Prince Street Pizza

Some of the best deep dish pizza you will ever have with high-quality toppings. Service is definitely not the friendliest and they do take their time, but I’ve never once been disappointed by the pizza. It stays very consistent. I highly recommend the naughty pie, which has pepperoni, a few cheeses like ricotta and then a honey glaze on top. It’s open late so makes for some great post bar food. Super pricey $45 for 1 pizza but I’d say it’s well worth. My picture is just a slice which I think is $8. I’ll never stop coming it’s that good.

Very clean and delicious, a man with beautiful braided hair will always help you there. Unfortunately my favorite pizza was not ready for tonight and I had to buy only two slices.It's always worth trying.

The pizza was ok but I wish the white cheese pizza had more salt flavor, it was bland. And the pepperoni slice tasted sweet which didn’t sit right with my taste buds. I wish this restaurant had tables to sit at so I didn’t have to walk just to sit somewhere and eat my pizza.

It was really sp delicious, i love them Hot Honey , and it was great serving with THIFANY she’s so awesome

Called in an order and was quoted 30 min and it was ready on time from when we arrived 28 min later! Only issue was the green machine should have came with black olives but it was still very delicious without it! Kinda awkward asking for a tip over the phone, you gotta experience the service before you get a tip! All in all I can’t wait to come back I love plain cheese so I can’t wait to try the 4 cheese… see you in October! Unless you come to Arizona!

Originally from back east, square thick crusted pizza is called Sicilian. Out here there are very few locations that make this. I worked in a pizzeria for many years and made Sicilian pizza. The process is more involved than a simple hand tossed pie. You have to put the dough into a pan. Let it proof, then par bake it. The crust needs to be just right and Prince Street gets it right. The sauces also carry a lot of weight in the pizza flavor, we would use a different sauce for Sicilian than we would for hand tossed. The taste is there with the different sauce options they provide. It costs more, but the quality is there. If you want a cheap pizza, go to Costco, there is very little flavor in that pizza. If you want good flavor, spend the money. Go to Prince Street.

I have been to a few different locations and had prince st pizza. It’s solid choice, I enjoyed all the slices I have tried. I do prefer their square slices but solid all the way around.

Can’t wait to try! I’m a New Yorker living in PB and Santa Fe, NM. My neighbor turned us on to your pizza. Question, shouldn’t the instructions on reheating say before eating? I’ve given 5 stars because I KNOW it’s gonna be good!

Beachfront deep dish just hits different Thick, buttery crust, melty cheese, and the sauce was so good. 10/10. Shoutout Morgan for the recommendation and great customer service!! Thank you!! Great pizza + ocean views = best day ever!

Got a couple square slices and a original veggie slice. Girl at the counter was helpful and fast to get my order. It's clean and set up to order and go inside. Conveniently close to the beach They have a lot of options and I was trying to do a neat free day after literally eating an entire rack of ribs at Phil's

This is one of the rare places I would consider 6 stars! I can confidently say this was one of the best pizza experiences I've ever had. The mouthfeel of their pizza is unreal -- perfectly crispy on the outside, soft and airy inside, with that ideal balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings that just melts together in every bite. The Naughty Pie is flat-out delicious. The crust alone deserves recognition -- and I'm someone who usually doesn't finish pizza crust. Here? I didn't leave a crumb. It's that good. The Spicy Spring is amazing as well. It definitely brings heat, but it's the kind of spice that enhances the flavor instead of overpowering it. A nice kick without being painful -- just balanced and bold. And the Meat Lovers? The sausage is incredible. You can tell the quality is there. Every bite is packed with flavor. It's no surprise there are numerous celebrities on the wall who eat here. I was recently at a comedy show featuring Gabriel Iglesias, and they brought in a stack of Naughty Pies for him -- that tells you everything you need to know. If you're anywhere near Prince Street Pizza, do yourself a favor and stop in. Five stars all day.

How long has your pizza been sitting in the glass case? It looks several hours old and even reheated isn't gonna look good. I'm very disappointed after loving what I had in New York City from you.

You got to get the naughty pie, what a slice! I've been to the original location on prince st nyc near nolita and I can confidently say that this spot is just as great and by the beach! Service and food is great but please note it is outdoors standing room only to eat the pies on the ledges outside the shop. The vodka slice is so a good shout if you want something a bit more minimal

Been wanting to try this place for a while now and it was so yummy! Highly recommend the naughty pie, the hot honey complements the pepperoni and vodka sauce so well. Also highly recommend getting the pie double cut so that the square slices are more manageable and easier to eat. I ordered online ahead of time and the time estimate was fairly accurate. Some standing room outside the restaurant to eat while hot, otherwise pretty close for beach access as well.

I tried the Downtown location a year ago and it was amazing. I tried the PB location tonight and it was not good at all. It was basically bread w/ a little sauce and barely any cheese on top. The crust was tough as well. Just not what I experienced at the DT location.

