ordered the grandma pie. This is a truly great, in my top 10, pizza. The light crust, tasty sauce, garlic and just the right amount of cheese make for pizza Heaven. I like mine a little extra well-done and Benny always delivers. I've eaten there, picked up, had delivery, and used BP&K for a large party. They're always friendly and their service is above and beyond. Give it a try!

This was our first time ordering from Brooklyn Pizza and kitchen. We order a grandma pizza, and a margarita pizza with a side order of mozzarella sticks. Everything was delicious. The order came on time and we are looking forward to ordering again!

Excellent grandma pie! It's about time that someone makes a pie with flavor and quality, amazingly full of fresh ingredients, plum tomatoes, garlic, basil, cheese and the crust was crispy, tasty and just soooooo good. The price is decent also. The owners are so accommodating and kind and I couldn't wait to get this pie home. We loved it and can't wait to visit again and try the upside down sicilian. They take pride in pleasing you, try it out!!!

Yummy but everytime I go here, the lady was not really that friendly. Smile a little bit you know.

Hands down the best Grandma Pie in North Jersey! Salads and pastas and other dishes we've gotten from here are great too! So glad to have this new go-to Pizza place in our town!

Family owned. This guy works hard and does a great job. Delivers as long as the roads are safe. Pizza is really good. Full kitchen menu too. Reasonably priced right in town too.

I truly enjoy eating at Brooklyn Pizza & Kitchen. The ingredients are fresh and the food is made to perfection. The grandma pie is delicious and totally recommended if you are looking for a good pie! The owner is also very nice! I love having this pizzeria a block from my house !

Coming straight out of Brooklyn, this little pizza place is spot to go if you want some New York Styled Pizza. Pizza is the only thing I get here, because it is so damn good. Thick Crust, warm and not to greasy cheese, and tomato sauce that makes you smile. I would try something else, but right when you walk in, it's pretty hard to miss the smell of pizza in the oven. Costumer Service here is great and the workers here are super friendly. So when your looking for that amazing pizza to bite on, why not give Brooklyn Pizza a try?

Nothing but nice things to say about them. We now order quite frequently and are always happy. Have confidence in their menu. Delicious!

Great pizza & great service! I stopped by for a couple of slices today and was welcomed with a warm smile and great conversation. The pizza was delicious but the Sicilian pie was outstanding. I'm going to have to come back soon to grab a couple of pies!

Best Grandma pie in North Jersey! Their ingredients are always fresh and their regular pizza isn't bad either. I'm not a fan of greasy pizza and their pies are perfect. They stand out among the many pizza places in the area - highly recommend!

We went in for a quick bite just to try it out but we will come for more. The sauce has great flavor and not bland at all. The owner Benny says it's a recipe passed down from his father in law that owned a pizzeria in Brooklyn in the 1970's. Great family place and great food! Family owned and friendly!

Delivery Beware. Accepted my order. Processed payment. Told food being prepared. 1 hour later, restaurant closes. No delivery. No response from the store. Incompetent.

I've been in Haskell for about 4 years and just discovered this place a couple of months ago.. my buddy told me about it and he grew up with an old school, awesome cooking, Italian mother.. needless to say I'll take his recommendation.. best pizza in town!

Having tried several local pizza spots since moving to the area, Brooklyn Pizza and Kitchen is definitely my favorite. Not only does everything taste fresh and delicious, but the delivery is fast (most times even earlier than they estimate!), and the owners are friendly and customer oriented. Don't be surprised if you see the owner drop off your order if the delivery boy is busy or not on duty yet. Their prices are also fair and portions- generous! Give them a try and you won't be disappointed! Our favs include marguerita pizza, calamari, Greek salad, and penne vodka. Bon Appetit!

My fav pizza place in town. Their philly cheesteak is also delicious! Aside from the food the service is great as well!

I eat a ton of pizza and this is the best pizza in town now. The pizza has a perfect crispy crust with flavorful sauce and cheese. The sandwiches are delicious. I can't recommend it enough.

Kids love the pizza there. Asked them to write happy birthday on the box and they made it much nicer than expected. Thanks!

Great restaurant and I usually get delivery but the food is pretty good. They are very accommodating and they even have this amazing dessert - Nutella pizza which is just God sent! Were trying out but a good local pizza joint overall.

First order ? Combo special --- eggplant parmigiana dinner ??? Not real eggplant some kind of patty --- awful ! Pasta average Sauce --- I have had much better ! Antipasto--- average cold cuts blah Dressing for antipasto--- too little! Garlic bread fair ! All in all an $18. Dinner could be much better ! The eggplant was by far the most disappointing! Absolutely horrible!

Ordered the Grandma pie and hands down the best, fresh tasting pizza I've ever had. The fresh garlic on top really makes it pop. I live a good 45 minutes from Brooklyn Pizza and I would drive that far to eat here again and again. The best the best the best. Run. Go. Now

This is my go-to delivery spot. They have consistently provided good food and great service. The food is delicious. I have tried their Plain Pizza pie, Chicken Cutlet sandwich, Greek Pasta salad, Chicken Parmesan sandwich and a few different wraps. Have not been disappointed. I have another pizzeria literally down the street but I'd always rather order from Brooklyn cuz of the quality of food and no delivery fee!

Had this place last night and it was very good the pizza was awesome the wings were amazing the garlic bread was good nice people there definitely would go back

Great pizza and wings. Nice selection of other food. Staff is polite and friendly. Pick up or delivery options. Highly recommend. Give it a try.

For me it's the best local pizza. Great taste and always delivered hot. I use the Slice app. for ordering.

This place is awesome.Amazing food.chicken parmigiana is fantastic. And their pizza is out of this world. So flavorful unlike some places I the area.Owners are so friendly

The pizza has to be the worst pizza I have eaten in quite some time. Ordered 2 pies, took 90 minutes to get to me and it was stoned cold. After heating it up the oven my whole family tried it. After the 1 piece no one wanted any more. Horrible food, horrible service. You can roll the dice and try it. GOOD LUCK