For what it represents this was just okay. The dough was a little thick and not as crunchy as I thought it would be. The toppings tasted fresh though

Was brought here by a friend of mine and he wanted me to try this pizza to get my take on it. Walking in they got a pretty good system. The employees are very nice, and engaged. The cleanliness could be a little better but not the worst I have ever seen. Now in regards to the pizza. I got the meat lovers. Crust is very good but the sauce used seems to have a sweet tang to it which is not the kind of flavor I would prefer in my pizza. But that is always up for interpretation. If you have a taste for a sweeter or wanna try a new kind of pizza, recommend this establishment to you.

STILL the best vegan slice in town! My wife and I were in PB a couple weeks ago for the Christmas parade -- we were starving and decided to stop by Prince for a vegan slice. They did not disappoint! The BEST!

So...I was at the OG one in NY about 3 weeks ago, and had a slice of their regular cheese (Long story, mix-up with my Brother on what I wanted) and it was just ok. I really wanted their Spicy Spring Slice so I made it down here to the SD location to try it out. I had my buddy and my kids with me. We all enjoyed it! I went with a slice of the Spicy Spring and a slice of the Mercer Margherita. My son got a slice of Meat Lovers and my daughter got a slice of cheese. How were they? Spicy Spring- This was the one I originally wanted at the OG one in NYC. Finally got it here, and it lived up to the hype. Great thick, crispy crust, LOADS of pepperoni. It was a mighty fine slice! Loved it! Mercer Margherita- This slice was a Grandma style slice. It had a super sweet sauce and some fresh mozzarella. Thinner than the Spicy Spring, different, but pretty damn tasty in its own right. Kids liked their Meat Lovers and Cheese Slice. My buddy liked his Spicy Spring and the other one he got (forgot the name). Staff was friendly as can be! No seating, but they have lots of space out front on the deck to post up on the railing and eat and watch the folks of PB go by. Would definitely come back. Not really "cheap" ($30.00 for 4 slices of pizza), but quality is good and taste is great!

I love Prince Street the pizza is always so fresh and the service is so good! The naughty pie has been my favorite ever since I tried Prince Street. I got to meet Isabella and she provided extremely fast service and was super welcoming!

Great customer service! Isabella is very sweet and helpful! Pizza is great and great location as well!

Isabella was the absolute sweetest! Always coming back to this Prince St! Their pizza and service is spectacular!

Amazing food and service by Isabella good food. Favorite is four cheese and sunset square

I arrived a little after 9pm on a Monday. Sign that slices may take a minute due to the slice oven having some issues. Man, that sucks. Girl at the counter was super friendly and attentive as there were a lot of people waiting. I ordered a meat lovers, a hot honey and pepperoni and a spicy marinara with pepperoni and they were all different and delicious! I think we agreed the Meat Lovers was our favorite. The ambiance is really for grab and go or to quickly munch a slice before you head back to the beach!!! It was so good my husband is back for another slice today and we've visited the one in NYC! So excited for this to be here.

SO GOOD!!! i got a slice that included spice, vodka sauce, and pepperoni ( i believe it was called the naughty pie) and it was genuinely incredible. my boyfriend got the margherita slice and it was also good, but i definitely recommend getting a slice with the vodka sauce on it. definitely come here and try the pizza!!

Unbelievable experience. While I was standing at the counter ready to order, the young man working there completely ignored me so he could continue a conversation with his friends. It took far too long just to be acknowledged. After finally placing my order, I was very disappointed to receive a pizza that was cold. I had been looking forward to trying this place, but unfortunately the experience did not live up to the expectations. Honestly, frozen pizza would have been a better choice. I hope this feedback is taken seriously so future customers have a better experience.

Isabella has amazing customer service !!! And the pizza was so amazing too!!! She was super nice and helpful and it was my birthday so she made my say :)

Hands-down, best pepperoni pizza in the area. The crust is fluffy and the pepperonis are so delicious, they're small and turn up to make little crispy cups, a bit spicy and perfect. I had come into their downtown location once before and the pizza was so delicious that when I had friends over, I decided to order delivery and it was so so good!!

SHOUTOUT to Charlie and Isabella! Incredible staff and always incredible food! Love it here

This is my 2nd time here and the first time I couldn't rave more about it. The crust was crispy and delicious and was telling everyone I saw they need to get down there. I did not post yet because I wanted to take a 2nd taste and this time ehhh less impressive. The pizza was a little old tasting and the crust was floppy as well as the entire slice. Not sure if it was enough to bring me back again but man was that disappointing..:the offer garlic powder to sprinkle on which I like. I also had the square pepperoni and it was decent but I came for the original..my guess it's been hanging out all day. Gave 7/11 vibes this time..only one person working so maybe just not enough customers to try today..

Honestly, some of the best pizzas I've had in the area. I was actually really surprised it was still open pretty late, which was nice after going out that night. Highly recommend and you really can't go wrong with the type of pizza you choose.

ABSOLUTELY LOVE PRICE STREET I'm a New York style type of pizza lover but Prince Street did not disappoint in the slightest. I've had the Naughty Pie and the Meat Lovers pizza here and been going here since I've recently discovered that it's the perfect place to go on a Friday and Saturday night. The place is normally packed due to its popularity and unfortunately does not have any seating inside. You see all the pizzas on display, pick the one you want, and they put it in the oven for you. It comes out VERY fresh and hot every single time without a doubt. I would highly recommend the Naughty Pie it's DELICIOUS. I don't know how I haven't written a review yet as I've been here for the past year but it's something you HAVE to try!

After trying the OG Prince Street pizza in NYC, i've dreamed about the Spicy Vodka slice ever since. I was excited to try the SD PB location but it fell just a bit short of my expectations. All Prince Street locations are busy for good reason, but this one is a zoo. We ordered our slices to go and ended up missing the ranch and 2 slices that we paid for. We noticed the ranch quickly and were able to get that, but we were so eager to get out of there, that we didn't notice the missing slices. The phone line was also busy or disconnected, so we couldn't call to ask for a refund. Definitely a bummer... the slices were good, but I probably wouldn't go back to this location. $40 for 6 to go slices of which 2 were missing just wasn't worth it.

I contacted the business as requested and their idea of correcting the issue was a gift card for next time I'm in the area since it was outside of Uber Eats refund window. I did what I was supposed to do by contacting the restaurant by phone and email right away. They told me they would have my refund processed and didn't. They now want to offer more food from a place that I refused to eat from the first time when I don't even live in the state. Once again, they are no longer responding. I didn't want people thinking that they actually take care of customer service issues.

Surprisingly very good pizza for someone who doesn't like pizza. We had the meat lovers and classic cheese. Something about the sauce is amazing and and whole pies feed only 3-4 people so beware. It's very pricey for pizza but actually one you want to eat!

My pizza was literally just bread with sauce. It was disgusting. It had no flavor. Nothing about it was appetizing. I could've just went to a little Caesars and had a better experience.. Definitely not worth the money, pizza is one of my favorite things to eat and unfortunately, this was so far from being it. I will definitely not be returning again! The two stars I gave are for the customer service. I thought the person in the front was very nice, but it's not his fault. The food was not appetizing. We still ended up having to go and pick up something else to eat. Nobody wanted to eat breadsticks with sauce for dinner. Save your money and thank me later.

I always have wanted to try this place after hearing good reviews but it was very disappointing. Slices sitting out for who knows how long even though they're put in the oven when you order. $7 per slice too is crazy. Taste and quality wasn't that good. I wouldn't come back.

Pizza was just raw dough!!! I waited 20 minutes past my pickup time all to receive an expensive pizza that is just cold raw dough. :( Drove 30 minutes after work for this pizza. Terrible.

This was my first time trying this place. I'd seen alot of reviews on TT and was curious since I love deep dish pan pizza style with cup pepperoni. The location is in a very high traffic area in PB, we parked several streets down in a residential neighborhood and walked to the spot. Upon entering it seemed kinda quiet and lonely and the pizzas in the window looked a tad old and maybe had been sitting there for a while. I wasn't super impressed by the looks and almost changed my mind. I was really in need of some food and decided to try it to satisfy my curiosity and hunger. My son ordered a square slice with cheese and I got the meat lovers, pep & sausage. Took a few minutes to warm up and then we dug in. Added some Parmesan and garlic powder. We took it outside and ate on the little ledges that are outside on the patio. There are no tables or chairs, it's mostly for takeout. We ate all of our slices but we weren't too impressed. I felt like they needed more sauce and the pepperoni and sausage didn't have much flavor. I'm glad I had added the garlic powder. The crispy crust was good and hearty but not super tasty. I probably wouldn't go back. The guy taking orders was super nice and friendly but the food I think is way overhyped.

No one answered when I called. Then they send this pie... sauce petty non-existent. For the price point they should never went a pizza out looking like this.

Not sure how people are rating other than a 5. Outstanding pizza - hits the spot at the end of an evening. I like that they have a couple spicy options to choose from, a lot of variety. Don't expect to go a sit down, but if you're looking for a by the slice place it doesn't get any better.

This place is terrible. I asked for two vegan slices of pizza and asked the young woman to please use a clean none contaminated spatula to pick up my slices. This woman continued to wipe the used spatula off on a towel and proceeded to pick up the vegan slices. When I asked her if she knew what she had just done, she looked me dead in the face as if I was stupid. This place lost our business forever. Incident just happened in real time on 03/13/2026 at 5:46pm.

My first Prince Street Pizza experience was delicious! I love all the variety of flavors and crusts. You pick your slices then they heat them up in the oven. We didn't have to wait long. I had the Boozy Broome and Mercer Margherita. Both the square crust and traditional slice were delicious. I tried my friend's grandma slice too which was a thicker square crust. I can't even put it into words. All the crusts are crispy, but not burnt. They're just perfect. The flavors of the sauces and toppings are spot on too. I would recommend and return! I do wish they'd ask if you are dining there though because it seems wasteful for each person to get a big box instead of a plate.

I have been to the NY, LA, and Miami locations, so when I saw they had opened one in Pacific Beach, it was perfect, as one of my friends is a huge fan of pizza as well! I ordered two slices; 1 of the Naughty Pie and 1 of the Mercer Margherita. Both were very good but my favorite was definitely the Naughty Pie one. I love how Prince Street Pizza uses the thick pepperoni cups and the hot honey added a very unique sweet twist to the taste which I loved! Outside, they had plenty of room where you could stand and eat your pizza. It does get packed late in the night, so I would keep that in mind when coming.

No wait during store open on a weekday. Got one corner slice of the margherita and it was delicious! The crust had a nice crisp and airiness. The tomato sauce was super flavorful without being too acidic. The slice was a bit too small for the price but all in all, it was decent. Would come back to try their other squares or even round pizzas.

Like most humans we eat a ton of pizza. We have had good pizza all around this wonderful world and we were told to check Prince Street out while in Mission Beach. The price made me nervous and heightened my expectations. And here I am telling you is one of the best pizzas I have ever had. We will be lifelong customers and drive to the other side of town of. Vegas.

Small space but the food is amazing. When we walked in we were greeted my the gentlemen behind the counter. I had my mind set on a spicy vodka slice but they were out. We did go towards the end of the day so that just means we have to go again! The slices are the perfect size and the sauce is 10 out of of 10! The while time were there the place was non stop with customers! We will be going back to try the rest you can't beat service and great pizza!!

It took a few minutes to get the order since there was a small line, but overall it was worth it. Solid spot if you're craving pizza near the beach.

We stumbled past this place when we were visiting the beach in PB. I remembered a place with the same name from the last time I was in NYC, and this turns out to be owned by the same people! We each tried two slices, and they were nothing short of incredible. My hands down favorite was the "Naughty Pie" with hot honey - you simply can't go wrong with this one :-) Highly recommended!!

Great pizza spot for a night out. Always hopping. Don't sleep on a Monday night slice . Shout of my girl Tiffany she was the nicest.

Delicious pizza! Square slices and traditional triangles. Whether you want a slice or a whole pie, they've got it for you but absolutely no ranch or ketchup lol Glad I dropped by after visiting the water and Belmont. Parking was easy. Service was quick and excellent. The place is clean. I'll be back for sure.

DO NOT SLEEP ON THE SQUARE PIZZA! The marg square pizza is my girls all time favorite

I love Prince Street Pizza and on my last trip to San Diego I saw they had a location here so had to grab a pie! I tried the naughty pie which was delicious and extra cheesy with the ricotta. It's definitely a richer pizza but well balanced with the delicious pepperoni and vodka sauce. Not as punchy as the spicy pepperoni pizza but equally as good.

I would get the naughty pie over and over again! I can't stop thinking it!! I went on a Sunday afternoon and it was not busy at all! The person working the front was very nice and had great recommendations. I heard it gets pretty busy late at night but during the day it's a perfect time to go! No line! The place is relatively small inside however, there is plenty of outdoor standing space to eat. I finally got to try this place and it was definitely worth the hype. I can't wait to come back for another slice of the naughty pie and to try other slices!

Hard to go wrong with Prince Street Pizza. The viral popular pizza from New York City has landed in PB. They actually use a machine to change the pH levels in the water to match that of brother Hudson River, which is why their pizza dough tastes so much better than other places in town. If you haven't yet, go get your slice!

A perfect place by the beach to enjoy New York style pizza. These pizza's are so yummy and they have lot of varieties available even for vegetarians and vegans options are also there. My favorite is Merger margherita, crust is so crunchy and cheese is so fresh. Their slices are bit costly thought and full pizza take a lot of time and it's always crowded and busy, so many people always waiting in line. It is a worth try experience if you love new your style pizza.

LOVE LOVE LOVE Prince St. Pizza! I've always been a fan of flat crusts for the crunch, but the crust of their deepdish was perfect and the entire pie sent me straight to flavor town!! Don't get me wrong, their thin crust pizzas are also really good! I was just surprised at how i fell in love with a thick deep dish type of pizza. I usually try to order online because of how busy they get too. VERY excited they're bringing a shop to OC! I no longer have to drive 2 hours for the holy grail of 'zas. Thank u Prince